Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

The midwife who by her inaction killed my child has stood for election as parent governor at our school.

239 replies

Bubble99 · 25/11/2007 22:26

In February 2005 one of my full term and healthy twin sons was stillborn during an emergency cs. We had been admitted to a ward during the evening for induction of labour. Routine monitoring quickly showed that the twins were becoming distressed and (after the event) we were told that a consultant should have been called and a transfer to the labour ward arranged immediately. The MW responsible for our 'care' did none of these things, did not contact any doctors ( let alone a consultant) for two hours and was later proved to be negligent.

After the death of my son Mr Bubble had to carry on as normal. DT1/DS4 and I were in hospital for a week and Mr Bubble came to see us after he had dropped the older Bubble boys at school each morning. A couple of days after Bo (DT2) died, Mr Bubble said that he had seen the midwife at school and that he had wanted to scream and shout at her. I could not believe that this was possible and we both agreed that it must be someone who looked like her. He has continued to see 'her' for the last nearly three years but I haven't.

We now have vacancies for parent governors ( I am also a parent governor) and on the nomination forms sent home from school are the statements made by each prospective governor.

I recognised the name of one of them who says she is a 'healthcare professional' and it is the same name... I have just phoned our chair of governors and he has said that she "used to be a midwife."

I know that I will not be able to cope with sitting opposite this woman during meetings if she is elected and it will affect any of my dealings with her on governor business.

What should I do? I was re elected last year and really enjoy the role.

I'm sure I should be able to forgive and move on but it is still so raw and I don't know if I can work with someone who has had such a profound and awful influence on my life.

OP posts:
CarGirl · 25/11/2007 22:29

Can you speak to the chair of governors in confidence and ash them to make it known to the ex midwife who you are, she may be in ignorant bliss that you are a parent governer.

I really don't know what I would do but like you I don't think I could be a good governer working with someone who had had such a profound and awful influence on my life.

Greensleeves · 25/11/2007 22:29

Oh hell, how terrible for you

I don't know what I would do. I wouldn't want to give up being a governor myself either. Could you have a quiet word with the chair of governors, are you on friendly terms?

I hope someone else has better advice, you must feel shattered by this

NKF · 25/11/2007 22:29

An awful situation and I'm so sorry. Terrible to lose your son. I don't know what to say regarding the current parent/governor business. I'm not even sure that you were asking for advice. I hope things get better for you. It's the last thing you need. Not much help I know. I just wanted to send my sympathies.

Carmenere · 25/11/2007 22:30

How utterly hideous for you, I would write to her and ask her to withdraw her application for the reasons you have stated here. You certainly shouldn't have to resign or deal with her.

MaureenMLovesmincepies · 25/11/2007 22:31

Poor you! There is no time limit on when you feel you can forgive and move on, so don't feel like you should.

Surely, she would have to be 'voted in' by everyone first? (Sorry, don't know the ettique!) If you have a problem, then you must say something. I'm sure your views and your feelings would be taken into account by everyone else.

Pannacotta · 25/11/2007 22:32

What a dreadful, painful situation. So sorry that your son died and how awful to come across the MW in this scenario.
Agree with the advice from Carmenere, I'd do the same.

CarGirl · 25/11/2007 22:33

From her point of view if she doesn't withdraw surely she realised that people are going to find out about what has happened in the past and that she was found to be at fault, surely she will realise that it may be best all around to have some sensitivity and stand down.

DrSpeckschwarteSurprise · 25/11/2007 22:33

God, how awful.

I agree, perhaps if she was made aware that you are a parent governor she would remove her name from the list.

Strange though, would you not get a list of the present governers when you put your name down as a prospective governer?

handlemecarefully · 25/11/2007 22:34

Any Head Teacher worth their salt would approach the ex-midwife and ask her not to stand - wouldn't they? wouldn't they?

Tis human decency surely.

