i think the judging is a bit - meh.
For the pattern challenge: can they understand the pattern instructions, is the construction basically all in the right place, with topstitching, sink stitching, hems etc all in the right place. Are the buttons/ties on the right way. Was the type of fabric right for the pattern.
Are the seams bouncy, are the points all turned well etc etc. And then maybe colour choice and general look of the garment.
For the (in its current form) transformation: does it look very different to how it started, did it use as much of the transforming stuff as possible, is it able to be worn, taken off, go to the loo etc
for the m2m: does it fit the brief, does it fit the model, is it technically excellent (see above), right fabrics? and so on.
i should take over from Esme!