My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: "Children are at terrible risk if the family courts don't put their safety first" (Warning: upsetting content)

108 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 20/01/2016 10:04

I'm sharing my story in support of the Women's Aid Child First campaign, which calls for children's safety to be placed above the desires of an abusive parent for contact with their child. I want to highlight the catastrophic consequences that can occur when the family court judiciary does not do this.

It took just 15 minutes on the 22nd October, 2014, for my life and heart to be broken completely beyond repair. I had warned those involved with my case that my happy, funny boys would be killed by their own father; I was right.

My boys were both with their father on that October day, and at around 6.30pm he enticed Paul, nine, and Jack, 12, up to the attic, with the promise of trains and track to build a model railway.

When the boys were in the attic, he lit 16 separate fires around the house, which he had barricaded, so my sons could not get out and the firemen could not get in.

Only 15 minutes later, at 6.45pm, the doorbell rang at my mum's. (We were staying there temporarily after the separation.)

"It's the boys, they must be early," my mum said - but I knew that wasn't right. The boys would have run into the house and straight into my arms; they always did after a visit to their dad. They were frightened of him - he was a perpetrator of domestic abuse. The statutory agencies involved in our case knew this.

I opened the door. Blue lights were flashing.

"There's been an incident at your former home; the boys have been involved in a fire."

Running into the hospital, the first thing I saw was Paul receiving CPR. A doctor, drenched in sweat and exhausted, told me they were withdrawing treatment.

I held Paul in my arms. I begged him to try, to stay, to not leave me.

He looked at me, smiled, and the life left his beautiful blue eyes. His hair was wet with my tears as I kissed his nose. Then Paul, my boy, was taken out of my arms and into another room. There was no further chance of touching him; his little body was now part of a serious crime enquiry.

Detectives arrived and informed me that my former husband was responsible for the fire, and that he'd also died. All this time I wasn't allowed to see Jack, as they were still fighting to save him. Thankfully, he never knew that Paul had died. He'd tried to save his little brother.

The police later disclosed that Jack was still conscious when carried out of the fire and told them: "My dad did this and he did it on purpose." This was taken as his dying testimony.

Jack clung to life for five days but his battle was too big for him to fight. His body had suffered 56% burns. On the 27th October, he too died in my arms after suffering a cardiac arrest due to his horrific injuries.

No more children should die at the hand of a parent. Social services and Cafcass (which represents children in Family Court cases) were found lacking in their duty of care to Jack and Paul. They offered little or no support to me in the months leading up to their murder. Failings have been highlighted; lessons must be learned.

Jack and Paul's father was a known abuser. One official involved in the case refused to assess him alone, because she didn't feel safe doing so. Why, then, was he allowed unsupervised, unsafe contact with my boys? Even though we'd separated, the abuse hadn't ended. This was not taken on board by the Family Courts. He wanted to take everything from me, and he did. The boys' right to safety - to life - should have outweighed their father's desire for contact.

I want to help other families going through the Family Courts and trying to escape domestic abuse. I want to ensure all children enjoy a safe future. Every child matters. It's too late for my boys, but not too late for others. The Women's Aid Child First campaign will help protect other children.

To sign the Child First petition and call for children's safety to be put back at the heart of the family courts, go to you.38degrees.org.uk/p/childfirst

To find out more about the Child First campaign, and download the report 'Nineteen Child Homicides', go to //www.womensaid.org.uk/childfirst

OP posts:
Report
Elendon · 20/01/2016 21:13

I listened to you speak this morning on Women's Hour. I've signed. You are doing such wonderful work by highlighting this. The vibrancy of the memory of your beautiful boys was clear as you talked about them.

May this campaign be successful.

Report
ScrambledSmegs · 20/01/2016 21:16

I've signed. I'm so very sorry for your loss, and for the heartbreak you've been through and are still going through. It should never have happened to you and your boys.

Report
Idefix · 20/01/2016 21:20

Signed.

No words can express the sorrow I feel for you.

Report
Devora · 20/01/2016 21:25

How brave of you to share this with us. I am so very sorry for your loss.

Report
DeAtHnOtE · 20/01/2016 21:26

I'm so sorry, Claire.

Signed, although it doesn't feel like enough.

Report
LikeASoulWithoutAMind · 20/01/2016 21:26

Signed.

I'm so so sorry for you and your lovely boys. You are so brave to share your story with us.

Report
RoystonVaseySmegHead · 20/01/2016 21:43

Have signed, knew the boys to say hello to and they were truly beautiful young people, so sad I can't imagine what you've gone through Flowers

Report
Badlittlesis · 20/01/2016 21:45

Signed and shared.

I can never understand why when a parent is known to be abusive against a partner/wife/husband, it's assumed that they won't do the same to the children?

