Been immersed in a work event, so haven't posted this week, but glad this thread is still alive! Happy Woman, sometimes when you write, it is like me talking. What you say resonates so deeply.
Counting to 10, I think you are spot on in your assessment of your H. His former behaviour was manipulative in the extreme and I'll bet he's always hated confrontation. Treating people badly so that they "sack" him, in effect, absolves him of responsibility and blame. My DH was similar to an extent, so much so that I wondered in the early days whether (during the affair) he was trying to get me to end the marriage, he was behaving so horribly. We've had lots of conversations about this and actually, I think it's a bit more complex than that.
In our case, he had been in contact (in some form of another) for about a year before he finally met up with OW. There was a fairly long gap of no text contact (about 5 months)during that time which, bizarrely, he doesn't really remember. He assumes they were still E mailing occasionally, or that she was phoning him, but he now wonders whether, having been met with refusals to meet up, OW moved on to someone else briefly.
However, during that year, we have concluded that he was "creating a gap" in our marriage, to allow the possibility of an affair. He was therefore withdrawing emotionally from me, but it was pretty subtle, so much so that when I realised I was feeling unhappy and unsettled, I didn't even pin it on him or our relationship.
The truly awful behaviour started after he'd seen her. He says that by that time, he felt he didn't deserve love, affection and a happy home life. He has also wondered whether it subconsciously occurred to him that if I ended our marriage, by that time, we would have been so estranged from one another emotionally, it would have been less painful for him to handle. However, he says that if that WAS a motivation, all that was shattered on Discovery night, when he really did think he had lost me. He says the pain was indescribable and acute, so any belief he might have had that it was going to be less painful, was shot to pieces. He is adamant that he never, ever wanted me to call time on our marriage - but is prepared to accept that he felt I had just cause to, there was always a risk that I might, and so was trying perhaps to lessen the pain for himself. One of the hardest things to forgive is that in effect, he "did a number" on me, to create the conditions where an affair was more justified.
Our rebuilding process has therefore included both of us rejecting any manipulative behaviours, with anyone in our lives in fact. He now tells people how it is and is much more straightforward with people and I don't expect him to read my mind about what could be troubling me. We are very direct and open with eachother.
YoVicko, I understand why you want him back, but he is still behaving manipulatively. In your position, I would want him telling OW that he is making a clear choice because he wants you and not her. I can almost hear him now, somehow blaming you to her for HIS choice to return to you. Have you considered giving him a time frame? Or at the very least, some appearance that actually, you are moving on now and if you have moved on too far by the time he has come to his senses, then that it HIS responsibility, and not yours?
Happy Woman, I don't blame you in the least for hoping that OW didn't get herself checked out! Did her H take her back in the end - have you heard anything about what she's up to now?
I also fantasise about what I would do if anything like this happened again, but although I always thought that an affair was a deal-breaker, I absolutely know now that a second occasion would result in the marriage well and truly ending. I would just know with every bone in my body that if he did it again, after this much pain, agony and soul-searching, I would think he was a sadist and a psychopath. I gain strength from knowing that actually, the decision would be much clearer cut than before - and there is a peace of mind about that.
But I genuinely cannot imagine he would do this again. Like your DH, Happy Woman, he is incredibly sensitive to flashpoints, like his phone going off, or unexpected calls. We are also into a summer of horrible "anniversaries" from a year ago, and he is extremely caring about how I might be feeling.
We have also talked a lot in recent times about the affair being only part of the list of things to forgive. The other day, my DH said that there are times when he feels worse about his cruelty and behaviour to me while it was going on. He finds that inconceivable now - but at the time, thought he was being "assertive"! He really hates himself for what he was at the time, Happy Woman, has that lessened at all in your DH? Is it healthy for someone to hate themselves that much?