Generally I don't like oud at all. Rose only if it's part of soft/fresh, realistic young rose scent. Like Delina La Rosee, Diptyque Eau Rose or MFK L'Homme À la Rose. I don't mind it in Chanel Chane eau Tendre either
Not fan on rose oud, rose patchouli, mature sweet rose, the likes of Portrait of Lady, Delina and many others. When it comes to rose I need it simple, clean, realistic.
I am open to change my mind, but this has been my experience so far.