Quick crash from the resident lurker to say hip hip hurray for the return of the rabbit TFM! It is the furry kind and not the other isn't it? That's one in the eye to HWSNBM - well, that and the fact that he was well and truly put on the back foot in all senses! All that's left now is for you to enjoy a relatively HWSNBM-free existence and finally get your life back - I'm so pleased for you!
Glad everyone else seems to be doing well save for the nonsense from HW's H, Tanne's P and Dior's H! Anyone for an arse-kicking??
Nothing much to say from my end save for an explanation as to my silence I s'pose - things were really hard for a while after DS was born. I guess I found it hard adjusting to the difference between parenting one and two and my rship with DH was a bit up and down, depending on my mood! things seem to be evening out a little now - thanks to TFM's nagging persistence, I've seen the GP and discovered that I am suffering from adjustment disorder (allegedly!). Not sure what it means - I'm too frightened to google! I don't quite see the light at the end of the tunnel yet, but watch this space...
I do however have some advice for Baffy fwiw - I too had the amazing non-sleeping second baby who also ended up in bed with me and was a world-class headbutter! When it got to the point that I was going to do someone bodily harm if I didn't get at least one hour's uninterrupted sleep, I took it upon myself to sleep-train him. I didn't really use a specific technique. He was about six months old iirc. He was still ebf at the time and I found he was doing exactly as your DS2 Baffy - waking for nothing, sometimes just to play. Although I admit it was cute, it would drive me mad when I put him in bed and he batted my face or played with me for half the night and then fell asleep with his feet on my head!
My routine went a little like this - I put him down semi-awake in his cot after his last bf and then sat next to the cot whilst he settled. At first he got up and down a lot but I just kept laying him back down. It was awful at first - lots of screaming and back-arching. Poor DD really suffered being in the next room (DH slept downstairs!). He did eventually go down though - I had to be really really strong and not pick him up, even if he was screaming his head off.
It felt cruel at first but it's amazing how quickly they learn that this is it now, they have to go to sleep. I didn't feel so bad because I wasn't leaving him to cry. I was there comforting him but just not picking him up. I figured that it was more important in the long-term that he had a good night's sleep than cuddles with Mummy all night. During the night, if he cried I'd have to get up and pat him back to sleep - if he got up, I'd simply put him back down and repeat ad nauseum. It graduated to the point where I would stick my hand through the cot bars and stroke his hand to get him back to sleep.
It took about a month for it to work and we had a lot of hiccups we had to work through, especially when I stopped bf at 14 months. I must admit that I do sometimes give in and take him into bed with me but I can count on the fingers of one hand the number of times I've done that in, say, the last three months. Another important thing is to do the same for day-time naps as you do for night-time - does he nap in his cot in the day? You might want to try with a day-time nap and work from there. I also found it reassuring to really fill him up before bedtime so that I was sure he wasn't waking up because he was hungry. Is he having a bottle before bed still? I'm slightly embarrassed to admit that DS still is and I give him 9 ounces to make sure that it sees him through the night.
Other things you can try would be to try to treat the colic. I've recently moved DS onto goat's milk because I found cow's milk/formula was making him really bunged up and uncomfortable, especially at night - he'd cough a lot. He doesn't do it at all now. You could also try colief - I didn't for DS but it was a god-send for DD. It's quite expensive and it's a small bottle but I think you put a few drops in the bottle and it breaks down the lactose. Do you have a routine in place for bedtime? I find that if I don't give DS a bath right before bed, he wakes up a lot in the night - weird! I also rub him down with a combination of cream and cal-rub and give his tummy a little massage to get rid of excess wind - he loves that!
Right - that's enough wittering ! I've bored the pants off myself and am going to bed now!