Wow - thank you all! You are very kind. Carry on like this and I may have to get some t-shirts printed up ...
TWDA you are welcome to your opinion (though obviously I vehemently disagree with it) but PLEASE get your facts straight. I have scrolled back and can't even see where I have addressed FedUp directly, still less "bullied" her. Maybe I have missed something?
Listen, it's very simple. In as far as length of sobriety counts for anything, I am a reasonably long time sober. And in that time I have seen people drink and then die of it. Anyone here has the right to drink whatever and whenever they want - it's not even illegal. And you are probably right - probably not everyone here is an alcoholic. But, leaving aside the terminology, it's clear that a lot of us here have problems with alcohol when we drink and the nature of that problem is, by and large, not being able to stop.
I'm not then going to say, "oh, well, you drank, never mind, you've cut down and that's the main thing" because I don't believe it to be the case. If someone is NOT a problem drinker but is drinking too much and cuts down, of course that is brilliant - he or she will be better off, healthier and will probably lose wieght into the bargain. But if someone is a problem drinker then, by definition, their control of their drinking is precarious and short-term to say the least.
If such a person drinks and comes back then of course I am glad. I am glad that (s)he is not dead or locked up. I am glad that - apparently, because (s)he has come back - it has strengthened her resolve. And I can relate to it because I did it myself, several times.
But it's not something I am prepared to endorse, any more than I would smile indulgently at an emphysema sufferer having a "cheeky puff". And, as the main reason any of us is here is to share our experience and get better together, I will, by and large, say that if I think it will help anyone else.
As you say, TWDA, you can just ignore me if you like. But there's a difference between bullying - saying things to people to try to hurt or control them - and giving people honest answers to questions and them not liking the answers.