Found this thread last night. I am in this quandary right now. Dh has agreed, finally, to the idea of it, although I have neer pushed too hard as I am not sure myself. I'm just not sure I DON'T want another.
Have 2 DSs, 2 and a half and 4 and a half. Both will be at school by next Sept. Have been back at work for about a year and love it. Life is easier by the day. Sleep is fine, they eat well, no buggy, no nappies, can leave the house at the drop of hat (well nearly!)
I do want another child in theory. But if I am being completely honest and pragmatic, I really don't think DH could cope. He is not the most patient man, and not the most natural father to babies. He is starting to come into his own now that the boys are getting bigger and join in in jobs round the garden, fishing, football etc. He can't cope with puke, poo, screaming. The stress in our house and in our marriage is less now that we don't have to creep around trying not to wake the baby, argue over who's had the most/least sleep, argue over who does the most childcare (I do but mind less now that it is easier).
Knowing all this as I do, is it really fair to up the stress and tension levels again by going back to square one with a newborn? And could I cope with it all again anyway?
With rose tinted specs and after a few glasses of wine we both agree it would be nice to have a bigger family, we discuss names, we agree that Dh might mellow if he had a daughter for example, he agrees he's have to do more with the boys. But in the cold light of day are we just kidding ourselves.
Like a previous poster, I also think about this everday...