Think you should speak directly to the Head about it

wheresthehamster · 25/11/2007 22:35

Speak to the chair in confidence but as PGs are voted for by the parents I don't think you can influence the outcome. Obviously the chair can make sure you don't sit on the same committees but as you say it would be awkward at full meetings and other times. How horrible for you but, fingers crossed, she won't get elected.

Kewcumber · 25/11/2007 22:35

Bubble - how awful for you.

I agree that a letter directly to her saying that in the circumstances you are asking her to withdraw her application might do the trick. If she doesn't and you really feel that you cannot be on the board with her then you must explain to the head your position and offer your resignation. I suspect a word will be dropped in her ear.

I would be significantly more underhand in your position but will keep my despicable tactics to myself

edam · 25/11/2007 22:35

Bloody hell Bubble, that must have been a huge shock. Presumably she doesn't know who you are? I mean, that if she becomes a governor she will be working closely with the person she wronged so badly?

Agree with everyone who said a quiet word with the chair of governors is in order. Not to say 'this woman is evil', obv. but to say 'I cannot work with her'. Because no-one could expect you to.

ShinyHappyPeopleHoldingHands · 25/11/2007 22:36

Was she fired after Bo died Bubble??!

(((hugs))) to you. Sorry to be little help.. but I would also suggest a chat to the chair of governors. As a valued existing governor I would imagine your predicament would be taken seriously.

Wordsmith · 25/11/2007 22:37

Bubble, I remember what happened with Bo - it was heartrending.

I would make it known to her (either directly by letter or by asking the chair of Govs to make it known to her) that you are at the school and also a Governor - perhaps she doesn't know and would be mortified if and when she does.

If that doesn't work I would put the word out on the jungle drums at school. It may be that she would make a very good governor but I can't imagine many people voting for her if they knew your history.

What a horrible coincidence that she is a parent at your children's school too.

Aitch · 25/11/2007 22:38

what a terrible situation... i feel for you. would the chair of governors be sympathetic, do you think?

pooka · 25/11/2007 22:38

Yes, very odd that she isn't aware that you are you and unimaginable that she doesn't recall what happened.

I think you should have a word with the chair of the governors and ask if they can make her aware (or find out if she's applied regardless). If she is aware of who you are and wants to go on standing, well then I think (though of course cannot imagine your pain) I would stand down if she was elected. Cannot imagine that if she is elected, there would be any possibility of you being comfortable working together.

ShinyHappyPeopleHoldingHands · 25/11/2007 22:39

I dunno about the jungle drums Wordsmith...

onlyjoking9329 · 25/11/2007 22:39

how awful for you, you cannot be expected to be alongside this person, i would have a word with the headteacher.

RustyBear · 25/11/2007 22:39

I don't think that as a governor Bubble could write to a candidate asking her to withdraw - I think it would have to go through the chair (not the head teacher)

handlemecarefully · 25/11/2007 22:41

Sod protocol

Wordsmith · 25/11/2007 22:41

Dr Speck - it depends on the school how much parents know about the governors. I had no idea who the parent governors are at our school, they are not listed on the list of govs on the website. I stood for election myself last month - didn't get in and was told who did - but there has been no communication with parents as to who won the election. Communication at our school is shite, which is one of the reasons I wanted to get involved.

(sorry for mini hijack)

pooka · 25/11/2007 22:41

I also agree with SHPHH that not a good idea to spread the word/try and influence the election. Understandably tempting as it would be, I just think that it would be better not to.

funnypeculiar · 25/11/2007 22:41

I don't think anyone would expect you to be able to work so closely with her.
As others have said, I'd talk/write to chair & ask them for advice/request they operate as intermediary.
What happened to her after the incident? Assume she resigned/was dismissed? Can't imagine her getting voted in....
Not what you need, sorry

moondog · 25/11/2007 22:42

Jesus Bubble. What a nightmare.
I was thinkning about you today as I haven't seen you around for a while.
Bloody hell.

Wordsmith · 25/11/2007 22:42

Shiny... sometimes jungle drums is the only way anyone finds anything out! I agree it's not 100% ethical though.