Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

X factor - Give your early predictions on who will win the games here! (Combined Thread)

447 replies

Flamebat · 28/10/2006 22:10

How's that for a combined thread title??

OP posts:
MrsFish · 12/11/2006 12:06

I thought Leona was amazing, I have just been watching it as was out last night. Not seen Robert yet.

I thought Ray was very good although I see Sharons point about not knowing whether he would sell albums or not but he is by and far the best entertainer.

I like Eton Rd - agree with Simon on alot of the points he made, but still think they are good.

MrsFish · 12/11/2006 12:09

Agree entirely with JoolsToo - best three were definitely Ray, Robert and Leona.

MerlinsBeard · 12/11/2006 12:15

I have that about Ray too Flame. He is very good at what he does but there is just no longevity about it, its already dull for me at least and i quite like swing! X factor is about versatility which he plainly hasn't got.
He is a good performer though i will give him that.

Eton Road will not win, they are too unpredictable but they will have a good career at the end of it, Ben will make it to last show but won't make final 2 - same reasons as Ray. Leona should win as she has a talent that is already up there with Kelly CLarkson and Christina Aguilera but with no training - imagine what shes capable of! Robert is a dark horse though, he is quite an excited performer.

McDull are exactly the thing that grates about x factor, its a popularity contest rather than talent

I knew i should have avoided all x fadtor related threads!

MerlinsBeard · 12/11/2006 12:16

I have that about Ray too Flame. He is very good at what he does but there is just no longevity about it, its already dull for me at least and i quite like swing! X factor is about versatility which he plainly hasn't got.
He is a good performer though i will give him that.

Eton Road will not win, they are too unpredictable but they will have a good career at the end of it, Ben will make it to last show but won't make final 2 - same reasons as Ray. Leona should win as she has a talent that is already up there with Kelly CLarkson and Christina Aguilera but with no training - imagine what shes capable of! Robert is a dark horse though, he is quite an excited performer.

McDull are exactly the thing that grates about x factor, its a popularity contest rather than talent

I knew i should have avoided all x fadtor related threads!

MerlinsBeard · 12/11/2006 12:16

whoops sorry

JoolsToo · 12/11/2006 12:34

I disagree about Ray - Michael Buble, Jamie Cullum seem to be making a good living and Frank Sinatra didn't do too badly for a 'one trick pony'. He may not make into the Pop charts but that doesn't mean he can't sell albums.

At the risk of repeating myself, Shayne Ward was outstanding last year but where is he? To be really big I think you have to be able to write your own songs - as Will Young does and Lemar - otherwise your pop career may be rather short!

Flamesparrow · 12/11/2006 12:39

Jamie Cullum bugs me too . None of the new ones seem to have that rich power of voice like Sinatra...

JoolsToo · 12/11/2006 12:39

I don't like Jamie either but does have his fans

DelGirl · 12/11/2006 13:54

I love all the big band stuff, but I don't like Jamie Cullum.

turquoise · 12/11/2006 14:12

I don't like Jamie Cullum. I'd rather hear the old originals, although Harry Connick is ok.
I don't like Ray much but thought he gave his best performance last night. Louis should be shot for giving Eton Road such a crap song.

anniebear · 12/11/2006 15:01

dont have a fave, but Leona was outstanding yesterday and really deserves to win. She is much better than any of the others

Wasn't sure about Rays performance! He has got better singing but not sure about that dancing

and I wish they would ALL STOP CRYING!!!!! the sad 'feel sorry for me votes please' before the songs....ugghh!!!!

anniebear · 12/11/2006 15:02

yes, why on earth did Eton rd do that song?

and the squeaky bit in the middle was awful...boring!

I usually like them lots

makemineadouble · 12/11/2006 15:34

I'v always loved x factor but this year it seems to be "battle of the judges" all spiting eachother? does'nt seem to have much to do with the artists?

Leona is in a class of her own,Ray makes me smile but then I love all that swing stuff, Eton road will do well anyway now just needed the break, Robert deserves to win just for his nerves of steel and sheer determination I enjoy it and it makes me angry but I'll still watch it

anniebear · 12/11/2006 15:41

although good last night, Robert doesn't do a thing for me

can't stand his frank bruno voice

makemineadouble · 12/11/2006 16:06

Knew he reminded me of someone lol

PennySweets · 12/11/2006 22:50

Sad to see Nikitta go, I really liked her. It's true, Leona has got an amazing voice, but you know what? Methinks she's a bit dull. Can she do anything really upbeat? It will be interesting to see on 'disco' night if they do that this year. Robert proved last night that he can do ballads as well as uptempo faster paced songs. Also, it's nauseating the way Simon fawns over Leona every week. That one man standing ovation... what a knob. Used to really like Simon, but he's becoming really annoying. I'm becoming more convinced that there's some horizontal jogging going on with him and Leona.
Ray should have gone, in my opinion. He can't do swing every week. Nikitta proved that she's more adaptable.

makemineadouble · 12/11/2006 23:16

Penny I thought that but thought it was just me?!

I feel that this time more than ever you can tell it's Simon's show (money I mean)

He's so up his own! why do women bow so easily? do we all like bad boys? everytime after he's been mean my girlfriends say Simon was so right! maybe he is? and I'd like him not to be? even with all that "I'v made a choice, no I'v changed my mind! I'll save Ray" I think he knew he'd say that all along. He'll go with Leona she's gonna make money after this show.....

BTW I think Andy Abraham's second album is so much better then his first

Flamesparrow · 13/11/2006 07:37

He had already written off Nikitta by chosing that song. He knew he had to lose one and chose her.

Westlife next week... does that make it boyband week??

MerlinsBeard · 13/11/2006 09:41

This year X factor is more about a platform for bands to advertise their albums than it is about the singing.

Waiting to see an Ad for double Eglasias as we have already had best of albums from Abba, Tony Bennet, Rod Stewart and Lionel Richie

MrsMills · 13/11/2006 09:54

But the Macdonlad Brother? Why is anyone voting for them, they are just awful imo.

purplemonkeydishwasher · 13/11/2006 10:00

I think simon's interest in Leona is more than just financial. He's a lech.
and poor nikitta. he picked piss songs for her. didn't take any interest in her really.

MrsMills · 13/11/2006 10:04

Perezhilton is raving about Leona

Flamesparrow · 13/11/2006 12:40

I'm getting to the stage of wanting to vote for McDull to show just how rigged it is!

sofaslug · 18/11/2006 19:57

I LOVE LOVE LOVE the McD's - they make me smile, so professional and so, just, lush...

Am worrying myself now

CountTo10 · 18/11/2006 20:00

I thought a lot of them were bad tonight - in fact I was disappointed by the whole thing!! I do love eton road though!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread