Hi everyone!
Handy, sorry I passed out last night before I could reply to your post! I am not surprised you are sitting with me on the WTF bench.. The ex wife comment was way out of line! But from my "can't open up" position I wonder if that was not CI's attempt at telling you that it is not that he does not want to let you in, he just can't for the moment? I dunno but the "feeding crumbs" and the lack of emotional literacy does resonate a bit with me. And, putting the pedestal stuff aside, it is not you or Karmic doing anything wrong. I am the one with the problem and my guess is that CI is probably too. Trying the direct questions approach is I think a very good plan. Might suggest Karmic does that
Freaky no worries, I need harsh!! Karmic is indeed "wonderful boyfriend" material, and I do need that oomph. A lot of oomph.
do I respect him? I think so.. But I am not sure I admire him.
But I am not marrying him tomorrow so maybe I just need to chill the fuck down and realize that if it does get too boring I can get out of it? Re Bacon, it looks to me like your anxieties are related to trust - is there any chance that part of it is fueled by your past experiences? Ie it is not you or him or the situation, it is the work of your ghosts from the past?
Sassy Karmic is indeed a little outside my type, even though I usually do not go for alpha males mainly cos I am the alpha. But I do not want a doormat either. Like 314 says (awesome analogy!) I want a co-pilot, someone that I feel comfortable passing on the wheel to. And that is where I am failing. Which is weird because I do trust him to drive safely.., I would feel "not in control". Also I am currently the driver and I know fuck all where I am going. Dammit, I am just a complete control freak on the loose. Argh.
Waving yep, I would unfriend Soho. He was pretty rude to you the last time you guys spoke wasn't he? That makes me think my first "opening up to Karmic" goodwill gesture is going to add him on FB. He messaged me on the chat and we are sometimes using it but I never added him. 
Jollyp
to you - and it is true the "hope for the future" does have a way to put unreasonable pressure on the present.
Traffic I can assure you you are not alone!! Dating is really hard. And wow at almost divorcee. Bastard.