Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Remember Me

345 replies

susiedaisy · 23/11/2014 21:16

Anyone watching?

OP posts:
Noyoucantwatchpeppapig · 24/11/2014 11:17

Brilliantly creepy, bit worried I'll have to wuss out before the end. Think that the photos are the key as Michael palin had turned them all face down and they move.
The dream within a dream was clever too. That has occasionally happened to me (minus the scary lady) and its really disorientating Confused

ProfYaffle · 24/11/2014 11:18

Oh, and the creepiest bit for me was when the tap stopped dripping when the care worker opened the door to the house.

TheBiscuitStrikesBack · 24/11/2014 11:21

I had an awful night sleep and still can't get the creepiness out of my head, but am desperate to know what is going to happen.

ginnycreeper5 · 24/11/2014 11:34

The dream within a dream was clever too.

I've had those dreams as well. You think you've woken up, but you haven't.

Shock

It was clever touch to put that in.

BamBam21 · 24/11/2014 11:35

Loved when the 2 oldtime music hall men in the photo doffed their hats to the care worker!

Showy · 24/11/2014 12:11

Bam, I actually laughed out loud at them doffing their caps! DH was waiting for the woman in black in the street scene photograph to get closer/turn round.

I wrote two of my dissertations on gothic horror, particularly involving children and this is absolutely packed with gothic tropes. Weather, corridors, spooky photographs, children, the sea, ageing, the unknown, innocence, the foreign/other, dreams, coincidence, repetition. So far it's avoided being clichéd and is using the tropes as they should be used. I hope it continues like this and has a good, meaty, plausible central conceit. If it goes all ridiculous and silly shock horror, I will be very disappointed.

We were saying the other night that we need a good spooky Christmas lead in. I even mentioned Whistle and I'll Come to You as the sort of thing they need to bring back. Looking forward to the next two Sundays now!

Showy · 24/11/2014 12:21

Oh and DH gave the policing side of things a thumbs up. He gave up on Broadchurch because of the unrealistic representation. Apparently Mark Addy's character being dressed down by his boss was like any day in the office. Grin

BamBam21 · 24/11/2014 12:44

Showy I thought the woman in the photo would move as well!

It's such clever casting to have Michael Palin in the lead role I think. He is so lovely and well loved that people are rooting for him before it even starts, and we would be sad if anything happened to his character, and shocked if he turned out to be evil. Makes it all the more powerful imo.

foofooyeah · 24/11/2014 12:53

The other thing I noticed is the 'womans' hand in the photo was slightly deformed - either burned or had a finger missing. I think this might be key.
Also there was a picture of her in what looked like me to be India.

Spooky and atmospheric: loved it.

Panicmode1 · 24/11/2014 13:35

I've just watched on catch up - the sun is streaming in to the house but I found it terrifying even in daylight!! Not sure I will be able to watch the next one - will have to watch the thread instead Wink.

ProfYaffle · 24/11/2014 13:51

Showy I was expecting the woman in the photo to have vanished!

BamBam21 · 24/11/2014 13:56

I read a short story years ago, where a girl is given an old photo of the house she has moved into. The photo shows a woman walking down the road outside the house, and over the next few days moves closer and closer until you can't see her anymore. She has gone inside! Anyway, the girl does some research and finds that this woman was hanged for bludgeoning her husband to death. And then the girl starts to hear footsteps coming upstairs, and her bedroom door opening.....!Shock That was a story in a book I got from the

Tanith · 24/11/2014 14:24

There's an MR James story like that (he wrote "Oh, Whistle and I'll Come to You, My Lad") called "The Mezzotint" where the creepy thing in the picture has moved every time it's viewed.

diddl · 24/11/2014 16:31

I'm just braving it!
i'm sure that when we moved into our first house that same carpet was in the hall 7 up the stairs!

LeopardInABobbleHat · 24/11/2014 17:34

I settled down to watch it this morning thinking it would be all comfy and Sunday Night Drama.
Then the thing unfurled in the water before the credits............

It was very MR James, but that's no bad thing.

girliefriend · 24/11/2014 18:38

The bit that has stayed with me since watching it ystd and gives me the shivers every time I think of it was when the social workers corpse shed a tear Shock

meltedmonterayjack · 24/11/2014 19:32

Did anyone notice that one of the photo's in his house was either in India or what I thought might by Moscow? It looked like St Basil's Cathedral? And there was a woman (taken from behind) in the picture? It showed that pic twice.

Also think the old, pale woman in the care home is linked to the mystery as she looks very troubled.

Any chance that Michael Palin could be a ghost himself? (as per The Others)?

YY when the corpse shed a tear!!!! Eeeek.

Really loved it. I live on my own and while I jumped a few times, I wasn't overly scared. Whereas The Woman In Black terrified me.

WandaFuca · 24/11/2014 20:10

I hadn't heard of this - thank goodness for MN otherwise I would have missed it.

I watched it on iPlayer earlier today. I've set my Sky box to record parts 2 and 3 (but I think I'll watch those in the daytime as well Wink).

ozymandiusking - Saffie plays the mother of Hannah, Tom’s HCP who went to his house.

Water seems to be a theme – the sea, the drowned woman, and the dripping tap. I think it was when the two young boys ran out of the house that there was a shot of the tap which was previously dripping but was then running.

Bambam - I agree – when BBC TV does proper drama, it does it better than anyone else. I think the directing/pacing was excellent.

sliceofsoup · 24/11/2014 20:54

I looked up the Floral Hall Scarborough and found a website about the Fol de Rols which is what I think it said on the poster in Toms house.

It says they first played there in 1911 and then at various times including the 1950s.

Might help towards figuring out the time period.

Great theories on this thread. I thought maybe someone had drowned but couldn't figure the Indian lady into it. And Tom made such a deal about not saying his age! brilliant theories.

guineapiglet · 24/11/2014 21:34

Yes Slice, Tom evaded pretty much every question directly, no family, no GP, no visitors - except his neighbours, no electricity (because of the water?), no definite age and no clothes in the suitcase. I guess the mystery is why now? What has prompted him to move to a safe place, and is the choice deliberate ? My eyes must be terrible, I didn't notice the photos being do 'active'....found the piano and all the music verrrrry creepy!
Shock

VenusStarr · 24/11/2014 22:09

Oh god. I just watched this - through my fingers! So creepy. Why did I watch it before bed! I need to watch 2/3 in daytime. I don't want to go upstairs!! It made me jump twice! I went off horror / ghost stories, now I know why!

GeorginaWorsley · 24/11/2014 22:12

Persuaded 15 yr old DD to watch on I player.
she was terrifiedGrin

Am going to re watch tomorrow.
Have missed loads of clues...

Bolshybookworm · 24/11/2014 23:03

Loved it, I love a good ghost story and we haven't had one on TV for a while. They have borrowed MASSIVELY from Ringu and Dark Water but I don't mind, you can't have too much gothic horror IMO!

Nessalina · 25/11/2014 06:43

Watched this last night with my mum, and she insisted on us having the sound on mute thank god! for all the bits in the creepy house Grin
We were doing a lot of shouting at the telly - why aren't you leaving you silly sod!!!
Not sure I'm brave enough for parts 2 & 3! Ringu had me sleeping with the light on for several years Blush

diddl · 25/11/2014 06:54

Yes, I was wondering why now as well?

I assume he had no electricity as the thing gets strength from it?

So it's something to do with the photo that the sw picked up that he wanted to leave behind?