Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

I just ended things with a good man. I feel sick.

403 replies

SeamsLegit · 13/01/2025 09:49

13 years, our kids 12 and 8. A calm home with plenty of laughs. As I said, he's a good man. Kind, reliable, dependable, funny. But we haven't had sex in over a year, the attraction is gone for me (he hasn't changed physically) and his drive has certainly disappeared. Feels like we are roommates. Talked a few times, he is content with life as is. I did spell out things I want... passion, romance, excitement, affection. He has definitely put in an effort, complimenting me, buying me things, defrosting my car on icy mornings - but when he puts his arms around me in bed it feels wrong. He's upset (disappointed in his words). I feel anxious, nauseous. Is that a sign I made the wrong decision?? I'm 40, he's 50. The house is mine, but I don't want him to feel scared, anchorless, worried about the future. I have suggested separate rooms, cohabiting and co-parenting. He doesn't think it will work. I don't want our kids not to see him every day. I don't want him to feel excluded - he is family to me, I love him, I'm not IN love with him. I feel like I've been hanging on for things to get better for a long time. But I also feel selfish for choosing ME over our family unit as it is.

History, my mother divorced my dad and left to travel the world when I was a young teen. Definitely affected me, my life derailed, I stopped going to school, wasted the potential I had, did things I shouldn't etc. Although I was young and really, older men shouldn't have done those things - but no force etc. I feel resentful that my mum left at such a young age, my dad obviously had a hard time adjusting, things weren't great for a while - although I have minimal memories of that time. Great relationship with my dad now, recently not so great with my mum as although we were besties for years, now that I am caring for her due to ill health, I am narky and impatient a lot because she didn't look after me when she should have!

I suppose I'm scared I'm doing the same thing - but I'm not going anywhere. I'm very aware that life is short. I don't want to have regrets!! But I don't want to hurt any of my family either. Any advice is welcome, although I guess posting this before I dropped the bomb last night might have made more sense. It just bubbled out of me lying in bed, like I couldn't hold it in any longer.

Now I'm in work, and tearful. I haven't told anyone irl, I'm trying to be resilient

OP posts:
Aquamarinescarf · 13/01/2025 15:01

One final thought, OP? Do you meditate? There's some new research out showing that it's good for depression and for me (I don't meditate much now, but I did for a while) it was a reminder that just because my mind was racing away with thoughts and my mind/body with feelings, I could detach and just watch it all flowing by like ticker-tape. I learned to watch myself thinking, if that makes any sense, but not get trapped in intrusive thoughts or desires. Just a thought.

Variegatedleaves · 13/01/2025 15:02

Chiseltip · 13/01/2025 11:52

"Passion"

"Romance"

Kindly OP, you live a real life, you have kids, you're not young anymore, and you aren't a character in a TV RomCom.

The figures show that it's mostly women in their 40s who instigate divorce, not sure of the exact figures but it's somewhere like 80% of divorces are started by women. The figures also show that men generally end up in a new relationship whereas the majority of women never do. You can leave for whatever reason you want, but it will change your childrens lives forever. Your relationship with them will change and it will never be the same again.

Just think long and hard before you do anything. The reality is that you probably won't have another relationship, so the passion and romance you crave is irrelevant.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

Re: the stats there, I think women often initiate the divorce because the man has ended the relationship, or made it untenable. I don't think the figure of 80% (or whatever it is) means that in 80% of cases it's the woman who has woken up one day and said "I love you but I'm not in love with you, so I'm filing for divorce". It might instead mean that the husband has run off and so she's finally filing for divorce in order to get the practicalities sorted out instead of him setting the agenda.

So... I don't disagree that dating as a single mum in one's 40s sounds absolutely to be avoided if at all possible, I don't agree that most divorced women have gone into the dating world intentionally and with rose-tinted glasses. Some, yes (I would have been one of them). For many, it might be because their husband got onto the dating apps while they were still married!

Hecatoncheires · 13/01/2025 15:06

OP, I feel for you. Never underestimate what grief can do to you. You perhaps are grieving the mother that you never had, possibly triggered by your own child nearing the age that your mum was when she left. I hope everything works out for you.

PS: I changed job due to grief. Was in a fuck-it state of mind! Really wish that I had not as it was not the best move for me. But at least it was only a job and not throwing a grenade into my family unit.

