Roussette
A poster made in my opiniona very dramatic take on what could have happened.. I know it was just a version CoffeeC!
It involved three people (two adults and an older child) ganging up (not my words) on Charlotte who was 3, being unkind. scolding her, calling her babyish compared to an older child, and this ganging up made Charlotte cry. I then said it would be surprising to send flowers if that toxic situation had happened.
I'm getting very tired of being (wilfully) misinterpreted.
It is NOT my 'take'. I have read this version but unfortunately cannot recall the source. I've looked - I have tried - as I know MN people like to say 'Can you post a link?' If I find one, I will. It was well over a year ago, but I have not imagined it, cooked it up from some kind of Kate-fan-girl fantasy or made it up maliciously.
I wouldn't have posted it because (like so many things on here) it's hearsay. It may be true, or it may not. But it's as valid as other versions as far as we're concerned because we weren't there. I put it up because I was exasperated with the blind acceptance of Meghan's version.
My main point to MN posters is this one: please consider that Meghan has told her 'truth' very many times and publicly. We haven't heard the other side - such as Catherine's version. Cannot people see how unfair that is? C is not allowed to respond. God - I know how angry that would make me, if someone told the world I was a bitch and I had to just keep my mouth shut. You need both sides if you're going to make any kind of judgement, and I'm amazed that anyone is happy to accept the story told by M at face value. Critical thinking, people!
And as for the people who can't believe in the scenario - I've seen that type of situation myself. Child is a bit whingey, other parent says something like 'Oh dear - what a silly cry-baby! That parent's child seizes the opportunity to join in and low-level bullying ensues. It happens, so while I'm not claiming I witnessed this, the way it was told really rang true with me. It's NOT an unlikely scenario on that basis.
I hope I don't have to go over this again!