It's a little hard to criticise since I seldom come across a woman's profile that screams out to me that the profiler is anything but a woman simply and genuinely looking for a like-minded partner. Of course I have no clue as to whether ungenuine men's profiles are somewhat more prolific and / or easier to identify amongst the sea of profiles but in general it's unusual for me to ever encounter a profile that instantly make me think "she's a wrong un".
I'll try to be constructive...
Photoshopped photos - could not agree more with PPs. Anyone wanting to make themselves look like a glittery anime teenager gets an immediate swipe left.
However, a smile always helps! You really don't need to pout instead - please, don't pout - a pout very rarely draws me to a profile. I just want to see what you look like, relaxed and natural.
Disagree slightly about the list of demands. No real problem with anyone broadly setting out what appeals to them on a recreational, spiritual, and to an extent physical level, OLD is a shop window after all. I'm no Adonis and carry a bit of timber so i'm hardly going to be attractive to, or particularly attracted to someone that runs triathlons every other weekend. And that's fine, we both know the score (unless of course said triathlete expressly states they're after some chubby chap who gets out of breath opening a bag of crisps). Saves a bit of time.
However I'm totally put off by profiles that appear to demand perfection (you'd be surprised what proportion of profiles follow this tack) because I wouldn't expect that's ever remotely likely to be me. I wouldn't be entirely surprised if these are the profiles that are honeypots to the chancers though.
I would be far more prepared to respond to profiles which set out what might be, let's say, more realistic, relaxed criteria and take it from there.
Jaded-with-OLD profiles... If I'm honest, these always seem to get a second look from me - I feel the same way after all. Whether I would want to reply to one is another matter - will I be the white knight to come and whisk you away from OLD, will I be seen as responding almost out of pity or, more likely, would I just be another in the long line of humdrummers?
Hope that hasn't appeared too mansplainy and critical, just my experience...