Aquamarinescarf · 13/01/2025 15:07

SeamsLegit · 13/01/2025 14:58

I have often felt I can be manic... that's the 'hyper-focus' I mentioned. I get a bee in my bonnet and can do nothing else. I have got back out of bed to rearrange furniture, organise cabinets, and for a while draw house plans to scale - I am not building a house. I have mentioned this to a doctor before but they were neither concerned nor interested

I have diagnosed ADHD friends who talk about being hyper focussed and would recognise that behaviour, so it sounds as if there's a whole bundle of stuff to be taken into account by anyone who is working with you. Are you in a position to consult a psychologist/ psychiatrist privately? I only suggest that because from everything I read and hear, waiting lists for NHS treatment are crazily long. You sound pretty self-aware, OP, and that will get you a long way — but you get further, and more efficiently, with the right help.

Whydoeseveryonewanttoargue · 13/01/2025 15:08

Hipalong · 13/01/2025 09:58

Passion, romance, excitement...life is not a mills and boon novel and your (now ex I guess )partner is 50. You're 40, with two children. You don't want to have regrets, but splitting up your young children's family because your life isn't exciting enough is likely to be a huge one.

I kinda agree. Life isn’t a Disney movie and there is a point in marriage where it isn’t like it was in the beginning (especially with children) but deeper and more meaningful..

OP you need to also consider that if you have broke up he may not feel the same about being friends or close to you.

i think therapy would be beneficial as the red flag in your post for me was you apparently sudden loss of attraction to your partner. Did you always feel this way? You say he hasn’t changed? Are you pushing him away as your dad left you at about the same age? Sounds like maybe you still have some things to unpack?

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:13

MoonHavana · 13/01/2025 10:56

Your life, your choices, your responsibilities. Think of the repercussions down the line on everyone that your pursuit of 'romance' is going to cause. You will then be able to look back in later years and say 'I did it my way!' 😂

Once you have kids, it's not as simple as 'your life' anymore.

samarrange · 13/01/2025 15:16

SeamsLegit · 13/01/2025 10:38

Sex life has fluctuated over the years, 2023 we had lots of sex, and he ended up getting a vasectomy (ironically so we could have sex without contraception). The operation, or rather the recovery, was painful for him, and we didn't have sex for about 4 months. We tried once, he couldn't get an erection. About 4 months later we had sex, that was it for 2024. He wouldn't go to the doctor about his non existent sex drive, he didn't go to a chemist, he began filling in forms online for viagra but abandoned them as 'too complicated'.

He has said that surely sex isn't the most important thing in a relationship, and asked how I would feel if I was going through menopause/something and lost my drive/ability to have sex and he wanted to leave me over it. But I would go to the doctor, I would take medication to try to fix it (like I do for my mental health, he is wary of medication in general).

But it has now come to the point where I no longer want to have sex with him (although my sex drive has increased dramatically!) and the thought of him actually coming on to me is rather alarming! I felt undesirable and unwanted sexually for all of last year.

he began filling in forms online for viagra but abandoned them as 'too complicated'.

According to the signs I see in Boots, you can walk into a pharmacy and buy Viagra now. I assume they ask a couple of questions about other medication and blood pressure.

But remember that Viagra and similar medicines only address "hydraulic" problems. If your DH is getting erections otherwise (for example, in the night) then it won't help, because it doesn't work on the psychological aspects of arousal.

SeamsLegit · 13/01/2025 15:16

I also don't want to demonise my mum... my early childhood was good. For years, from my mid 20s, we had more of a 'friend' kind of relationship, and there have been lots of times she has financially helped me out of a hole or been very generous. We have had plenty of good times. But now, as her independence dwindles completely, I find her more and more needy and I suppose I'm crumbling under the pressure. She's always disappointed when I leave and I guess I feel guilty at not WANTING to be there with her.

OP posts:
LondonPapa · 13/01/2025 15:16

@SeamsLegit , I've read your posts multiple times and all I can say is you scream poor impulse control, clear mental health issues due to trauma, and a bunch of other red flags. You're throwing away your relationship, your stability, your rock, over your life not being exciting? everything you described is what happens in the early days before routine kicks in, and with kids, boy does it settle.

If you continue to leave him (or if he isn't understanding and gives you the boot), you're going to be in for a very big shock as to how life really is.

Madamegreen · 13/01/2025 15:18

Variegatedleaves · 13/01/2025 15:02

Re: the stats there, I think women often initiate the divorce because the man has ended the relationship, or made it untenable. I don't think the figure of 80% (or whatever it is) means that in 80% of cases it's the woman who has woken up one day and said "I love you but I'm not in love with you, so I'm filing for divorce". It might instead mean that the husband has run off and so she's finally filing for divorce in order to get the practicalities sorted out instead of him setting the agenda.

