teresa ds suddenly started saying he prefers the "other one" as well. I think the offer grades are completely distorting in his mind where he actually wants to go. He keeps thinking the more difficult offer is automatically preferable, just because it is higher (a status issue?) whereas in fact the lower offer might be a better bet for him.
And suddenly he has lost confidence that he might make the cardiff offer at all, so I cannot determine whether he even wants to go there if he DID make the offer.
It is a bit like choosing a life partner perhaps, when you are presented with three suitors at once, one has a flat, one doesn't but might make lots of money, one is incredibly attractive - who on earth do you choose, let alone which one makes you laugh...and lives round the corner..
It really is absurd. I have no idea, ds has no idea, all the choices are good, but all have cons...