Wanting things to be literal indicates ND OP which is fine.
I don't "fit in" really, but I am happy to not go too deep with many people.
I would think about it differently, sometimes conversations about who died, or who has bought which house can lead to really interesting conversations.
If people are homophobic say, gays jokes ha ha, then small talk with them are all you should aspire to surely?
Wanting others to change to become interested in the deeper topics is not going to happen. What deeper topics do you want to talk about? And have you asked yourself if you want to talk about them, hear different views, enter a debate you are prepared to change your mind if the arguments from others are more rounded, or do you want to basically lecture, tell people how they are going or thinking all incorrect and you are the more enlightened one?
This is why there is small talk. It helps establish who is of similar mindset.
Your mind needs to be open for other people, you can be a black sheep but a black sheep that is really needed in a group. You can change minds and phobics, but it takes time and minimal judgement to begin with.
Posters saying they have "high standards", to be honest I don't know what that means, to be politically correct, which again is difficult to determine, to dress for any occasion, to have a show home and polished car, to have read the 'right' books, not like football but enjoy a bit of cricket? I just don't know what that means.
My advice, relax, enjoy people with all their messy attributes, don't judge, have a glass of wine and try and work out if the people who bought number 10 might or might not be ok even if they haven't read any deep high brow literature.
I am a bit of a black sheep but luckily can be a grey one with other grey sheep. It's an ok place to be.