Well I am having a horrible time
I did have one lovely night... after another rough night on Sunday, DH said he would take a turn at dummying on Monday night so I went in the spare room. The plan was that I would come back around 4 or 5am to feed DD. I woke up once and heard crying, but looked at my watch which said 12.50 so I went back to sleep. Then next thing DH was waking me up and it was 7am! It's the first time I have had 8 hours almost uninterrupted sleep since before DD was born, it was fab!
Turns out my watch had stopped (I thought it was very light when I woke!), and although DD had woken loads of times in the night, she went back to sleep (eventually) every time when DH gave her the dummy, and the only time she didn't wake was when he was expecting her to need feeding! So it seemed like she just didn't really need it.
BUT... as she was still waking loads, we decided we had to try cold turkey again. So since yesterday morning we have not given her the dummy; but it has been hell.... Yesterday was bad enough but as DS was in nursery, I could spend time soothing her and managed to get her to sleep without it a few times (though never for more than 20 or 30 minutes before she woke again); also took her for a long pushchair so she wouldn't get too overtired. Then the night started reasonably well, got her down in about 20 minutes, and back to sleep after her dreamfeed too without too much trouble.
But then she woke about 1.45 and could NOT get back to sleep for absolutely ages, and was crying terribly - I was that close to cracking and giving back the dummy but didn't want to undo all the work so far. By 3 she was still screaming so I fed her in desperation, although she doesn't normally need anything then, and after that she finally conked out until just after 6.
Then today has just been a nightmare - I have DS today too, so it was hard to get time to settle her without leaving him on his own too much (and the one time I did get her to sleep, he came barging in and woke her again...). She is getting more and more tired but harder to settle, and just gets really upset as soon as I try to put her to bed. DH has her in the pushchair now so she at least gets a bit of a nap (he took the afternoon off to watch the match!) but I am not looking forward to when he gets back and I have to try the crib again - or to tonight, as I think it may be worse than last night.
If I could see any alternative I would give up, as she is getting so upset, poor thing... but if we give the dummy back now she will just be even more dependent on it, and will keep on waking loads of times every night to cry for it. So I think I need to try and tough it out somehow, for all of our sakes...