Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

DH doesn't want to spend his birthday with us

354 replies

Limewater · 10/02/2022 22:19

Hi there,

New here but I’ve been a lurker for years - hoping some of you ladies can give me your opinion on this dilemma because I’ve gotten in a right mood over it and now can’t tell if I’m being way over the top?!

DH and I have been together since we were 16. 13 years later and we have a DD and DS and just got married in January 2022. My DH is due to turn 30 in April and a couple of weeks ago I started making a list of things I thought he might like to do - travel/fancy meal/night outs etc. I figure everyone wants a fuss made out of them on their 30th?! Anyway, he listened to the ideas and gave a lack lustre response but didn’t downright dismiss any of them.

Cut to this evening, he’s come in and said, ‘I’ve checked with the ‘boys’ and they’re all free on my birthday weekend - so I’m planning to go to Edinburgh on my birthday (Fri 15th) and come back on the Sunday (Sun 17th)’.

I was upset because I came up with loads of plans for him to choose from. All really well thought through and involving varying degrees of friend groups so there would have been loads to enjoy. But he doesn’t want to spend his 30th with me AT ALL. I guess I’ll be at home looking after the children. Not to mention that that weekend is actually Easter Weekend - which I feel like should be considered family time?

When I asked him why he doesn’t want to go away with me, he said, ‘we don’t really have fun when we go away. I want to actually have fun and go drinking with my friends’… I’m just hurt - why did you marry me if you don’t enjoy my company?! I thought we did have fun? And I do drink btw (just not until I’m sick… like some people I know).

What do you guys think?

OP posts:
MimiDaisy11 · 11/02/2022 10:15

His comments and the way he went about planning the trip behind your back aren’t good. I’ve no issues with going off with mates for a mini holiday.

When you brought up your ideas he should have just said then what he wanted instead of announcing it later when plans had been agreed with friends. It suggests he thought he wouldn’t get his wish if he discussed it with you first or he didn’t think to do so and thought it acceptable to make plans without you agreeing to look after children. Either way it’s not good.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 11/02/2022 10:15

I wouldn't mind the going away with friends part as long as you can go away with yours in return, but this 'we don’t really have fun when we go away' was downright rude and he's an arse for saying that. He either has some serious apologising to do or sod getting him a present

This. And I wouldn't be impressed with the going out and getting so drunk that you puke up over the carpet. He needs to grow up.

BoodleBug51 · 11/02/2022 10:19

I'd let him go, but I'm darned sure that I'd be doing the same for my own birthdays. And leaving the kids with him for the same time and spending the same amount of money.

It's cruel to have said that you and the DC aren't fun though, that would upset me far more than the birthday weekend.

mydogisthebest · 11/02/2022 10:19

@CharlotteRose90

I think it’s fine sorry. Your 30th is a big birthday and maybe to him he doesn’t want a boring meal or meal out with you and the kids. Most people have a nice holiday or a party. You settled down young so I think he wants a final party. You don’t have to be one of those couples that does everything together as that does get boring. Let him go and then when it’s your 30th you do something for the weekend and he has the kids.
Yes 30th is a big birthday and, to me, you would want to spend it with your family.

If a meal with his wife is so boring maybe they shouldn't be together. Of course couples don't have to do everything together but if my DH didn't want to spend his birthday with me I would be upset.

Why can't he go on his lads weekend another weekend and spend his birthday with his wife?

I am really surprised that so many posters think it would be ok or even that they spend birthdays with friends rather than their partner.

My DH is my best friend and I really would not want to spend a birthday with anyone else. A big birthday I may want a meal with him and my family but I would not want him not to be there

Hshuznw · 11/02/2022 10:20

Hmm I would be ok with spending the birthday with friends, but it’s the way he’s gone about it and his comments that aren’t ok.

Lockheart · 11/02/2022 10:21

I'm not sure where the 4-day trip is coming from, if it's Friday 15 - Sun 17 then it's what, 48 hours? 2 and a half days max?

He is being completely unreasonable to present this as a fait accompli out of the blue, especially when money is tight.

I don't think the comment about not having fun is much to read into - trips away with young children are rarely properly fun and relaxing for the adults and I can sympathise with wanting a carefree weekend, with the caveat that if you were to also organise a surprise birthday weekend away without him and the children that it would be no problem!

theleafandnotthetree · 11/02/2022 10:23

@mrsbyers

That’s absolutely unacceptable even just because of Easter let alone his birthday - I would be fucking furious
What's with all the ballyhoo about Easter? Most people if you put them up against a wall wouldn't be able to tell you the actual meaning or significance of it. It's a bank holiday weekend, relax, there's lots of them Hmm
SunnySideUp2020 · 11/02/2022 10:30

**DH does have a history of rolling home so drunk and out of control that he's thrown up on our hessian rugs a good number of times... Anyone who's ever cleaned red wine sick put of hessian gets me when I say I have a slight distaste for people being so drunk they can't make it to the toilet!

