I wouldn't say my sex life is boring and I'm mundane. If anything my husband is the vanilla one.
The elephant in the room here, is the sex act and people trying to dismiss op's OWN concerns. She said herself that she isn't entirely happy with the situation and that needs to be looked at. Why does she feel he is so exciting, yet can't seem to see why she feels uncomfortable. Why does she feel she can't communicate her own feelings with him. Rather than try and ask strangers if this is normal, or question herself.
So the elephant in the room is the women in this thread focussing on the sex act, insisting on screeching at everyone for being prudes, rather than concentrating on this woman's unease.
That's quite scary, considering it's other women doing so.
I don't have an issue with fetishes, or other peoples for that matter, it takes all sorts. There is a huge problem however if it makes you feel uncomfortable, has you questioning yourself and reluctant to communicate your own belief, without checking the "norm" with others first.
It's not the sex act that shocks me, it's not him asking that shocks me. We all have fantasies, how can you communicate that without saying so?
My problem is how op feels about it, the questioning of normal, the questioning of herself, the unease, and unhappiness about it, but not saying so straight to him.
That alone screams unease to me. I know a groomer when I "see" one. Quite a common tack. Baring in mind as, has been said, some men into this kind of thing, do groom the women, to accept more and more, than they are comfortable with.
I'd be interested to know his exact job. As this is sounding so startlingly familiar. My friend eventually got out, when he rammed a fist up her and made her bleed then pissed in her mouth.
She won't mind me saying that. She started off, all "he is soooooooo exciting, so out there, really good sex, I've changed my view point, blah, blah."
She was reluctant to start slapping, but did so. You could just see, the exact same questioning pattern, it was uncanny.
But I digress, the issue here is that op feels unhappy with the status quo, can't seem to say why, just that it doesn't sit right. Combined with the fact he does seem to have her questioning herself and normal so soon, that is the issue.
So all the people moaning about mundanes, stop thinking about sex for one bloody second, and listen to the ops concerns. They are there for a reason. People talk about projection, I think they have themselves confused. There is only one side using projection here. People with an agenda to try and prove how great they are in bed and how mundane other people are for showing concern.
Scary that you are all dismissing the op's feelings to do so.