Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Brexit

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Brexits Arms - To GE or Not to GE that is the question?

999 replies

time4chocolate · 26/10/2019 17:26

Will the man from del monte say yes on Monday or will he leave a lot us doing this.....again

Brexits Arms - To GE or Not to GE that is the question?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
time4chocolate · 26/10/2019 21:38

Well this is certainly not me!!

Drop a peanut down my frontage and it’s hitting the floor before I’ve even had a chance to grab itGrin

Brexits Arms - To GE or Not to GE that is the question?
OP posts:
HateIsNotGood · 26/10/2019 21:41

Ok no worries the frumpster I understand now - you've got shitty tits and your salad isn't much better. That's really fine., It's getting a bit chilier and not so salady in the UK anyway. It happens every year, the shitty, cold, damp weather - that the actual full yime UK residents live with every day of every year.

What fools we are, for living here, when we could be somewhere else - cheaper and warmer - but we stupid, thick Brits don't desert our shores.

Epicwaffle · 26/10/2019 21:43

Haha, @time4, I always pictured you more as a Peggy than a Bet lynch!

DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 21:56

My brextits are typically full of crumbs.
I keep a dustbuster handy by the bed to clear up when I take my bra off at night 😉

What do I think will happen?

GE blocked, lots of dithering & waffle about not trusting BJ & no deal being taken off the table, Blackford huffing about the reckless Tory government, Corbyn doing the sniff & saying 'bring it on, the Tories are scared' about a GE whilst whipping to block it, Soubry banging on about giving the people a say, Peter Bone making some nonsensical intervention about how marvellous the UK is, BJ baiting & goading whilst saying nothing much & Bercow repeating the same done-to-death lines about soothing medicaments & using 100000000000 words when he could have used 10.

Macron will fall into line, extension til end of Jan & Parliament will carry on blocking everything & holding govt hostage.

End of Jan we'll be back at the same point as now, with another Parliament-forced extension request 🤷🏻‍♀️

Bearbehind · 26/10/2019 22:17

dusty I think you’ve pretty much nailed it with that prediction.

DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 22:20

I've actually catapulted myself into a deep depression after writing that 🐻 😩😩😩

Bearbehind · 26/10/2019 22:32

Go to bed and hoover your boobs 😂😂😂

time4chocolate · 26/10/2019 22:33

Right, I need some assistance as I think I may have zoned out at some point last week (for my own sanity) but where in Boris' deal is the threat of leaving on a no deal that JC refers to? Are we talking time wasting?

OP posts:
time4chocolate · 26/10/2019 22:35

Go to bed and hoover your boobs 😂😂😂

OMG😂😂😂!!

OP posts:
DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 22:48

😂🐻

Walkingdeadfangirl · 26/10/2019 22:49

but where in Boris' deal is the threat of leaving on a no deal that JC refers to?
Its more the case that Boris and the EU might not agree on a FTA in a few years time and then we agree to disagree and leave with no deal in 2022. Corbyn is just throwing out a red herring to cover for his incompetence.

Parker231 · 26/10/2019 22:50

Now what’s going on?

Brexits Arms - To GE or Not to GE that is the question?
DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 22:51

As far as I can understand his incoherent garbage...

The threat is present for 2 reasons:

  1. If vote for GE under FTPA passes, then BJ could unilaterally 'change the date' of election to after 31st Jan (or whenever extension runs out)
  1. If they pass the WAB, then there is a threat of no deal happening at end of transition period if no future arrangements deal is reached

Obvs this is all predicated on the notion that BJ desperately wants no deal, even though he literally negotiated TM's deal & is desperately trying to get it passed 🤷🏻‍♀️

DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 22:57

😮 Parker!!

This is no bad thing actually - they're basically assuring the EU27 that there would def be a GE if they offer a hard 31st Jan & no leaving before then

This means we could get a much needed GE & all parties campaign on their various clarified Brexit positions
Tories will presumably campaign on BJ's deal

As far as optics go - Parliament will again block Brexit (WAB) and GE on Monday, and it's clear that opposition parties are dictating the delay not BJ

Could be a win-win situation for Brexit (even though delayed) 🤞

GreenishMe · 26/10/2019 23:00

....is there a point at which the merry go round has to grind a stop?

I mean, the whole point of the 3 month extension is to wreck the deal as it stands, so presumably another extension will be needed at the end of Jan because the amended deal won't be agreed and so on and so on .....

Is it possible to run out of extensions or can it carry on indefinitely?

time4chocolate · 26/10/2019 23:00

Thanks Walking
So he is thinking ahead to 2022 and the possibility of no deal, when we could in fact have a no deal situation at end of Jan 2020 but that’s not his immediate concern?

OP posts:
DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 23:07

Everything is up in the air if GE before WAB passed Greenish

I'm unsure if opposition are going to insist that WAB is put on ice til after the GE - I think they might because we can't revoke A50 once it's passed & ratified by us & EU.

So they're gambling everything on a remain or hung Parliament being returned in GE I think 🤔

Dusty01 · 26/10/2019 23:08

Dusty Diamond - why do you want us to Brexit?

I voted to leave, but it was as a protest vote against Austerity. I've been persuaded I was wrong and that all Leavers are evil. I see the logic behind remaining now and can't understand why I ever voted to leave - but also do not believe that all Leavers can be stupid or bad.

Are there positives to leaving?

DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 23:12

Peston on what the SNP & Lib Dems are seeking to do:

www.itv.com/news/2019-10-26/snp-and-lib-dems-unite-to-force-december-general-election-writes-robert-peston/

Parker231 · 26/10/2019 23:18

Problem with a December election is postal votes getting lost or delayed due to the Christmas post and quick elections usually mean overseas voters are not given the opportunity to vote which is totally wrong.

time4chocolate · 26/10/2019 23:19

Greenish - EU I don’t think will give us indefinite extensions so it will have to end at some point (I hope).

OP posts:
Walkingdeadfangirl · 26/10/2019 23:30

we could in fact have a no deal situation at end of Jan 2020 but that’s not his immediate concern?
Yes in reality your right but of course its all a smoke screen to stop an election.

they're basically assuring the EU27 that there would def be a GE if they offer a hard 31st Jan Only they dont have that within their power, only Labour does. So they will know full well that a 31st Jan extension would have to be extended again.

Interesting they never signed the letter ;) petulant children

It also demonstrates that the UK has zero sovereignty over its own elections. The losing parties can just appeal to a higher authority to ban the UK from having an election or enacting the result of an election.

The UK is now ruled by the EU and we have to ESCAPE by any means possible.

DustyDiamond · 26/10/2019 23:56

Are there positives to leaving?

Hi fellow Dusty 👋 😊

It depends what measures you use to define 'positives' tbh

For me personally, I've been vaguely Eurosceptic since early 90s. Was vaguely aware back then of the ERM debacle & John Major signing us up to the Maastricht Treaty & putting us on the path to an integrated Europe & single currency.
(It's only years later I actually looked into it all in more detail)

The accession of Eastern European countries in the 2000s made me more hardened against the European project as one size does not fit all - there is a place for a trading block of nation states, but not a federation of unequal parties.

The rapid advancements in technology etc & the subsequent shrinking world over the last few decades were unprecedented & big trading blocks such as the EU were less of a good idea in a globalised arena - better to have the ability to be agile, dynamic & competitive as an autonomous nation state in my view.

Gordon Brown signing up to the Lisbon Treaty was the point at which I became a hardened Eurosceptic. It was the EU constitution in all but name, and we had been promised a ref on it & then were denied it.

I do not want to be part of a federal Europe, I do not like that our Parliament is not the independent, sole & final arbiter of our affairs.

I think our MPs got lazy & inept over the last few decades because they were less accountable due to EU supranational governance. They rubber stamped everything & threw their hands up because 'it's been mandated, we have no choice 🤷🏻‍♀️' which was mostly incompetence & laziness on their part (imo)

I also hate that we are dictated to as to how to spend our own recirculated money (as a net contributor)
I did not want 'ever closer union'
I do not approve of the opaque & convoluted way that the EU is managed & run
I do not approve of the wastage that goes on such as the unnecessary schlepping between Strasbourg & Brussels

The slogan from the ref rang true with me: take back control of borders, laws, money, waters & sovereignty.

For me, they are the positives of leaving - we will be the masters of our own destiny & the people we directly elect to run our country, & who are directly accountable to us will be in control. We can directly kick them out if they let us down.

These reasons may not be 'positives' to you, but they are to me - & I understand that my reasons may seem intangible or ideological to you.
Nonetheless, your reasons for wanting to remain are just as important & valid to you as mine are to me (to leave)

Where I am now, is that I want democracy to be upheld & this is more important to me than anything else at the moment.
I'd like the WAB to pass as I think it provides a stable transitional arrangement with immediate freedoms from the EU.
I am not an advocate of no deal, not at all, but if it came to it then I would take that over revoke & remain.

Massive essay, sorry, but I tried to explain as much as poss instead of a flippant soundbite for a change...

Dusty01 · 27/10/2019 00:12

Thank you for your long explanation - other Dusty.

I am trying to get my head around the 'other' way of thinking and this is really helpful. Obviously there are many different 'other' ways of thinking.

You know more about the details of our relationship and history with the EU than I do.

I worry that if/when we leave the EU our standards will fall and that we'll be more aligned to the US. Is that something you think might be a problem?

Also what I fear at the moment - more than actually leaving the EU - is the behaviour of our government. It feels that they are lying and dictating in a way that I never believed would be possible in this country. That doesn't feel like a democracy to me at all. And it feels as though that as time goes on it just gets worse.

DustyDiamond · 27/10/2019 00:25

Obviously there are many different 'other' ways of thinking.

There are loads...
Obvs I can only speak for me Smile

I worry that if/when we leave the EU our standards will fall and that we'll be more aligned to the US. Is that something you think might be a problem?

If there was a govt that reduced standards for eg workers rights, environment etc then we can boot them out - it's up to us who we put in power.
I suspect that if a govt did do such a thing the party would not be voted back in again - but if they did, then that would have been the choice of the electorate

I honestly think this is a scaremongering tactic though - our existing rights are better than the EU mandated minimums & if the 'nasty Tories' had been desperate to shred them they'd have done so already.

Also what I fear at the moment - more than actually leaving the EU - is the behaviour of our government. It feels that they are lying and dictating in a way that I never believed would be possible in this country. That doesn't feel like a democracy to me at all. And it feels as though that as time goes on it just gets worse.

What you feel about the govt is exactly what I feel about Parliament.

A remain-heavy, Brexit blocking Parliament with countless MPs having switched allegiance without a by-election & Labour MPs who vowed to respect & deliver on the ref result now campaigning for remain

Further, the absolute contempt they are showing of the electorate by holding a zombie govt hostage & refusing a GE

Swipe left for the next trending thread