@JamieJ93
Hello, I've been reading the puppy survival threads for months (as I have a 9 month old rascal pup) and have been following everyone's stories, including yours and Milo's.
Having read your posts today, I really feel for you.
The majority of us on the doghouse, myself included, will feel for Freddie too, and no-one more so than you! He's had a hard life and could become so much happier with your family. Most of us will be rooting for Freddie to have found his forever home with you. But most of us, if we're honest, either aren't willing or aren't able to do what you're doing for him.
You say Milo saved you from the lowest of times. You've also mentioned that he's obsessed with Freddie so has less time to be cuddly towards you -that sounds hard too.
Many of us on here are here because we're struggling, at least sometimes, with our pups. Most of us would really struggle to take on Freddie too. What I'm trying to say (maybe badly) is please don't be hard on yourself if you're feeling similar. Your intentions are pure (as are most people's) but you're struggling with the practicalities and, damn, I think we all would be too.
I know it's not simple though. You feel for Freddie and you want him to feel safe and happy, as he deserves to be too.
It sounds like he's been neglected before he came to you. Perhaps a lack of socialisation in his early months could have led to much of the fearfulness too? The fact that he's 8-9 months old but not at all house trained suggests to me he's not had much human interaction until now and may have lived outside in kennels?
Yet he sounds like a resilient, essentially good natured dog too.
Only you can decide what you want to do, knowing what you know now.
If you decide to keep him, for what it's worth, I 100% believe you will be able to house train him in weeks. You already know how to. I think his other problems will very likely greatly improve. He will likely bring you unique rewards. But please do not allow me to influence you either way, or to make it sound easy, it's not me doing an ounce of the work. You are doing it all.
If you decide you can't keep him, Freddie will be OK in time, you'd make sure of it. You'd be no more "guilty" than me or anyone else who's unable/unwilling to have him, no matter how much we desperately want him to be happy too. Of course I'm rooting for Freddie as much as anyone else on the doghouse (except you of course!). But here's the important bit. I think the vast, vast majority of us, myself included, are rooting for you just as much and more too.
I created an account to say that but am unlikely to keep it open for long just because I don't usually post on any social media. So please dont take it personally if I don't reply more on here.
You're in a difficult situation, caught between wanting to help Freddie and wanting to be happy too. I hope you find a way to do both. Whatever you do, please do be kind to yourself, always. Take care x