So... I don't disagree that dating as a single mum in one's 40s sounds absolutely to be avoided if at all possible, I don't agree that most divorced women have gone into the dating world intentionally and with rose-tinted glasses. Some, yes (I would have been one of them). For many, it might be because their husband got onto the dating apps while they were still married!

Out of my friendship group that divorced half regretted it.
I know a couple whose wife told her husband, 'I don't love you'. He packed a bag immediately and filed for divorce the week after. She told everyone much later she just wanted to get his attention and never wanted the divorce.
He's still never spoken to her.
I often feel divorce is used as a tool to communicate dissatisfaction and not many realise the after-effects.

BettyBardMacDonald · 13/01/2025 15:25

Hipalong · 13/01/2025 09:58

Passion, romance, excitement...life is not a mills and boon novel and your (now ex I guess )partner is 50. You're 40, with two children. You don't want to have regrets, but splitting up your young children's family because your life isn't exciting enough is likely to be a huge one.

This. Even though you say you will "no go anywhere," you basically are planning to do to your own children what your mother did to you: Rob them of their secure family unit, their identity as a member of an intact family, their feelings of security.

Doing so if there is abuse is one thing, doing so because you want more "excitement" in life is inexcusable, in my opinion. You made a "for better or worse" commitment and you doubled down by having two offspring in the marriage. I realize that "life is short" but you owe it to them to stick it out until they are adults. Just my opinion.

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:30

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 12:57

Hard agree.

There seems to be a strong 'any man is better than no man' vibe going on here. I think a lot of posters are also projecting, to some extent.

No, the vibe is "the man who is the father of your children and who is a lovely man is better than no man".

This isn't just about what the OP wants, it's about what's best for her children.

Secondstart1001 · 13/01/2025 15:32

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:30

No, the vibe is "the man who is the father of your children and who is a lovely man is better than no man".

This isn't just about what the OP wants, it's about what's best for her children.

It should really be about both, if she’s unhappy it’s going to impact the children anyway. I don’t think she’s selfish but she does need to slow down and work through her issues before she makes far reaching life decisions.

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:34

PiggyPigalle · 13/01/2025 13:27

After thirteen years shared with a good man and father to two children, "the house is solely mine"?

Can you imagine if a man said this?! He'd quite rightly have his arse absolutely handed to him.

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 15:35

SeamsLegit · 13/01/2025 14:58

I have often felt I can be manic... that's the 'hyper-focus' I mentioned. I get a bee in my bonnet and can do nothing else. I have got back out of bed to rearrange furniture, organise cabinets, and for a while draw house plans to scale - I am not building a house. I have mentioned this to a doctor before but they were neither concerned nor interested

It could be a combination of ADHD and being perimenopausal. I have ADHD and combining that with the other physical and mental symptoms of menopause (which I also started relatively early at 46) has just exacerbated it massively. In my experience, once the love/sex hormones that give you rose-tinted glasses to some extent are annihilated by the menopause, you're also a lot less tolerant of your partner's foibles.

I had an adult diagnosis of ADHD which I had to go private to get. If you're high functioning with any mental health disorder, doctors don't give a shit.

I DID choose to end my marriage, and tbh don't regret it, but my situation was not the same as yours. All four of us are absolutely fine though.

BettyBardMacDonald · 13/01/2025 15:36

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:30

No, the vibe is "the man who is the father of your children and who is a lovely man is better than no man".

This isn't just about what the OP wants, it's about what's best for her children.

Exactly. When people decide to have children, the adults' "fulfillment" takes a back seat to providing a secure and happy home until those children reach adulthood.

Absent abuse, danger (such as drugs dealing) or other dire circumstances, parents need to suck it up. It's only an unhappy home if they choose to make it so. We can control our feelings and actions.

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 15:37

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:30

No, the vibe is "the man who is the father of your children and who is a lovely man is better than no man".

This isn't just about what the OP wants, it's about what's best for her children.

It's also about what the OP wants. Self-sacrifice isn't always what's best for everyone.

Bulletpointers · 13/01/2025 15:39

@SeamsLegit Divorce is no fun, and really there isn't an abundance of wonderful men out there to sweep you off your feet.
My exh was abusive in all possible ways apart from physical. If he was just a bit dull, i wouldn't have torn mine and my kids lives apart, because divorce and everything you and the kids have to go through because of it is shit!!
I agree with pp. Work on your trauma. Appreciate what you have. Being single with kids, co-parenting, dating etc etc is not all that.

Aquamarinescarf · 13/01/2025 15:41

BettyBardMacDonald · 13/01/2025 15:25

This. Even though you say you will "no go anywhere," you basically are planning to do to your own children what your mother did to you: Rob them of their secure family unit, their identity as a member of an intact family, their feelings of security.

