Beyond a mechanism to report the abusive liars, feedback is a horrible idea. I don't want someone quibbling over how much weight I may or may not have gained since my profile picture was taken.
Look, this isn't supposed to be easy. Genuine attraction and connection is a rare and wonderful thing. That's why it's so bloody exciting when it does happenand why monogamy has any hope of working.
People ask whether OD ever works? Define works. I know of several couples who have met and married through OD, which seems to be the default benchmark of success. (And interestingly men seem to have much more success in progressing to relationships if that's what they want). But why should it be? Others have had longish relationships. Others have had lots of fun one night stands. For some, it really is online dating and not online marriage arrangement. Does meeting people in a pub "work", does a sports club "work", the office? OD is one tool in the toolkit.
And for that I do think something quite controversial: If someone has done OD for years and it not worked, they have presumably also been out and about in real life and that hasn't "worked" either. That doesn't necessarily say anything negative about them a large part of my brain still believes all the eligible straight men married at 25, but it does say OD is not the sole fault. And I say that as a deeply single person.
Nice and normal is overblown as a defence mechanism. Are you nice and normal? I'm not. We all have baggage, we all have quirks that are loveable to some and repulsive to others. I'm not a raving loon, but I know I have a way of engaging with people that just isn't going to work with lots of men, interests that bore many, etc, etc. What's that quote? We are a little weird and sometimes we meet someone who is weird like us and call it love? I paraphrase hugely, but the point is most people are not going to be your significant other. It's very likely that Mrsdigitalbunny's husband who she met online is the same freak that Msfrustratedsurfer posted about in the dating thread two years ago. Horses for courses.
I don't believe in the one but I do believe in the not many. Therefore if you increase the number of people you meet (which at the end of the day is all OD can do for you), you're massively expanding the number of people you meet who were not the one.
Although there are freaks out there so for godsake have boundaries, a thick skin and a good radar.