Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Brexit

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

MNHQ here: results of our Brexit survey - 71% want another referendum

280 replies

RowanMumsnet · 04/09/2018 10:35

Hello

We ran a survey on Mumsnet in August-September; more than 2000 of you took part. We were asking about your thoughts about Brexit and whether there should be a second referendum.

We're releasing the results today, and they show that 71% said they wanted another referendum (although 26% don't).

60% of survey respondents said they felt misled by claims made by campaigners in the 2016 referendum, including 41% who said they felt misled by claims made by the Leave campaign and 18% who said they felt misled by claims made by both Remain and Leave.

Summing up, one respondent said 'I envisaged jobs, travel and opportunity, not having a potato delivered by the army.'

You can read all about it here.

Thanks
MNHQ

OP posts:
CardinalSin · 05/09/2018 09:42

"If a democracy cannot change its mind, it ceases to be a democracy."

  • David Davis (yes, that one)
jasjas1973 · 05/09/2018 10:27

Wanting another referendum is IMHO because only since the referendum and results have facts become either apparent or widely publicised

No one is suggesting we have another re-run of the 2016 referendum, it would be a vote on the deal.

Its shocking that people just accept corruption in British politics as being perfectly ok and something to do absolutely nothing about.

CardinalSin · 05/09/2018 10:59

"Its shocking that people just accept corruption in British politics as being perfectly ok and something to do absolutely nothing about."

^^ This. Very much this.

surferjet · 05/09/2018 11:07

Its shocking that people just accept corruption in British politics as being perfectly ok and something to do absolutely nothing about

We don’t accept it - that’s why the British people demanded a referendum on its future with the EU & voted to leave.
Isn’t democracy wonderful Smile
#BorisforPM.

topcat1980 · 05/09/2018 11:16

"Isn’t democracy wonderful smile"

It is, but you think using an advisory referendum to force through policies which weren't on the ballot is democratic. Nor do you believe in the democratic processes of the country.

You called people traitors for upholding constitutional law.

You only like democracy when it suits.

surferjet · 05/09/2018 11:39

What was on the ballot?

Nothing.

Just do you want to leave the EU.

Yes or No.

More people said Yes.

What happens after that is up for debate yes. But some remainers want the result overturned no matter what.
They are traitors yes. 100%

topcat1980 · 05/09/2018 11:42

Thanks for enforcing that my critique of you is correct.

Democracy only when it suits.

1tisILeClerc · 05/09/2018 11:43

@Surfer, see my post immediately before yours and take it up with MNHQ

surferjet · 05/09/2018 11:47

Democracy only when it suits
& remainers know all about that of course, being experts in it.

topcat1980 · 05/09/2018 11:49

No you do.

Democracy - but not when the House of Lords (a key part of our parlimentary democracy) does what you don't like.

Democracy - except for when the judiciary uphold constitutional law.

Democracy- the ability to campaign for 41 years after a lost referendum but shout down anyone who challenges when the result goes your way.

Hypocrite.

1tisILeClerc · 05/09/2018 12:08

So if you go to the dentist to have a filling, and while you are there the dentist decides that all your teeth look a bit 'gammy' so whips them all out, you would be fine with that?
The question 'do you want to leave the EU' should have qualified HOW MUCH of EU legislation do you want to abandon, bearing in mind how much the UK is/was entwined in the EU.

jasjas1973 · 05/09/2018 12:14

What happens after that is up for debate yes. But some remainers want the result overturned no matter what

Having a debate on if there should be a vote on the terms of exiting the UK, is exactly that...debating what happens after we leave the EU.

If you and other remainers are so sure of your position, why are you so afraid of giving the people a say on the type of this exit?

Though how Brexit sorts out corruption in the UK escapes me, you Sufferjet, are putting your faith in UK politicians, who have consistently failed to build this country into the sort of place we can all be proud of.

Icantreachthepretzels · 05/09/2018 12:35

I didn’t take part in the survey because I didn’t even see it.

I therefore demand a re-run.

sticky in active
Why are so many leavers intent on advertising that they can't see what is as plain as the nose on their face?

And I'm sure you understand that this joke is not an accurate parody of remainers? No one is saying - 'we didn't know about the vote do it again'
we're saying:

  • the leave campaign told outright lies *it was illegally funded
  • information on voters was illegally mined by Cambridge Analytica
  • There was Russian involvement (links between the embassy and Aron Banks) *since the vote, said Russians have attempted to murder a former spy on British soil - endangering the British local population as well as committing an outrageous act of encroaching on our borders (once upon a time - this would have meant war.) These Russians - they are not our friends.
  • The vote was split amongst generational lines, with younger voters preferring to vote remain. These are the people who will have to live with the legacy and effects of brexit the longest - and they never wanted it.
  • we were told (by Liam Fox) that negotiations would be the quickest and easiest in the history in the world - but two years down the line we have accomplished nothing.
  • Due to no deal fears rising we now have i) the govt sending out technical notices to businesses telling them to stockpile food and meds. ii) businesses replying they don't have the warehousing space to stockpile - as in the single market we have used Just in time supply chains. iiI) Air companies telling us that (in event of no deal) we will fall out of the free skies agreement and that British pilots licenses will no longer be recognised and neither will our inspection methods of whether a plane is OK to fly. This means planes will be grounded. iv) in the light of this - holiday companies are putting in clauses in their small print that they are not liable if your holiday is cancelled as a result of brexit. v) trade agreements with America are going to involve us having to lower our food safety standards to match their own. Which means chlorinated chicken and hormone ridden beef. Vi) trade agreements with India and China are going to involve us having to agree to a lot more visas for their citizens - meaning higher immigration not lower. vii) meanwhile Japan has just signed a FTA with the EU - and will pull all their investment out of Britain if we don't stay in the single market. This means masses of job losses - and the knock on effect for the rest of the economy. viii) The NHS is on its knees due to a mass exodus of EU doctors and nurses. iX) Apparently vets will be in a similar position - as many of our vets are EU citizens. X) Businesses, banks, and EU institutions (the EMA for one) are all slowly trickling out of Britain. Taking jobs and money with them. XI) The fall in the pound has made living expenses even higher and things even more tight... this is on top of 8 years of austerity - and promise of worse to come as brexit hasn't even happened yet.