It smacks of victim blaming to me. Yes s/he is abusive ..but only to you...not the children.

Sorry if I'm not been clear, but if it's in a persons nature to be abusive to one person, surely we should be making them prove that they not going to be abusive to others. Rather than assuming that they're only going to be abusive to partner/wife/husband. . . .

I wish I could be more articulate here but I'm full of cold, so I hope my meaning is coming through, that is my deepest sympathy, and my deep frustration that children are being hurt at the alter of someone else's rights

Report
lotsofdogshere · 20/01/2016 21:45

So brave of you to share your story, I ve signed the petition. I agree the focus on contact except in very rare circumstances is just wrong and dangerous

Report
Whoknewitcouldbeso · 20/01/2016 21:54

Signed. I have no words for how tragic and terrible your story is. I'm so sorry for your loss 😣

Report
GloGirl · 20/01/2016 21:57

I am so desperately sad for you Claire, and your beautiful boys. I have signed Flowers

Report
SisterConcepta · 20/01/2016 21:57

So so sorry. Thanks
Signed

Report
BertieBotts · 20/01/2016 21:59

I've been reading the Women's Aid report and it is sobering, even though they have avoided any specific details and kept it very anonymous.

The last 10 year report (1994-2004) was called 29 Child Homicides, this year's, which covers the following 10 years, is called 19 Child Homicides. It sounds like a big drop but 13 families were bereaved in the first report and 12 families were bereaved in the most recent one. That is ONE less family who have had to go through this. That is sickening. This is DESPITE changes made in legislation as a result of the first report. It is shocking. Only one family less in ten years. Radical change is needed.

Report
TwoLittleBlooms · 20/01/2016 22:04

I am so sorry for the loss of your beautiful, brave boys. I have signed the petition.

Report
clairemum22 · 20/01/2016 22:06

I'm so very sorry for your loss. I have signed.

Report
Dontyouopenthattrapdoor · 20/01/2016 22:11

I had my first ever experience of CAFCASS last year. Some of the recommendations they made were staggering, and flew in the face of what everyone else involved was saying, families and professionals alike. And yet they hold so much sway in court. I live in fear of a similar call. I'm so very very sorry for what happened to you. Thank you for sharing this. I will sign x

Report
Illyillyilly · 20/01/2016 22:12

I am so sorry for the loss of your boys. I cannot even begin to imagine. I've signed, this is so so important.

Children don't have the power to stay away from a parent that is abusive. What sort of system allows children to have no power over who they spend time with? They're still seen as property, as something to be passed around, and not people in their own right.

I'm rambling, and I know that's only half the problem, there's a whole group of children that can't see the abuse, that don't think it's that bad. It breaks my heart.

Report
sminkypinky · 20/01/2016 22:13

Those poor boys, I'm so sorry Flowers I have signed the petition.

Report
LuluJakey1 · 20/01/2016 22:40

I have signed. Just awful and completely avoidable. I work with children and have been a designated teacher for safeguarding. Children do not come first with social services in my opinion- they wait in line behnd caseloads, social worker's frequent holidays, days off and absences, the rights and needs of adults and endless policies, procedures, broken promises and light touch social worker input.

Report
Mediumred · 20/01/2016 23:30

I've signed. So very very sorry for the loss of your beautiful and brave boys.

Report
fusspot66 · 20/01/2016 23:41

Signed. I'm sorry for the loss of your lovely boys.

Report
Baconyum · 21/01/2016 02:15

You are so brave and so strong for supporting this campaign.

My own experience of cafcass was that they assume the mother is bitter and wants to with old the child/ren for revenge reasons and the father is hard done by. I also happen to know of a case where the father served 5 years for repeated sexual abuse of his daughter and then was awarded unsupervised contact by a judge upon release from prison, seriously what planet are these people on?!

I have signed the petition but would like to be able to sign an official government petition. I hope the campaign is successful and ideally that known abusers simply don't get unsupervised access. As is often said on here they don't change they just get better at concealing who they really are.

Report
ChipsandGuac · 21/01/2016 04:40

I honestly wish MN would stop putting things like "Trigger Warning" and "Upsetting Content" on this kind of thing. OF COURSE it's upsetting! Everybody should be making sure it just doesn't happen anymore.

Report
differentnameforthis · 21/01/2016 07:47

ChipsandGuac

of course it is upsetting, but those who have been/are going though similar, have the right to be warned that content will be upsetting & that it may trigger them.

Demanding that MN stop is denying people who are suffering/have suffered, the right to protect themselves by not clicking!

Report
differentnameforthis · 21/01/2016 07:49

I have signed too, op. I am so very sorry for your loss, and that your weren't believed when you tried to warn people about this.

Your boys & you paid the ultimate price, that no one should have to pay, because not one person stood up to defend you!

That's beyond shit!

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.