@Ruralbliss from personal experience, I'd recommend giving Hinge a go if you haven't tried it already. My experiences of the apps I'm on are:
Tinder - not that many matches, quite a few fake profiles, but it seems to be the site almost everyone signs up to at some point, so worth a try. I was quite active on there for a bit, but hardly use it these days. I've had a few matches, only met a few women but saying that, of these one was Miss C last year who I really fell for, and then Miss Rose who I'm seeing again this weekend.
Bumble - frustrating as a guy, as quite often I'll match with someone and they then won't get in touch. I used to pay for the membership where it showed you who had liked you, but they've made this more expensive now and I haven't renewed which makes it harder to match now.
PoF - signed up deleted the app within the first day. I thought it was awful, the only matches I got were spam accounts trying to get me to click dodgy links.
Hinge - my favourite. Profiles are simple, and people seem to be much more genuine and looking to meet for something more than a hookup. I've had by far the highest number of chats and dates from people I met on Hinge. Not sure though if that implies there are less guys, so I stand out more.
Match - couldn't be bothered to go through the effort of writing a long profile and answering all the questions, when the other apps are so simple. I was on there years ago when it was just web-based, but haven't seen the appeal this time around.
I even signed up to fab a while back, but didn't really spend any time on my profile, and haven't used it since. I'm quite tempted to give it a go though as a few people here seem to rate it.
One thing I do, which has helped increase the number of likes I get, is to occasionally pay for my profile to be boosted during certain times (Sunday evening is meant to be the busiest time for swiping, but I also go for Thursday evening too plus other random times). The apps seem to be trying to grab more money though, as recently Hinge changed it from boosting for 24 hours to 1 hour, with only a small drop in price.