Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Scent of the day part 10, the friendly perfumistas are spritzing again!

562 replies

IDontHateRainbows · 01/09/2026 11:12

Shiny new thread just in time for the new season - I'm thinking smoky, spicy gourmands as we head through autumn.

Old thread here
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/style_and_beauty/5536911-scent-of-the-day-part-9-with-the-friendly-perfumistas-cheapies-or-niche-were-smelling-divine?reply=152661590

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
RoseTeaLady · 28/09/2026 09:28

A cool sunny morning in Berlin today and wearing VP Dear Polly. Smoke, tea and citrus. Seems to suit the city.
Finished a sample of CT Star Confidence yesterday. Nice but nothing special.

CorneliaStreet · 28/09/2026 10:11

IDontHateRainbows · 28/09/2026 09:03

Another 13, le labos musky skin scent.

Been described as smelling like a baby after a bath!

Edited

I’ve just finished a sample of Another 13 and it just smelled like Molecules 01 to me. Babies after a bath make me think of Johnson’s shampoo, not ISO E Super!

I’m wearing Kayali Vanilla 28 today but it was a mistake - weather was miserable first thing but now it’s sunny.

IDontHateRainbows · 28/09/2026 11:05

CorneliaStreet · 28/09/2026 10:11

I’ve just finished a sample of Another 13 and it just smelled like Molecules 01 to me. Babies after a bath make me think of Johnson’s shampoo, not ISO E Super!

I’m wearing Kayali Vanilla 28 today but it was a mistake - weather was miserable first thing but now it’s sunny.

I get the babies skin reference. Slightly sweeter and muskier than iso e 13 to my nose.

My actual baby's skin smelt of sour sicky milk as he was a vommer! Golden milk ? ( as experienced by some)

OP posts:
OvaHere · 28/09/2026 11:13

Angel Dust Extrait today. I just have a sample of this but trying it out again to decide if I love it enough to keep the one that (hopefully) will arrive in the BT advent. I do like it but also recognise it has a similar DNA to others I have, probably because I like this kind of scent.

Advententhusiast · 28/09/2026 11:23

Smelled a couple of fragrances on my skin yesterday.

The Harrods Rose Bac frag. Not my thing. Disgusting on the dry down. Very heavy burned/powdery smell. Did not like it. Glad i didnt get it off Vinted.

Jeroboam. Smelled it on a paperstrip before. Like it on the skin. Smells fresh. But the longevity isnt there. Wont buy a bottle but will keep the fragrance from my Harrods Fac

Gong on the skin went exactly like the paperstrip. Its a no for me. There is a note in it that I dont really like. That one will go up for sale or a trade.

Got 2 BDK samples to take home. The new Tonka extrait and Impadia. I like them a lot.

Smelled some paperstrips for the Selfridges Frag. I really like Initio Musk Therapy, the Lift Me Up is fine, the Oud one meh. The Queening is a bit too sweet for me. Too much Vanilla but will try them on skin first.

QueefofSheena · 28/09/2026 13:52

I'm opening my JLFAC as a bought it to use now. The box is a handy size and not necessarily Christmassy, but pretty, so I think I'm going to use it to store my travel sizes by brand and label the drawers.

I wore Tubereuse Astrale when I was out on Saturday night and really like it. I was told I smelled lovely so that's always good 😁

IDontHateRainbows · 28/09/2026 14:05

Advententhusiast · 28/09/2026 11:23

Smelled a couple of fragrances on my skin yesterday.

The Harrods Rose Bac frag. Not my thing. Disgusting on the dry down. Very heavy burned/powdery smell. Did not like it. Glad i didnt get it off Vinted.

Jeroboam. Smelled it on a paperstrip before. Like it on the skin. Smells fresh. But the longevity isnt there. Wont buy a bottle but will keep the fragrance from my Harrods Fac

Gong on the skin went exactly like the paperstrip. Its a no for me. There is a note in it that I dont really like. That one will go up for sale or a trade.

Got 2 BDK samples to take home. The new Tonka extrait and Impadia. I like them a lot.

Smelled some paperstrips for the Selfridges Frag. I really like Initio Musk Therapy, the Lift Me Up is fine, the Oud one meh. The Queening is a bit too sweet for me. Too much Vanilla but will try them on skin first.

Edited

Was that the montale one from harrods, crazy in love? I thought it smelled like impadia at first but it has a sour screechy note so I went off it.