What a catch Confused

stickysellotape · 11/02/2022 10:32

My DC are similar ages and look forward to our birthdays almost as much as their own, so for that reason alone he is being unreasonable. Never mind it being Easter too. He could go away with his friends another weekend to celebrate his birthday.

And as for the comment about Easter Confused For some people it’s more important than Christmas.

Balonziaga · 11/02/2022 10:35

Can't believe how many people are ok with this.

I think the problem is the actual dates.

His big birthday falls at Easter and kids are old enough to understand about 'actual birthdays'. He has a wife who has tried to organise something for him and children that want to be with him. For that reason he should WANT to spend is birthday with them.

There is no reason why he can't have a birthday weekend with his mates but they are not six - they could go a week later and still celebrate. They won't care whether it's his 'actual' birthday, but his wife and kids do.

It's the date that bothers me - that's for loved ones.

And of course the comments about 'no fun'.

worriedatthemoment · 11/02/2022 10:38

@Chloemol why can't married people not go away with friends on there own? Your not tied at the hip , your still two different people
Im happy for my dh to go away and him me as we trust each other and a girls weekend is totally different to a couples weekend and you can enjoy both

Bookworm20 · 11/02/2022 10:39

OP, what he has done is really hurtful. He's been an absolute arsehole to be quite frank.

I totally get you trying to think of some ideas to make his birthday special, thats not controlling at all (someone said that! wtf), its being really thoughtful and taking the time to suggest some things to him that he may not have thought of. I'd appreciate it if my DP made some suggestions of fun stuff for my birthday, it means they care and are thinking about wanting to make me happy.

Unfortunately i too agree he probably had this already planned which is why he was reluctant to engage with your suggestions. wonder when he was actuually going to tell you! And I also bet his mates are seeing it as a bit of a stag do combined birthday event. Which is likely why their partners are possiby having to ok it - its x's stag do, we have to go blah blah.

A whole weekend away for a birthday when you have a young family and not flush with money, and only been married a couple of months is incredibly selfish, at best.

The way he has gone about it is a whole other level. He has not discussed it and to boot insulted you to justify his reasons for going!

He has totally disregarded you as his wife and your family just so he can go on the piss for a weekend, which will drain your finances by the sound of it. And you have no say n it. II'd be really really hurt if my dp did this.
In fact Id find it very hard to get past. Totally understand he wants to celebrate with friends, but there are ways of going about that without insulting and compltely disregarding your wife and family.

If he does in fact go ahead, will he be spending from the joint account? I'd be so tempted to take a load of money out of that account right after he leaves for an 'emergency' purchase so hes bloody skint the whole weekend. And certainly don't get him a present. He doesnt want to send his birthday with you, in fact hes basically said you'r boring, so why the hell would you get him a oresent!

So he leaves on his birthday, is that right? I'd be waking up that morning as normal, not mention a word of happy birthday to him.

I'd also be wondering what sort of 'fun' they will be having in edinburgh thats so incrediblly important that its worth him completely shitting on his wife for. He can get wasted any time he wants, but I'll bet this isnt just a piss up weekend. So sorry OP, but it appears he has very little respect for you.

He could of had his weekend with the lads the week after or before, with your blessing, no doubt if he'd not been a total arsehole about it. I''m so angry on your behalf.

Phobiaphobic · 11/02/2022 10:40

Bloody hell - who blew the cool wives klaxon?

Ponoka7 · 11/02/2022 10:40

@theleafandnotthetree, you never celebrated Easter with your young children? The shops are full of Easter crafts etc. How would you manage to just ignore it?

Being Easter weekend will put the price up loads. If they are going on a drinking weekend there's cheaper places than Edinburgh. He should be having the weekend on a different date. I used to have two/three birthdays, one which included my children, usually on the actual date. He has been planning this behind your back and as usual it's assumed as Mother, you'll take over the childcare/housework etc. It shows you what he thinks of you. Whatever you do, don't make compromises in your own life for him.

