There is so much wisdom in this thread - just read back the last couple of pages... @HairyArsedMan that is so true about unmet needs and the scourge of self-help books making us all think we won't succeed until we're perfect.
I've been very guilty of this and bought a whole stack of books after my previous car-crash Tinder experience... and was merrily trying to reconstruct myself as this perfect new self who would therefore be immune to heartache. One day my counsellor proposed the idea to me that instead of trying to rebuild myself to be perfect, I should instead accept the world as it is, inundated with imperfect people including myself, and try to develop resilience and acceptance instead easier said than done
@TheCatWithTheHat - sorry to hear about your experience too... painful though it absolutely is (it's very similar to my ex who after insisting he was under so much stress he needed space, was on the verge of a breakdown, etc; with me then offering help, backing off a bit, and spending a couple of weeks in confusion - I then found him with rejigged profile back on Tinder) I think she has done you a favour by admitting the feelings weren't there for her too because it stops the wondering, and the attempts to 'right' something that you can't. I'm so sorry though - it is horribly painful.
I have spent much of my life wondering if I'm unloveable, or perhaps very difficult to love, or something - I'm quite sensitive and a bit mixed up, but with the appearance of a very confident and assertive person - and I think that combination can be quite difficult for many people! I am also starting to recognise that I have previously continued with relationships even if from the start it was clear that they should NOT be continued - so really do applaud those of you who have been or are better and wiser at getting out if things don't feel right... it's not easy to do and it is FAR better to be single than to be in an abusive relationship or one just based on drama!
Things continuing well with my new iron, although I am a bit wary as he is only separated for a year and halfway through divorce. He is quite boundaried about not expecting or wanting either of us to dump our own 'stuff' on each other too much, but as I've been separated for 7 years and divorced for 4... I know how raw it is when you're still in the first year - this will be his first Christmas not in the family home for example... I was a mess at that point and it's hard not to compare.