Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Moral dilemma - whether or not to lie to DD (6) to save her feelings.

165 replies

snigger · 24/02/2009 10:47

Background:

When DD1 was born, it was PFB all the way. DD2, as is the lot of DD2s, was greeted with equal adoration but less fanfare - the first weeks were, to be honest, all about me worrying about jealousy and displacement in DD1 on the grounds that a warm, fed, loved baby wasn't bothered about anything else.

DD2 is now 6.

Two issues: we've been putting together photo albums of them from birth to date, and the fact that there are substantially fewer baby pictures of DD2 than DD1 has been remarked upon - I explained this as best as possible without actually saying "We were too busy potty training your sister".

The issue of "DD1 is your favourite" has been brewing quietly, and DD1 most helpfully weighed in this morning at breakfast by bringing the Gund bear DH shot out to buy her minutes after birth, and remarking how she'd had this bear 'all her life'.

Needless to say, a special bear for DD2 would have been a good idea, but never appeared due to time constraints and general lack of organisation, added to the fact that DD2 was born at home, rather than metres from the hospital gift shop.

This morning, thankfully directly outside the school, DD2 turned and asked where her 'special teddy' was, to which I shooed her off with a "Not not, later".

I don't lie to my kids, and it's a major point in our house that if we can't be honest with each other what's the point. For the first time though, I am tempted to text DH, get him to buy a bear for her, and go stick it in the attic and say it must have been there since the move.

What would you do?

Dumbass thread, I know, but I really am not looking forward to telling her much as we adored her, we never quite got round to doing all the things we did with DD1.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
ingles2 · 25/02/2009 12:38

That sounds like a happy ending for dd2
I would've lied though and bought a bear...
In fact recently, we were looking through pictures, usual story, loads of ds1 none of ds2. So I took half of them out of the album for ds1 and told ds2 they were him!

EllieG · 25/02/2009 14:17

What a nice ending - snigger is honest and snigger DD2 feels happy. Ahhh - it warms the old cockles it does....

snigger · 25/02/2009 14:53

Snigger was asked this morning if we bought DD2 anything while she was a baby.

For a moment I wondered if morningpaper had gotten to her.

OP posts:

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Danceaway · 25/02/2009 20:42

Does anyone else wonder what a dog ugly bear looks like? Am I wrong to feel sorry for the bear??
I used to have a bear with close together eyes and was fond of him till DH called him Mr Inbred Bear one day and the name just stuck.

stealthsquiggle · 25/02/2009 20:46

Danceaway - DD has 'roadkill bear' (intensely trendy sheepskin thing beloved of babies of slebs, apparently ) - he will be forever 'roadkill bear' in our house.

EllieG · 25/02/2009 21:59

My DD has 'roadkill mouse' - is pink and very flat and she sucks it's nose. Is revolting and have had to buy two so can occasionally wash them.

PortAndLemon · 26/02/2009 13:37

I shall have to keep checking back for pictures of "dog ugly bear" now...

yellowflowers · 26/02/2009 14:09

If you have enough money can you afford a bear factory trip for both of them so they both get a special bear - and lie too and find an old bear in the attic so she doesn't feel hard done by. I bet they both end up liking their own bear factory bear more.

snigger · 26/02/2009 14:58

As soon as DogUgly gets here I'll post a picture

OP posts:
TooFoggy · 26/02/2009 17:23

I would get a Steif bear from Past Times and tell her it was so expensive she hasnt played with it yet and thats why she hasnt seen it.

FrannyandZooey · 26/02/2009 18:12

i think you did it right
the thing is, you can't remove all perceived favouritism for the rest of her life, no matter how hard you may try
the fake bear would have been a lie and you would have felt guilty and it wouldn't have addressed the real problem which is that sometimes, she will feel different to her sister and may wonder if she is as much loved
byou CAN reassure her about that
that's all you need to do, not rewrite history

Sugarkane · 26/02/2009 18:49

Ok I have been in the situation with my mom, there are 100000 of pics of my sister and a few of me, I know it sounds really silly but it kind of hurts, and all the family wind me up an laugh about it. It is such a small thing but could mean a lot to your youngest, so bite the bullet and get a bear up the loft ASAP. (God when I read what I have put it sounds so silly, but im only being honest).

SparklingSarah · 26/02/2009 20:43

I have a similar thing
my DD is going on 7 and my DS is 10 months

with her it was all a bit oh ah flap and him I'm like oh yea they were both born at home
but she was not planned to fall out over the sofa so I have film of him being born and photos just minutes old and with her it took 'til the next day for me to think oh yea shit baby photo!
so she gets a bit crestfallen I guess at times about the "differences"

I was SO worried that she'd think we loved him more or all that jazz but I was very honest with her and embellished life a little.
So I tell her I love them both because they are them

AT 6 yes she is a bit young for ins and outs
they are so very black and white.

However I really think get her alone sit with her and say look y'know sometimes things look better than they are your sister got the bear because the shop was right there and you didn't because we were just SO enraptured with your arrival.
Tell her that Minnie was bought for her special thing and ask her if she's like a bear now (possibly with year of birth on?)
as my daughter has a slightly unusual name I did an eBay search for the name and found a painting by an artist with the same name and bought that for her maybe something like that?

but seriously don't make it a huge deal or it will be a huge deal for her be gently honest.
if you buy a bear there will be no photos of him so then you really have lied, she will wonder why she's never met him

SparklingSarah · 26/02/2009 20:44

oh balls

I opened this page hours ago and didn't refresh so umm I'll just go hide pink faced in the corner...........

ruthosaurus · 03/03/2009 12:40

I crocheted a blanket and kept a pregnancy diary for my DS (3.5 months) and have now realised I either have to do this for any subsequent DCs or keep DS an only child. Having more DCs without their own blankets and diaries is obviously not an option, and to be fair DH did warn me about this.But hey, who needs sleep when you can be crocheting, eh? Anyone know if patchwork is faster?

DS also has more clothes and bears than we know what to do with but to balance it out we have not decorated his nursery yet. We use it as a box room. So any NSCs can be smug in the knowledge that at least they had a room to go into...

New posts on this thread. Refresh page