Former RG STEM admissions tutor here. My School has a very high offer and hasn’t been in Clearing for a while.
So many good posts above that I will beg forgiveness for failing to cite individuals below.
This is absolutely about bums on seats and it is a double edged sword. Marvellous when you can trade up, or to prevent being victimised by ‘a stinker of a maths paper’ (great phrase).
Otherwise I do urge ruthless honesty when using Clearing, for reasons PP have alluded to. Some candidates who are well prepared for their exams do fail to show their true colours for reasons that won’t recur. These are the ones who can benefit from trading up.
Those without great study habits or who have worked hard for their results should be more cautious for different reasons. A few do turn over a new leaf at uni, which is very gratifying to watch, but they are a minority. And those who worked hard but didn’t make the grades are better off in a programme designed for them. Why bump along at the bottom of your cohort when you could thrive elsewhere, with appropriate teaching?
There are many excellent, suitable degree programmes around the UK. I always enjoy learning about them on this Board.
Case in point: PP said that Liverpool Maths is accepting BBC in Clearing. The difference between grades A and B in Maths AL is huge and the pedagogy at Liverpool Maths will be designed for grade A students. I honestly wouldn’t want DC there as a grade B student.
I agree with statements that the whole thing is a mess.