Which dress do you prefer?

[Karcheer]

I need to pick a dress for my brothers wedding.
I’m not sure which I prefer.

Which one do you think I look better in?
Thank you.

1st one - but what is the pink badge, does it have to stay?

They are both Navy blue. The pink circle is a label, as I’ll return the one I won’t wear.

Second one for sure

First one. Lovely with the red shoes too

The first one.

Definitely 1st one

You have a great figure but I’m not really loving either dress for a wedding... do you fancy any of these instead?
www.houseoffraser.co.uk/women/oasis-angelica-dress/d918081.pd#296556635

Depends on the wedding - 1st one is more city wedding, 2nd more country wedding, if you know what I mean. You look nice in both but I would probably brighten up the dark colour with lighter shrug / accessories to make them more 'weddingy'. Blush pink looks nice with navy I think.

The other one looked black to me anyhow definitely the one with the red circle .

Def 2nd longer one - more classy and flattering. Agree with pp that blush pink shoes/ wrap would look good

first one, it's lovely on you

Both look good but I prefer the second one on you.

Second is nicer and more flattering Imo - lovely dress

Ah!! Def that one!!

You look gorgeous in both but I prefer the second. I love the cut, it really suits you.

First one!!! The second doesn't do you any favours at all

Agreed the first one's halterneck really flatters you.

The second one is more to my taste but the first one suits you better

Crikey, I understand why I can’t decide, you all seem pretty split between the two too!

I’m afraid the red shoes are staying. It took me long enough to find a pair of shoes I liked today :)

Would you mind telling us where the first one is from? It's lovely on you.

2nd one is best, shape of first one looks a bit dated. Also, I think you need to be a bit a lot braver with the shoe choice.

They are both from Chi Chi.

m.asos.com/chi-chi-london/chi-chi-london-premium-lace-prom-dress-with-cutwork-hem/prd/9582528?clr=red&SearchQuery=&cid=8799&gridcolumn=1&gridrow=2&gridsize=2&pge=2&pgesize=72&totalstyles=840

www.theprettydresscompany.com/sale-c16/the-pretty-dress-company-thea-pencil-dress-p88#attribute%5B1%5D=2

www.theprettydresscompany.com/new-arrivals-c12/new-arrivals-c14/the-pretty-dress-company-1940s-navy-ivory-polka-dot-wrap-dress-p219#attribute%5B1%5D=25

www.theprettydresscompany.com/new-arrivals-c12/new-arrivals-c14/the-pretty-dress-company-hourglass-faux-wrap-pencil-dress-p202#attribute%5B1%5D=2

I don’t think either are quite right to be honest. The cut of the arms in the first dress is v unflattering and the cut of the second dress makes your hips look much bigger than they are in comparison to the first. If it’s a choice only between the two, then the second dress, but I think you could get much nicer.

I'm not a great fan of halter necks generally but I much prefer the first one as it flatters your shape. The second one is too long for your height, makes your bottom half look big and shows way too much cleavage for a wedding.