Quick update - I'm not quite home yet...
He was absolutely lovely and we had great evening. Much wine was consumed (1 bottle me, 2 bottles him), which unfortunately led to a failure to "rise to the occasion" which left him mortified. I of course told him not to worry and we had nice kisses and cuddles all night- my goodness I don't think he let me out of his arms all night, it was amazing and just what I needed after my recent fuck and chuck experiences. So, I figured it would be OK and we'd try again this morning - same thing but no alcohol to blame, now I'm thinking it's me ☹.
He says it's never happened before - he's 39, fit and healthy and has no reason to lie, but he says he's been so nervous about meeting me. He's messaged me saying how embarrassed and sorry he is and hopes we can meet again with less alcohol involved. I'd love to meet him again, but his working hours are crazy and he lives an hour away. Sorry, just thinking out loud, I'm 60/40 thinking I'll meet him once more so I don't have that "what if" feeling and I can put it to bed either way.