Here is my experience. Decent looking male living in the North West.
POF. This is my weapon of choice. Any dates I've had have all come from here. Lots of fakes sending meet me invites but these are easy to avoid. I have been a paid member and never would again. It just serves to show how many people delete your messages without even reading them. Some things are better off not known. Currently installed.
OKCupid. Had a bunch of chats via here but nothing ever came to a date. People do seem a bit almost alternative on here. The match percentage means nothing, I've had very high 90s who haven't responded. It's all about the photo. Currently not installed.
Tinder. This does seem to be all about hook ups and therefore it's not me. I have had limited luck on here. Currently not installed.
Bumble. A seeming never ending flow of attractive women which made it seem either fantastic or fake. I matched nobody, not one single person. Currently not installed.
MeetMe. I used this for a few days and didn't like it at all. Strange app filled with strange people. Currently not installed.
Match. This one needs to be paid up or is useless. I've been a paid member in the past and had no dates. Had a lot of message from fake users though. Wouldn't join again. Currently not installed.
Happn. Barely bumped into people and just because you've walked past someone means absolutely nothing. Started getting people from the other end of the country. Their support team advised rebooting my phone. Pur-leeeese. Currently not installed.
I've probably used a couple of others but they're all naff around this area. Most users on apps around here are an hour away which places me outside of their zone.