The fact that jumps out at me is that the "kidnapper" wrote a 3 page ransom note and got the pen and paper from where it was kept and PUT THEM BACK in the right place!
That was mighty calm kidnappers, kill a child hide the body in the basement, then calmly write a note with 3 people sleeping upstairs! And also have 2 other attempts at writing the note.
I think it was a cover up by the parents. I think the child came downstairs stole a bit of her brother's pineapple and in a fit of rage he hit her with the torch.
Torch was in pictures of the crime scene but subsequently disappeared. Maybe the dad disposed of it when he was allowed to go out for an hour by himself.
Also the mum said she took the sleeping girl up her room from their car and straight to bed after their day out. No mention of her waking and eating the pineapple!
Also if you received a ransom note ordering you to tell anyone, would you call the police AND 2 couples and your pastor??? Who all came round?
The mum changed her story as well, first she said she went into the child's bedroom and saw she wasn't there then she said she went down the stairs first, read the note then checked the bedroom.
I think the moment you realise your child is missing is burnt in your memory! I remember every second of losing my son in a shopping centre for 5 minutes and that was over 35 years ago!!
There so many more oddities to this story.
The whole thing is nuts.