Rockluvvindad Oh, I don't take offence at anything said on this thread. We're all going through the emotional mill, I'm sure everything (harsh or not) is written with the best of intentions. The whole point of this thread is that we say crap to each other and work it out so we don't appear like crazies IRL. 
I'm having a few wobbles (because I'm human) but I know I am happy being on my own. I had quite a few serious long-term relationships and I've only really got comfortable with my own company in the last few years. I am confident of that. I am not reconsidering out of desperation. (You can say it.)
I feel like Beardy and I were totally on the same page emotionally and physically. The differences we had were many, but just detail - nothing fundamentally important. The non-negotiables were non-negotiable and actual problems... but now I am genuinely wondering if they're just things I've got used to saying and thinking as opposed to actually being true. Does that make sense?
I would never have had a child with my ex. We were together for longer than many marriages but I knew subconsciously I didn't want half his genes and/or to bind myself to him forever. I also thought he would be a crap parent.
So... is it me, or is it the man? I am frantically trying to figure it out. I've never really given this much thought. I think it's important to figure it out. I mean, even if I never see Beardy again, I might meet a similar Beardy and I'll have to know the answer to this sooner or later.