So in response to all that people are saying 'hmm maybe we should have a new referendum - where we get to choose between the terms of the deal and remaining. Where we get to decide if our lives will actually be better off in the EU or under the terms our Govt manages to secure. That sounds like democracy.'

Nobody is saying rerun the last one. We're asking for a different one - where the terms and conditions are known down to the last full stop.
I can see why that may be a terrifying prospect for the hardcore leavers and the terminally delusional. And why they would want to shut down even there merest suggestion of it. But that is not them being on the side of democracy.

2016: Do you want Britain to stay in the EU? Leave or Remain

Leave wins - 2 years of negotiotiating

2018: OK - here is what we will have when we leave. These are the terms. Are they acceptable? Do you believe your life will be better under these terms? Yes or No

Totally different questions - coming from a totally different place in time and events. Totally different referendum.
If we can't have this one, then we'll have to call the 2016 referendum null and void - because we voted on it back in the 1970s.

If you want to claim that things moved on and circumstances changed since the 1970s - so 2016 is legit - then the same is true for now (see my list).

There really isn't a democratic leg to stand on, denying the people a final say in the future of their country. But still we get this constant persistent belittling - which is always slightly inaccurate.

It really doesn't make the leavers saying it look very smart, I'm afraid.

1tisILeClerc · 05/09/2018 12:38

If the ERG/JRM/Fox contingent would actually put PROPER facts and economic projections on the table that can be verified by experts (those who actually know how the world system works) THEN a meaningful discussion could be had. They are full of trashing Mr Hammond's projections but offer NOTHING in return.
A trade deal with Africa, WHO HAS NO MONEY, as they are now indebted to China, is worth a 30th of the deals we already get with the EU and being part of the EU enables deals with 60 or more other countries.
If the UK wants to leave then cancel A50 immediately and start negotiating PROPER deals that can be brought into play in say 10 years time, as that is around the MINIMUM time span to do any significant deals.

surferjet · 05/09/2018 13:00

I’m not complaining about the survey.
It’s a meaningless ( completely predictable) bit of fun.
It’s along the lines of walking into a pub and finding out that 70% of people don’t mind a drink.

Icantreachthepretzels · 05/09/2018 14:56

No you're saying this

I didn’t take part in the survey because I didn’t even see it.

I therefore demand a re-run.

which is a poor and inaccurate attempt to parody and belittle the remainer view point.
I merely pointed out all the reasons it was an inaccurate parody - and therefore badly done.

RowanMumsnet · 05/09/2018 16:59

Hello - sorry not to respond sooner, has been a busy couple of days

On survey respondents' 2016 votes: the split was 76% Remain and 19% Leave (with the rest saying they didn't vote in 2016).

As to the question of whether we're going to campaign on this, we're a bit wary - the 26% who didn't want a second referendum (ie over one-quarter of respondents) translates into quite a lot of MNers and we know this topic is understandably one people feel really strongly about. We're loathe to actively campaign on something that a quarter of MNers strongly disagree with. Our campaigns have always been based on broad consensus and whatever your view on Brexit I think we can agree it's not often associated with the word 'consensus' Grin

In terms of talking to the media - yes we'll take those opportunities up where possible and communicate what the survey results tell us about what MN users think.

OP posts:
mummmy2017 · 05/09/2018 17:38

So of 2000 who voted..
1580 remain... 380 leave..

Less. Voted for new vote. 1420.. 520 didn't want another vote..

84 people who voted leave said they would now vote remain...
32 people who voted remain would now vote to leave...

CardinalSin · 05/09/2018 18:25

...if you believe them...

Hazardswan · 05/09/2018 19:04

Thanks @RowanMumsnet

If you dont mind me asking...What's the office consenus for a further survey of brexit? i.e finding out if there are specfics of brexit that unit mumsnet users more. Such as concerns over the issues raised in the technical notices, lack of warehouse storage, the just in time food supply system, medication stockpiling. These issues I would imagine go beyond who voted what and have the potential to get everyone on the same page.

Thanks again, I think it's great mumsnet is willing to talk to the wider world about what their users think. Gin

Buteo · 05/09/2018 19:16

26% who didn't want a second referendum (ie over one-quarter of respondents) translates into quite a lot of MNers

So if 26% of MNers who don’t want a second referendum is significant enough for MN to be wary, why isn’t the 48.1% of the electorate which voted who voted Remain significant enough to have a voice?

hamburgers · 05/09/2018 19:21

Ok I read the full data set.

98% of respondeants of the survey voted to Remain.

So no wonder the findings of the survey show strong support for a second vote Hmm

Buteo · 05/09/2018 19:31

Ok I read the full data set

No you didn’t.

You need to read the filters on the reported responses.

TheElementsSong · 05/09/2018 20:04

98% of respondeants of the survey voted to Remain.

Where the heck was that in the "full data set"?

TheElementsSong · 05/09/2018 20:07

Actually, it's quite funny. Seeing as almost 2 and a half hours earlier than the post claiming boldly that "98% of respondeants of the survey voted to Remain," RowanMN had already posted the actual survey split. So, top quality data analysis with "98% of respondeants of the survey voted to Remain" Grin