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · 28/09/2026 14:08

Got the 7 virtues sampler as was passing Sephora earlier.
Also at home waiting for me is lf fac. And I just ordered the perfume shop fac. It has gone up.in price a lot, was £80 last year. But still looks good value.

I think i have just accepted now I'm a perfuma-shopa-holic, there are worse things in life to be.

OP posts:
Advententhusiast · 28/09/2026 14:24

IDontHateRainbows · 28/09/2026 14:05

Was that the montale one from harrods, crazy in love? I thought it smelled like impadia at first but it has a sour screechy note so I went off it.

Yes, that one. At first I thought, oh thats nice and it turned quickly. Hated it so much that I couldnt even be bothered to look up the name. It turns in a way that is so heavy. Burned powder. Not good at describing fragrances but no, no no no no.

Today I am wearing Opus 3 Green Crush from L'Atelier Parfum. I would say that the title covers the scent.

IDontHateRainbows · 28/09/2026 16:20

7 virtues discovery kit so far

LOVE clementine dream. Citrus but softened with vanilla so gentle, mellow.

HATE buttercream haze, sickly closing heavy gourmand

LIKE vanilla woods. It's a very fruity, light vanilla. A bit too subtle

NOT SURE ABOUT Strawberry jam. A bit too strong and sickly. Generally I don't massively like Strawberry as a note.

INTRIGUED BY cherry ambition. A spicy cherry, reminiscent of cherry stem

Still to try: candied lychee and coconut sun.

This house is easy, mid market a la phlur/ ellis brooklyn/ dedcool.

At least 2 so far I like. Enjoying trialing!

OP posts:
CorneliaStreet · 28/09/2026 18:33

I remember really liking Cherry Ambition when I had the 7 Virtues samples. I think I liked Coconut Sun too. Agree that they’re Phlur type scents.

MiaN · 29/09/2026 07:21

I am not sure I will put them in Same group as Ellis Brooklyn but that's probably right if you look at what they are - not at what they started as. Phlur initial perfume ls were very juvenile and simple, Ellis Brooklyn more complex bot of you sample them now they are way closer.

I am going to try to use vanilla rice for few days. That has the potential to be vanilla that smells like vanilla and I can get on with.

JoRaRaRa · 29/09/2026 08:01

Giving Jo Malone English Pear & Freesia another chance today before I sell the one from the Harrods FAC. It just makes me feel like I've sprayed some glade air freshener on myself 🤣 I am actually craving a more comforting fragrance so I'm not sure how long I'll last trying it out.

MiaN · 29/09/2026 08:13

I don't like this one but in general - trying something wheen you feel like something else or in the wrong season doesn't give it a proper chance.

However this aplies more when you are in doubt. Not when you are nearly certain.

IDontHateRainbows · 29/09/2026 08:28

I quite liked the pear and freesia and i don't like much JM but I agree it is a moresummery scent .

Miller Harris Oud Eclat today - a light not very oudy oud, but I do really like it. Similar to oud for greatness.

Miller Harris are quite an under rated house, I do like scherzo, staccato and soufflot in particular. They also have good offer on the 4 x 2ml sample size.

OP posts:
JoRaRaRa · 29/09/2026 08:49

I did try the JM in summer when the HFAC contents list came out but I was of the same conclusion. This is it's last chance 🤣 it is meant to be sunny here tomorrow so I'll give it another go tomorrow. Its almost disappeared from me now so I think I'm going to go with JM myrrh and Tonka from last year's HFAC 🥰 now that one is beautiful and long lasting.

MiaN · 29/09/2026 09:08

JM is suppose to come up with two boozy scents this winter - don't ask me when or what names. Their winter citrus has tobacco - not my thing at all but maybe interesting for tobacco curious people.

IDontHateRainbows · 29/09/2026 09:20

MiaN · 29/09/2026 09:08

JM is suppose to come up with two boozy scents this winter - don't ask me when or what names. Their winter citrus has tobacco - not my thing at all but maybe interesting for tobacco curious people.

Ooh I am tobacco curious ! Intrigued.

So far the tobacco scents I have liked are the molton brown one and the guerlain one, tabac sahara. Also soufflot by Miller Harris.

Didn't like the new crivelli one. The TF one is appealing but will wait until nearer christmas I think

Liberty 1875 is smoky rather than tobacco-ey but I do like it.

