Yes, I often feel that I am dealing with someone with emotional maturity of an adolescent (which are, as far as I am concerned, often very like toddlers due to a weird period they go through of emotional regression). Essentially I often feel like I’m dealing with a toddler.
My response is really long @Labrakadabra!!! I’m so sorry. You don’t have to read it! :)
I don’t know if your OH felt rejected (although obviously you would know better than me of course!!). When I read through your dialogue, which I have two or three times now, trying to imagine this as if it were my DP, this is what would be going on in his head. (I appreciate he is a different person to your OH! But they sound like they have some similarities)
Firstly, I got the sense of confusion on your OH’s part. You had tried to have an adult conversation and to give him a heads up about something which was significant to you and would illicit an emotional response in you. What I got from reading this through was that often trying to have sensible adult conversations about your own feelings is going to be hard with someone whose emotional maturity is that of an adolescent (toddler). For a start you’re talking about feelings which are not his, so you’re on a hiding to nothing from the start really! He obviously had a problem applying his version of logic (which is of course the only truth) to your situation. He even said “how can you possibly know how you will feel about something in the future?” He clearly isn’t able to do that. Again doing that would require emotional development and knowing yourself and what your emotional response to something will be, let alone taking the time to actually stop and think about it, is the behaviour of a developed self aware brain. It’s not logical to him, because he doesn’t have that kind of brain. Therefore you are the one that doesn’t make any sense/is illogical and is trying to complicate matters.
By this point he felt irritated (why is she making me have this ridiculous conversation?!) so your calm explanation that you were just trying to forewarn him about something (which was inconsequential and irrelevant as far as he seemed to think) may have been seen as you treating him like a child (which is sort of what we have to do a lot of the time! Predict the emotional meltdowns. Try to be proactive in terms of placating rather than reactive. It really is like knowing you’re going to need snacks when out with your toddler to avoid the inevitable meltdown!! We’re so used to doing it!). Perhaps he sensed this a bit and, irritated already, went off on one about you having no place telling him what he needs!!! Also, of course, as you say, he’d heard you say this before and probably banked it subconsciously for use at a later date. My DP certainly has a HUGE thing for people not telling him how he feels. It makes him furious if he thinks I’m doing that. He bangs on about his ex and how she ignored his feelings. He is very focused on having his truth heard and doesn’t take kindly to someone else interpreting his needs for him.
And of course once you snapped at him then he was the victim! And you were cementing what he already knew. You’re the angry one trying to argue and he is the calm laid back victim in all this! You explaining you would like an apology is probably seen as a demand and also a “look how wonderful I am compared to you because I know how to apologise!” Which is then going to illicit the very typical “I will not apologise! I will not be told what to do! I am not a puppet. I don’t do what is expected!!” (DP has real issue with following expectations and rules. I find it really bizarre that autistic people are often viewed as people who need to rigidly follow rules. DP is the complete opposite and takes great pride in his autonomy. I think he feels like he’s won!!)
If you’ll forgive me (you might not like what I have to say, so apologies if this comes across as rude or preachy!), I think when he made clear he didn’t see the point in the conversation and you agreed, you said “Anyway, let’s move on….As I said…” and I think this was a mistake. (Sorry!). Leaving it at “let’s move on” might have been better. DP does this to me. He says he wants a conversation to end. I immediately say “ok fine yes” and then he feels the need to say “all I’m saying is….” And then reiterates what he’s already told me / his point of view. Which I don’t need to hear again. Especially not after we have just agreed to end the conversation and move on. DP has lastworditis! Despite often being the one to say he wants the conversation to end, as soon as I agree he then has to have the final word on the matter. I usually stop him and say “no actually. We are either ending the conversation, as you’ve requested, or we are continuing to iterate our views. You cannot ensure the conversation ends, but only for me, while you carry on making your point! Either we both stop talking about this or we don’t!” I pull him up on this when he does it. Which is often.
In short, your OH sounds pretty insufferable. I could imagine a similar conversation with DP. I am fortunate to have moved into my own accommodation and this means as and when he has his intolerable moments, I don’t feel the need to enter into a dialogue about it. I don’t feel the need to explain myself or try and reason. I just say “I’m going to leave. You’re not being very nice”. I don’t get drawn in any more. Much easier now we live apart. The physical space and my ability to walk away without any escalation means he seems to be much better at reflecting on what he’s just said, realise he’s been a dick, and apologise profusely. I tend to say “thank you for the apology, but I really don’t need one. What I need is for you to think about what you said and how it might have come across/made me feel. And try and use that information for future reference”. I find apologies quite useless. They’re too easy to say. I would much prefer the mental effort that is required to have some empathy. Much harder than an apology!! DP seems to be getting a whole lot better at this!
I don’t know what you should do. Sounds like you already live apart.? Do you see a future with this man? I don’t mean moving in together. It’s perfectly
possible to be in a partnership and not live together. But is that what you want? Are there positives that balance out this type of infuriating interaction?