I think our advice somewhat reflects the stage we are at with our own relationships.
I think once you try a course of action that works, like you TFM, you can look back, see your mistakes, and then advise with wisdom and with the benefit of hindsight.
For all of us, we go through the emotions as and when they come, and then do what feels right at that time.
I think that my advice to UC comes because I regret not voicing my real feelings in the early days. I tried to withdraw too quickly. Tried to show him what he was missing. Be strong and dignified.
But, in my case, it led to him feeling guilt free and happy to move on. It backfired big time!
He was so shocked when I eventually broke down and let him have it! That was literally months later. And again changed the dynamics of the relationship. I really wished I'd got it all out at the start.
I think for you TFM, it's after a lot of soul searching and learning from what didn't work, that you found the best way to deal with your situation and found what works for you.
I bet it's frustrating to think you're watching us repeat your mistakes. When you know what's worked for you in the end.
Everything you say is spot on. Especially about being responsible for our own feelings. But I think our partners respond in very different ways to our behaviour and the same thing that may salvage one relationship, may spell the end of another.
If that makes sense!
I only hope UC can see all these different perspectives and understand why we disagree. But then find whatever perspective feels right for her, and go with that.
I hope we're not messing your head up even more UC.
Just do what I do. Take on board the advice you like agree with, and ignore the rest!