Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Boohoo the poor menz: a BBC report on why men's feelings should be equal to women's in the abortion debate

275 replies

ByGrabtharsHammarWhatASaving · 29/08/2019 12:38

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-49240582

"Men are usually involved in an abortion in one of four ways, all of which can leave men traumatised when they come to reflect afterwards on their roles, say those running counselling groups for post-abortive men. Sometimes men coerce a woman into having an abortion against her will; others say they will support the woman's decision either way, while steering that decision toward abortion. Some men find out about the abortion for the first time after the fact, or the abortion goes ahead against their wishes."

Speaking as someone who was coerced into an abortion I didn't want, I couldn't give a fuck how traumatic it might be for him to later "reflect" on his actions. One day he'd be saying it was all my choice and he'd support me no matter what, the next day he'd be making plans to move country if I had the baby, the next he'd be threatening to use his contacts at social services to have the baby removed from me and saying he'd take full custody if I went ahead, then the next day he'd be bringing me gifts and begging me not to terminate. Shockingly that was quite a lot to cope with whilst also studying full time and experiencing such extreme morning sickness I could hardly think. Shockingly I decided that wasn't an environment I could justify bringing a child into. When I went for the surgery, because I was 11 weeks by the time I decided, he begged to be allowed to come with me, then never showed up because he decided to go shopping for a new BMW instead. I never heard from him again, but I lost the next 3 years of my life to severe depression over the guilt and regret I felt. I seriously and frequently considered suicide. I engaged in very high risk sexual behaviour in the hope of contracting some terrible STD which I felt was what I deserved. I went to the doctor several times but was rejected for help each time and told to basically get over it as it was "my choice". I was offered a single counselling session by the NHS with a woman who told me she "only really knew about miscarriages" and suggested I just make a list of pros and cons to look at when I felt sad. Ultimately I dropped out of university because the course material focused often on pregnancy which I found too upsetting. Many years later I now have 2 children but I still cry to think of the one who isn't here. So I don't give a shiny fuck how the man who got me pregnant feels now.

At the same time another friend I knew became pregnant by a man who was abusive to her but for religious reasons didn't want her to terminate. He would turn up to her house in the middle of the night screaming at her that she was a murderer. He made her life a living hell, but because of her termination she was able to finish her degree, leave that relationship, and is now happily married and professionally successful. So I don't give a flying fuck how the guy that got her pregnant feels now either.

""Men are meant to be protectors, so there is a sense of failure - failing to protect the mother and the unborn child, failing to be responsible," says 61-year-old Chuck Raymond, whose 18-year-old girlfriend had an abortion in the late 70s when he was a teenager."

I don't give a fuck, Chuck.

"He likens the mental and emotional anguish that can follow an abortion to battlefield post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)."

Post abortion stress syndrome isn't even a recognised condition for women yet, you know, the people actually trying to make the life changing decision in the midst of morning sickness, social pressure, and often male coercive control. The ones who actually have to choose between giving birth and raising a child, or going through an often traumatic medical procedure. And I don't believe for a second that these poor "traumatised" men actually wanted to raise the baby themselves, it's all about not being able to control the woman.

"It's changing now, men are fed up," Ms Bonopartis says. "Men had bought into how they have no say in this and that if they speak out, they are against women, but now the impact is being felt by more and more of them as the repercussions of 45 years of abortion are being seen."

FUCK. OFF.

FUCK OFF FUCK OFF FUCK OFF

I don't care if men are fed up. I don't care how sad they are, or if they feel emasculated by not being able to control women, or if they feel like being made to pay child support somehow gives them part shares in women's bodies, or if they think that they are the natural protectors of children and women (despite being their number one killers) and should therefore be allowed to "protect" a fetus by forcing it to be born to an unwilling mother when 9/10 times they have no intention of caring for it themselves. I don't give a single fuck and I am so angry that the BBC has run this "sympathetic" article which basically says men should be allowed to have a say in women's medical care. Men can state their preference for an outcome, fine, and they're allowed to be upset if that preference isn't followed, but they have no right, not now and not ever, to expect their preference to be given equal weight to a woman's.