Doing so if there is abuse is one thing, doing so because you want more "excitement" in life is inexcusable, in my opinion. You made a "for better or worse" commitment and you doubled down by having two offspring in the marriage. I realize that "life is short" but you owe it to them to stick it out until they are adults. Just my opinion.

OP and partner aren't married and you have made up the stuff about for better or worse. Not agreeing with OP is fine, making stuff up isn't.

Aquamarinescarf · 13/01/2025 15:42

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 15:37

It's also about what the OP wants. Self-sacrifice isn't always what's best for everyone.

Have you read all of the OP's posts. They tell a very different story.

SarahPaton · 13/01/2025 15:42

@SeamsLegit I feel for you. I could have written this. I did not fancy my husband at all and I ended it. I loved him but was not IN love with him. I won't lie. It was horrific. Breaking his heart and my daughter's heart (4 at the time and now 7) was sickening. The guilt has crippled me over the years. He also moved to my city for me and has no family or deep friendships here. I will never forgive myself for the pain I put him through. There was also someone else involved. Although it wasn't a physical affair, it was just someone I fancied so much that I couldn't concentrate and had spoken to in ways I shouldn't have. It was a long and difficult road. I am 40 now and single. I find it very VERY hard. I miss all the family stuff so much it hurts, especially at Christmas time - it used to be my favourite time of the year and now I dread it :(

But equally, I have hope that I will fall in love again and feel all those things I wish I had felt for my ex. The truth is, if you stay it is hard and if you leave it is hard. It's which version of hard you want. But at least, having left, I do have hope of falling head over heels again. I have also experienced that wild passion with a couple of guys over the last few years and it reminds me what I need from a relationship. I don't have to pretend to feel all the things for my husband that he deserves to have someone feel about him, and that is a relief (there's nothing enjoyable about making love to someone you aren't physically attracted to).

But splitting up a long-term relationship with young children involved is deeply unpleasant. It sounds like we are in the exact same shoes but I have walked a little further in them. Reach out if you would like to chat. Wishing you happiness xx

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:42

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 15:37

It's also about what the OP wants. Self-sacrifice isn't always what's best for everyone.

I'm afraid that's just something selfish parents tell themselves.

There are OF COURSE valid reasons for ending a relationship which has produced children, but not getting enough sex isn't one of them.

peachgreen · 13/01/2025 15:48

Oh gosh OP, so much of what you've written here resonates with me. ❤

I think you are making the right decision to NOT make any big decisions regarding DP while you're going through all this. I suspect things will become clearer in time, and until then it sounds like he is supportive and will help you work through some of the pain you're in.

Sending love.

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:48

SarahPaton · 13/01/2025 15:42

@SeamsLegit I feel for you. I could have written this. I did not fancy my husband at all and I ended it. I loved him but was not IN love with him. I won't lie. It was horrific. Breaking his heart and my daughter's heart (4 at the time and now 7) was sickening. The guilt has crippled me over the years. He also moved to my city for me and has no family or deep friendships here. I will never forgive myself for the pain I put him through. There was also someone else involved. Although it wasn't a physical affair, it was just someone I fancied so much that I couldn't concentrate and had spoken to in ways I shouldn't have. It was a long and difficult road. I am 40 now and single. I find it very VERY hard. I miss all the family stuff so much it hurts, especially at Christmas time - it used to be my favourite time of the year and now I dread it :(

But equally, I have hope that I will fall in love again and feel all those things I wish I had felt for my ex. The truth is, if you stay it is hard and if you leave it is hard. It's which version of hard you want. But at least, having left, I do have hope of falling head over heels again. I have also experienced that wild passion with a couple of guys over the last few years and it reminds me what I need from a relationship. I don't have to pretend to feel all the things for my husband that he deserves to have someone feel about him, and that is a relief (there's nothing enjoyable about making love to someone you aren't physically attracted to).

But splitting up a long-term relationship with young children involved is deeply unpleasant. It sounds like we are in the exact same shoes but I have walked a little further in them. Reach out if you would like to chat. Wishing you happiness xx

I have also experienced that wild passion with a couple of guys over the last few years and it reminds me what I need from a relationship.

Was this passion worth breaking your 4 year old's heart for? I just can't imagine it was.

SarahPaton · 13/01/2025 15:50

IButtleSir · 13/01/2025 15:48

I have also experienced that wild passion with a couple of guys over the last few years and it reminds me what I need from a relationship.

Was this passion worth breaking your 4 year old's heart for? I just can't imagine it was.

Do you feel better for your judgy input? I hope you do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread