Whether you feel he is lying or not, you have no right to shout and scream at him. That is abusive. You also have no right to expect him to hand over his phone. It's his personal private property. If you don't trust him, that's on you, but your reaction isn't on
Are you for real, @MissNothing1991?
He has no right to lie to the OP, and he certainly has no right to go behind her back and potentially cheat on her. He has no right to take an HIV test and not even have the decency to inform OP that she needs to take one, too. This isn’t some little cold that he’s got some cold and flu sachets for, it’s incredibly serious.
This man is being much more abusive than the OP. She got upset over something quite horrific, that he caused. He on the other hand has kept things from her, lied to her when asked about it, manipulated her by changing his story, is treating her like an idiot (in the sense that she would lap up the ‘prank’ story), is playing with her physical health by withholding vital information from her and has potentially cheated on her.
Regarding the phone, if he has nothing to hide then he has nothing to feel bad about. He abused their trust and when your trust is broken, you look for ways to clarify the truth. He is actively withholding that. Sure, it’s his “right” to, but it makes him look pretty fucking sketchy if you ask me.
And lastly, “if you don’t trust him, that’s on you”- are you purposely trying to be completely dim?
OP saw a change in behaviour.
She found evidence which makes sense regarding the aforementioned.
She asked him about it and he behaved in an odd manner- he didn’t try to explain a plausible story, he didn’t offer up “proof” that he was being honest. He literally made no effort to convince her otherwise.
He has changed his story and went to the “bath”, which to me means he’ll have his phone in there and be deleting everything off it before OP has a chance.
If you would trust your partner after all of those behaviours and incidents, regardless of whether he cheated before or not, then more fool you. Sometimes you have to call a spade a spade.
Stop trying to defend a shitty man who at best has had suspicions of having HIV and hasn’t told OP, and at worst has played away, contracted HIV and kept all information from her regardless of her mental and physical health.
Honestly, it’s one thing lying about cheating, but break ups happen and people get over heartbreak. It’s another thing entirely to keep something so serious medically from a person. She has every right to know.