So, fuck off BBC. Fuck off Alabama. Fuck off all pro forced birth people but especially pro forced birth men. Fuck off to my ex and to my friends ex, and to the exes of all the equally traumatised women I met in the one solitary non religious (i.e you need forgiveness) post abortion support group I was able to eventually find online because no one gives enough of a shit to form one in real life on behalf of women. Fuck off to anyone who thinks the decision over what happens to a woman's body should be in the hands of anyone but the woman herself. Fuckity fucking fuck off.

OP posts:
Kit19 · 29/08/2019 15:59

If men really dont want children then wear a condom and dont expect women to take all the responsibility but wait what's that I hear? Its the wailing of men saying
"but iiittsss nooootttt aaaasssss sensitive when i weaaarrr a connddooom boohooo"

I am so sick and tired of men wanting power over women's bodies. My body, my choice, that's it

Im with the OP, they can fuck off

MaximusHeadroom · 29/08/2019 16:03

Well said OP and Flowers for your awful experience.

Everytime we get a step on the ladder, there is a hard done by man wanting an extra 2 rungs added to his to make it fair.

omgomgno · 29/08/2019 16:08

I think men can be part of the conversation but ultimately it's the woman's choice and his job is to support her.

LonnyVonnyWilsonFrickett · 29/08/2019 16:12

Men are usually involved in an abortion in one of four ways, all of which can leave men traumatised when they come to reflect afterwards on their roles...

How about getting involved in a fifth way bloke? How about having mature, considered discussions that recognise this is not your decision, offering unconditional support, and getting the fuck over yourselves? I think that might solve some of your PTSD. For fucks sake.

Under his eye.

PS I actually think it's good that these things are reported...

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 16:16

Men have two solid choices available to them if they don't want to deal with pregnancy/abortion:

  1. celibacy
  2. vasectomy

Funnily enough, many men won't take these options and would prefer to keep having penetrative sex with women and running the risk of pregnancy every single time, even if it's a minuscule risk, the whining about 'what about MY rights?'.

I'm also with OP.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2019 16:37

'what about MY rights?

What about your responsibilities?

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 16:38

Errol - are you asking about my responsibilities or those of men?

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2019 16:43

Oh sorry, I meant the idiot whiny men!

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2019 16:44

( I enumerated some of the ways they should be responsible upthread)

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 16:47

That's what I thought you meant but I wanted to be sure - we're on the same page.

Soubriquet · 29/08/2019 16:53

I do get why men feel they should have a say as obviously it IS their baby too

However, it is 100% the woman’s choice as it’s HER body that is dependent on that foetus growing, and then it’s usually the woman who takes a break in her career to raise the baby.

I did have a friend who desperately wanted a baby with his girlfriend but she went to have an abortion.

He was crying to me about how “he would have raised the kid” and “she didn’t have to do anything”

I was quite naive about pregnancy then, (I have had life changing problems from pregnancy), but he still fell out with me for a while when I pointed out that she needed to carry that baby and deliver it before he could step in and therefore it was purely her choice

Lumene · 29/08/2019 17:03

Agree with Soubriquet.

I am pro choice but that doesn’t mean men have no feelings or they shouldn’t have the right to express their views.

Jicole · 29/08/2019 17:06

I think men needed to be included in the decision of abortion as it their child also but it is ultimately down to the women as it her body, her choice. And I think some men can have SIMILAR post- abortion upset HOWEVER women unfortunately have the burden of making that decision so we have to live with that and we also are the ones to go through the pain, emotionally and physically. And I also think it's a different conncection for woman as the unborn chill is literally inside us so it just feels different. I remember feeling empty after my abortion because there was something inside me that was now missing, and my partner never had to feel the physical and emotional void. I think we need to be considerate of everyone feelings involved, Male or female but this is ultimately effects the woman a hell of a lot more.

