Lessons will be learned. When exactly?
Caroline Carberry KC, Batool’s barrister, described Sharif as a “manipulative, serial abuser of vulnerable women” and an “abuser of children … over many years as confirmed in police and social service records”.
The trial heard Sharif had previously been arrested on suspicion of assaulting a baby and a child. He had also been arrested for allegedly abusing three unconnected Polish women, including Sara’s mother, Olga Domin, with the first claim dating back to 2007.
In each of those three cases, Surrey police said an investigation was carried out but there was insufficient evidence to proceed and
Sharif was released without charge.
Sara was placed in the care of her father after a custody hearing at Guildford family court in 2019 despite concerns for years about the potential risk he posed.
DCS Mark Chapman, from Surrey police, told the Guardian the force’s contact with the family “goes back some years”. He said details of the contact were “properly referred into the custody family court hearing around [the] placement of Sara”. He said there had been no further contact with Surrey police after that.
Surrey county council is understood to have supported Sara’s return to her father in 2019 because that had been her preference.
Sophie Francis-Cansfield, the head of policy at the charity Women’s Aid, said the case highlighted “a devastating failure” to safeguard children at risk.
She said: “Sara Sharif’s story is a devastating reminder of the consequences when red flags are ignored and children’s safety is not prioritised in family court decisions.
“Before Sara was even born, there were alarming warning signs. Her father had been accused of abuse by three women, and Sara was placed under a child protection plan at birth – clear evidence of significant risk. Yet, despite multiple signs of ongoing harm, the system failed to act decisively. Instead of ensuring her safety, family courts prioritised reunification at the expense of her life.”
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/dec/11/sara-sharif-father-stepmother-found-guilty-murder