The poor dog. 😢
You’d think your husband would be more alarmed as purposeful cruelty to an animal (Especially motivated by jealousy) is a very bad sign.
My husband can occasionally recognise that his daughter is an issue. But then he undergoes a massive cognitive dissonance thing where he decides that I’m in the wrong for objecting to it not her for having done something unkind.
And he’s always sucked straight back into the hideous dysfunctional dynamic of his first family. Totally reinforced by his family who all participate in it. It’s really overt too. They all pretend that I’m making it up but I really am not.
Things like MIL insisting that SD must have her own room at her house (because she’s a girl) but that meant that SS literally had no room at all and was being made to sleep in a travel cot in with his dad at 4! All while there was a room permanently designated as ‘SD’s room’. That’s not subtle favouritism or whatever. And both the children’s parents allowed this!
I have said so many times to my husband that, if any member of my family treated my children like that, they would not be seeing us. I would not take my children to visit a grandmother who plays favourites like that.
But, what I have learned over the years is that it wasn’t just MIL. That’s the whole family dynamic and he and just ex did similar things. They’re all caught up in this golden child/black sheep bullshit.
And the irony is that being treated as the golden child is making SD a pretty unpleasant person. It’s not good for her at all. SS’s behaviour is difficult too. But, frankly, I’d think ‘fuck it’ and want the world to burn if I were treated as he has been. His whole life.
There’s nothing I can do about the awful dysfunction around the stepchildren. But I refuse to have my baby subject to the same golden child crap. And I am not having him steamrolled by SD’s enormous sense of her own superiority like SS is.
My older sons both think that the way SD talks to SS is dreadful. I’d never have allowed the older one to tell the younger one that he just wasn’t as good at anything or as clever or whatever, which is what SS hears all the time.
DS2 was utterly perplexed to hear SD saying ‘Oh SS. You just don’t know how to swim. I’m really brilliant at it’. SD cannot swim. Neither of the SC can. SD has had some lessons but if she doesn’t have arm bands on she screams and wails and scratches everyone and just won’t try. If anything, her much younger brother is braver and more competent than she is. But still her parents let her tell him how he’s just not as good as her. It’s not even insecurity - she genuinely seems to believe that she is better than everyone else and is unable or unwilling to recognise that she isn’t. 🤯
She tried to tell my DS that she’s better at swimming than him that same day. He swam off and laughed. He is 4 years older than her and knows fine well that she can’t swim (whereas he’s a seriously good swimmer), so he found it hilarious that the girl with armbands on was trying to claim she was amazing at swimming.
His favourite SD anecdote is the time that she was lecturing SS in the car about how he knows nothing unlike her. He doesn’t even know where Sir Francis Drake lived (which she’d been learning about in school that very week). Except it turned out she couldn’t bloody remember it either. DS is usually quiet and chooses to ignore this crap but he spoke up and said: ‘don’t worry, SS. She doesn’t know either. Maybe it would be better to make sure you know things before you start boasting about it to others people’. My husband told DS off and insisted that ‘you can know something and just not be able to remember it’. Rather than agreeing that she was just being horrible and had comfy unstuck. Rather than learning to be nicer, she had it reinforced that she is actually better than SS.
This is the sort of thing that happens day in day out. Everyone around her keeps preventing SD from learning humility or empathy. And poor SS just has to listen to his father agreeing that his sister is better than him - even where her boasts are nonsense (rather than simply bring because she’s nearly twice his age).
Any decent parent would simply stop their child being horrible and boasting. How hard is it to say something like; ‘he’s much younger than you. He’s at nursery and not being taught these things. Please stop being unkind to your little brother’?