SomeDyke · 29/08/2019 17:07

If men don't want to suffer the terrible psychological effects of getting someone else pregnant, they should either not do PIV, or wear a condom. Simple. Or wank off and blub over the poor lost wrigglers, that men have been doing since Onan.

beagadorsrock · 29/08/2019 17:09

Just watched that Dave Chappelle Netflix special that got panned by 'journalists' who use the word Ter* liberally - seemed all right to me, muted in fact on his social observations. But he had a massive go at men wanting a say on abortion (tempered however by the MRA-ish 'but then we shouldn't pay if we didn't want a baby').

madcatladyforever · 29/08/2019 17:12

When they can push babies out of their own orifices they can have a choice.

thebogwitchisback · 29/08/2019 17:16

I couldn't agree more!
Well said!!

PicsInRed · 29/08/2019 17:47

If these guys have so much whinging time on their hands, why don't they go tells their mates to pay adequate child support? And not the bare fucking statutory minimum either. Marriage or no marriage, relationship or no relationship. Oh and encourage an interest in caring for the children BEFORE separation, not just when child support comes due. Hmm

No?
Ah, well, fuck off then.

Gingerkittykat · 29/08/2019 17:47

An Alabama abortion clinic is being sued by a man after his girlfriend had an abortion at the six-week stage, against his will in 2017. The case is the first of its kind because the court recognised the foetus as the plaintiff and the father as the representative of his baby's estate

What the actual fuck?? A non viable foetus the size of a pea has an estate?

Giving men a say in abortion would be a fantastic way of an abuser to trap and harass a woman for the next 18 years.

There was a case in Scotland a long time ago, maybe 20 years, where a man tried to stop his girlfriend from having an abortion in court. Of course it was thrown out but I never want anything like that to be possible here.

silverystream · 29/08/2019 17:49

They are allowed their feelings. They are allowed to communicate them (as long as they don't harass) However, they should not be allowed to compromise women's bodily autonomy.

GroggyLegs · 29/08/2019 17:50

I don't think anyone is saying men shouldn't be sad if their child is aborted & they wanted the mother to carry it to term.

I think we're saying,

  1. act responsibly in the first place & don't have sex with people who don't share your desire for a child.
  2. Go & discuss your trauma with other men, instead of making women responsible for male feelings all the time.
  3. Women should absolutely NOT be coerced into carrying unwanted (by them) children because of men's hurt feelings. The hurt feelings are not a factor. Feeling angry that you can't force a woman to have your baby is not a factor.

Harsh though it feels to voice it, men have no say in this. End of.

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 17:53

An Alabama abortion clinic is being sued by a man after his girlfriend had an abortion at the six-week stage, against his will in 2017. The case is the first of its kind because the court recognised the foetus as the plaintiff and the father as the representative of his baby's estate

It's always Alabama, isn't it? Leading the way in undoing the reproductive rights women have fought for for years.

Get fucked, Alabama.

BarbaraStrozzi · 29/08/2019 18:01

Everything you said in your OP is spot on.

Men: Is it your body? No? Well, don't have sex without the consent of the person whose body it is, and accept that if you have consensual sex, there is a risk (no matter how hard you try to mitigate it) that the woman will conceive - then she, and she alone, gets to decide what to do about it.

Also Men: Yes, you can feel hurt about her decision. Feelings are feelings are whatever they are. But. No, you don't get to use those feelings to try to guilt trip her into making the decision you want. That's the point at which you can fuck right off.

ShortCircuit181 · 29/08/2019 18:14

I agree that it should ultimately be the woman's choice but nor sure all the anecdotal stories really 'prove' anything.

nevermorelenore · 29/08/2019 18:21

Jesus, all these whinging men should read this classic Reddit thread where someone stopped their girlfriend from having an abortion, promising to look after the kid, then realised that having a child is actually really fucking boring and tiring and wants the ‘deadbeat mom’ to help out.

www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/5b79z4/nm_i_got_a_girl_pregnant_and_she_wanted_to_get_an/

I feel like if men actually had a say in abortion that this would be the outcome in a LOT of cases.