OP posts:
MiaN · 29/09/2026 09:23

I wonder if the Luxe Space NK is actually fragrance advent? or will it be instead of fragrance? It's hard to see them doing two, while also having the one that we thought it's lux and now it is just a regular :)

I am bit annoyed at them for that fiasco - people didn't know they may have alternative choice when they purchased the first one.

When in Lanarote last week there were so many very heavily discounted, designer perfume focused shops and for first time ever I wasn't really interested. Over the years I have learned the dna of so many. It's not that I won't test another designer perfumes, or that there aren't some I really enjoy. I will, and I do. But I no longer have interest in so designer heavy advents like Fragrance, Perfume shop or Boots or even Look Fantastic so I was not tempted.

I have to look at buying wishlist item & samples vs buying another offering, I have 10 samples coming form skins and that will come with 20 euro discount code. I can order Wishlist item and get another 10 samples. I want to explore Foraiku, Veronica Gabai, few more of the Initio line, and in store Celine perfumes. I may do brand of the month or something like this? I plugged in all my perfumes in gemini and asking to remove heavy oud, patchouli, tabacco scents as well as very heavy on jammy rose. I didn't add vanila as it is weird one - I have a lot of winter spicy vanillas I get on with.

Missing Harvey Nicks already, and it looks Space NK may not be happening too. 24 samples curation maybe for December?

In a way I am glad I am fussier with sampling and buying sets - I am really not in mood for selling or have too many samples or tiny bottles that I am trying to like to make my money worth. I went to Brown Thomas few times to look at their offering - it seems being fraghead makes me stingier with my money even when it comes to beauty advents. If I do not want the perfumes, the appeal goes at least 40% down.

MiaN · 29/09/2026 09:35

I have to say D'Annam for me is the new and improved byredo. And a lot of the perfumes have developed & changed when tested on skin - for few it took me few times testing on skin to make my opinion. I gave all that are more intense to my son - smokey, oud, I would have liked the whisky one maybe but he got it. I still have at leas 5 I need to make my mind for - playing around with bubble tea and pho breakfast. I do recommend sampling them at home and the sample set - at least to me they were great to explore the brand

TragicMuse · 29/09/2026 09:43

Air of Aquarius today. It’s been 90 minutes and it’s nearly gone already.

That’s just poor. I wouldn’t buy a full size because it’s so short-lasting.

IDontHateRainbows · 29/09/2026 11:02

TragicMuse · 29/09/2026 09:43

Air of Aquarius today. It’s been 90 minutes and it’s nearly gone already.

That’s just poor. I wouldn’t buy a full size because it’s so short-lasting.

I think Sana jardin has gone bust now so not sure you'd be able to anyway!

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · 29/09/2026 11:03

MiaN · 29/09/2026 09:35

I have to say D'Annam for me is the new and improved byredo. And a lot of the perfumes have developed & changed when tested on skin - for few it took me few times testing on skin to make my opinion. I gave all that are more intense to my son - smokey, oud, I would have liked the whisky one maybe but he got it. I still have at leas 5 I need to make my mind for - playing around with bubble tea and pho breakfast. I do recommend sampling them at home and the sample set - at least to me they were great to explore the brand

This is next on my list!

OP posts:
Fillybuster · 29/09/2026 11:36

@IDontHateRainbows & @CorneliaStreet funnily enough, Another13 sax also my SOTD yesterday. I didn’t get the baby part, though, more quite subtle but reasonable stay, very lightly spiced.

Unusually friendly HN Le Labo assistant gave me a whole bunch of samples when I bought my mistake Neroli last winter. I’d completely forgotten about them until I did my big clear out over the weekend because they were shoved at the bag of a drawer in their little brown envelopes. Now working through them, although worried I might like several. Tried Lys41 2 days ago, too floral for me.

Big day today, taking dd2 to uni. My heart is breaking - I’m not remotely ready to let go of her, even though I know she’s going to have the best time ever. Sobbed my heart out in bed last night.

Le Labo The Matcha for uplifting vibes & feeling fresh to keep me in a positive mindset. Although it might take more than perfume today!

Advententhusiast · 29/09/2026 14:41

IDontHateRainbows · 29/09/2026 09:20

Ooh I am tobacco curious ! Intrigued.

So far the tobacco scents I have liked are the molton brown one and the guerlain one, tabac sahara. Also soufflot by Miller Harris.

Didn't like the new crivelli one. The TF one is appealing but will wait until nearer christmas I think

Liberty 1875 is smoky rather than tobacco-ey but I do like it.

Have you tried Tabacco Toscano from Santa Maria Novella?