Phobiaphobic · 11/02/2022 10:42

@Limewater

Also I should say that when I said I came up with plans for him to choose from. It wasn't that he had to choose from those plans, it was that he'd not mentioned any plans at all and I didn't want his 30th to get there and for there to be nothing in place!
Don't worry, OP. Normal people understand this.
AryaStarkWolf · 11/02/2022 10:43

I'd be very hurt by his reply. I could get over him wanting to go away with his friends but saying that he didn't want to go away with you because you don't have any fun together is really nasty and very hurtful

worriedatthemoment · 11/02/2022 10:44

I think the big issue here is you haven't discussed it , hes just told you what he plans
We would discuss , so I would say I was thinking of going for a weekend away with the girls for my birthday c, whats your thoughts ? Dh may say yes go for it or i was thinking we could do this , could you move the girls weekend to weekend after etc
So I don't think a weekend away is wrong or should not be allowed because your married , but a discussion around it and so it fits in with all if you is fair as your a family

worriedatthemoment · 11/02/2022 10:50

@mydogisthebest but thats you , my dh gives zero crap about birthdays so I could go away on his birthday and he wouldn't careless
If I had a weekend away booked with the girls and it happened to be on my birthday I wouldn't not go , I can see my DH when I get back 24/7 and we can celebrate then, we are adults doesn't have to be on the day, mostly we work on our birthdays anyway
I can't understand people who have to do everything together all the time,
Surely your still your own person and sometimes a birthday may clash and you would understand that and be ok
This instance with OP is different as there has been no discussion and his comment was uncalled for

theleafandnotthetree · 11/02/2022 10:51

@stickysellotape

My DC are similar ages and look forward to our birthdays almost as much as their own, so for that reason alone he is being unreasonable. Never mind it being Easter too. He could go away with his friends another weekend to celebrate his birthday.

And as for the comment about Easter Confused For some people it’s more important than Christmas.

For devout Christians, absolutely. But that is a very, very small minority and I don't get the impression that it's the missing of Easter services that the major problem here.
Toanewstart23 · 11/02/2022 10:51

How is your marriage generally?

Odd you never refer to this.

RachelGreeneGreep · 11/02/2022 10:57

Anyone who's ever cleaned red wine sick put of hessian gets me when I say I have a slight distaste for people being so drunk they can't make it to the toilet!

I hope he was the one cleaning it up!

layladomino · 11/02/2022 10:59

I would be really hurt by that.
I've no problem at all with DH having a week end away with friends, but he knew you were already suggesting fun things to do, and yet he ignored those things and then went away, and without any reference to you he planned something with other people.
A coupled / married / family man who ignores his wife's suggestions for a lovely week end and then makes plan with other people - and tells his wife when it's a done deal - is showing his wife where she stands in his priorities.
He could have gone away with his friends any week end.
If there was a particular reason it HAD to be that week end, he could have discussed it with you, explained why it couldn't be avoided, and suggested you do your things the following week end.
I suspect he already knew what they were planning when you started talking about it.
And then the real stinger - his reason for doing this? Because he enjoys his friends company more than yours.

I don't think I'd want to stay married to him. That sounds stupid when it's just about one week end. But it isn't just about one week end is it? It's about the fact he's planned something behind your back, when he knew you wanted to do something, on a special birthday week end, because he doesn't have as much fun with you and his children. It's a slap around the face for you and your children.

(Plus I couldn't be married to someone who makes a habit of coming home blind drunk and vomiting over the carpet. He sounds like he hasn't grown up).

You deserve so much better.

Bananarama21 · 11/02/2022 11:02

Easterbunnyiswindowshopping

I think he should fuck off away. One way.

Your joking right? How dare he want a weekend away for his birthday with his friends what a twat Hmm

If it was you wanting a birthday weekend away with friends people wouldn't batter an eyelid why is it any different because he's male. Plenty of people I know who have went away with their friends to celebrate their birthdays separate to their partners.

AryaStarkWolf · 11/02/2022 11:06

@Bananarama21

Easterbunnyiswindowshopping

I think he should fuck off away. One way.

Your joking right? How dare he want a weekend away for his birthday with his friends what a twat Hmm

If it was you wanting a birthday weekend away with friends people wouldn't batter an eyelid why is it any different because he's male. Plenty of people I know who have went away with their friends to celebrate their birthdays separate to their partners.

For me personally it's not him wanting to go away for a weekend with his friends, it's the fact that he said he doesn't enjoy weekends away with his wife. I'd be really upset if my husband didn't enjoy my company or have fun when he's with me, wouldn't you? I'd definitely be re-evaluating my relationship if I found out my husband felt that way about us
PleasantBirthday · 11/02/2022 11:07

So what's he planning to do with the kids on his weekend away? I'm sure has sorted something suitable out.