Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Why do some parents think private school at primary is a waste of money.... but are secretly saving for secondary?

735 replies

Tallandgracefulmum · 27/06/2014 23:55

AIBU as my little one is starting prep school in Sept. I was asked by a friend at DD's nursery my plans, said private all the way and was told I would be wasting my money and should save it for secondary when it matters.

I hate this ..most parents I know would send kids private all the way through but cannot afford it so are saving for secondary. But to be honets if your not used to paying shed loads monthly for schooling, you will not suddently 7 years later ( and higher fees) start doing it for secondary.

What some people don't seem to get is that some parents value educational experience over material possessions or fancy homes. This friend in question said she will use the money she saves to provide education experiences for her children and give them a lump sum for uni.

My thoughts are she just can't afford it and wants to make me feel bad for spending my hard earned money.

How many parents actually compare a range of private school fees, then calculate how much it would cost to send one child then save the relevant monthly amount ready to give each off spring at 18? Doesn't happen. What's wrong in providing the best educational experience you can afford for your kids without others constantly telling me I am wasting my money.

FWIW I can understand private school bashers who hate all forms of private schooling, but not those who bash primary but would send kids to secondary in a heartbeat!

OP posts:
Ilovenicesoap · 28/06/2014 09:30

Maybe your DF is picking up on your "if you care about education you will send your DC to private" attitude and is being a bit defensive !

I had the option of buying a smaller house and sending DC to private school or buying the house we live in now and being in catchment for outstanding state primary and secondary< very lucky to have this option I know>. Its near to work so no horrendous commute either, so able to provide lots of support after school.
It has worked out for me precisely because of what zoe said up thread and I have an asset ,my house, to sell in the future.
Both older DC achieved outstanding results , youngest is still at school.

Caring about your DC education is about making the best choice with the resources you have available - so you and your friend are both doing what you think is best.

Mind you, I do think your DF is being a bit rude and I would reply "my money to waste !" Wink and leave it at that.

Sleepyhoglet · 28/06/2014 09:31

I think private at primary is so valuable. Not biased at all!

YouMakeMeHappy · 28/06/2014 09:42

Your friend sounds jealous. There's no reason not to fork out for primary.mwe are doing the same as your friend and only paying for secondary. Primary too would be the best bet but we've got three kids and plan on two more.

I think you are doing the right thing by your children and you should be proud.

campingfilth · 28/06/2014 09:44

I think your attitude of state schools is appalling and saying that people who choose them don't value education is again appalling. Maybe they feel that their children will do better at a state school with a wider variety of people.

My son's state primary that he is going to in september is far better than the local private schools apart from one. I think you need to educate yourself on why people choose state over private and stop belittling people about their choices.

I value education a lot but my son will be going to state schools your assumption that I do not care about his education is quite frankly offensive!

PecanNut · 28/06/2014 09:45

You sound like you've got a massive chip on your shoulder about this tbh.

Perhaps try to not to worry so much about what everyone else thinks. Probably most of them are making small talk and don't really care where you send your kids.

You've made a choice that you are happy with, let it be and stop criticising others for their choices.

ObjectionOverruled · 28/06/2014 09:46

Higheredserf , I am glad you made that point about generational effects. My father-in-law educated his kids at mediocre private schoosl and it would have seemed like a waste of money because they pretty much left with nothing. The last two have gone on to do very well, in a more roundabout route though which obviously took a little longer.

BUT, the next generation, almost all educated at very ordinary state schools throughout (no money for leafy suburbs or private education), but my goodness, they stand out from the crowd. Every one of them. Some compete nationally and internationally.

ObjectionOverruled · 28/06/2014 09:47

OP, you can't please all of the people all of the time.

AvonCallingBarksdale · 28/06/2014 09:58

As good as the grammars are, they take the best of the best students, but still cannot compare even to mediocre private schools
^ This made me laugh out loud. A mediocre school is just that - mediocre! It probably sticks in the craw somewhat more if you're paying for the privilege of going to a mediocre school, I would imagine. It's a grammar system round here, which has suited us fine, but there's no way I'd send DS to the local boys private - I have two friends, who are lovely but not very bright who teach there, and that's enough of a decider for me Wink
Anyway, to your OP, you do it your way, let your friends do it their way. Pas de probleme Smile

lljkk · 28/06/2014 10:00

I am impressed that a cleaner in London could afford even a mediocre private school for her children, even if she did work 7 days/week.

Tallandgracefulmum · 28/06/2014 10:01

Tween:

I went on my first holiday at age 13 thats when parents could afford it. Looking back, yes I wished for nicer fashionable clothes, holidays abroad, but to be honest. I am happy it was spent on education, now I can take my DC anywhere I want, do what I want. Sometimes parents sacrifice things for kids.

Whats wrong in forgoing holidays for 4/5 years if it means kids can benefit from that later on? Most young kids don't remember holidays when they are young anyway, even when looking through photos.

Roll:
I can state some "mediocre" in comparison to other top performing fee paying schools and the comparative grammars from my old neck of the woods. Consistently, the grammar as it does takes on the top academic pupils, gains better GCSE and A Level results.... YET the mediocre schools gain more passes to Redbrick (or Russell Group) and Oxbridge uni's why that is?

Because of my background and not being private all the way through, I still lack in some areas, might be silly things to some, but not the best in spelling, handwriting is a mess, can talk about my subject areas and area of work, but, arts, classics, other conversation starters, just don't know.

When I go to many posh events, people love to hear about my background, and how my parents must be proud. They are, their sacrifices HAVE changed the way my siblings and I live, the partners we met and married, the opportunities our own DC are having. But in mine and my brothers professions, we are few and far between.

I also don't agree that uni's are discriminating towards those from private schools, its media bluff to take the heat over those do choose to send their kids to the right school for them.
Until employers change the way they employ, the grades they require it will still be those from elite uni's and private schools.

OwlCapone:
Fine your choice for your kids, but if you had friends who questioned your choice and called you stingy would you not get offended, maybe if you were a stay at home and they said you could work for it?

Thats my point, my people, my friends, think I am wasting good money on these kids for primary and should only do it for secondary or other view, if I could maintain my own luxuries. Whereas I have happily given them up.

Happy, I get some of this too from friends. I guess I should just ignore the comments, hard to though. Word, thank you. I am getting used to these comments now, better get ready.

If I can say, my mum and dad now have moved, but I still go to visit family who still live on the estates back in SL and when I drive through ( came from a Peckham Estate) I can honestly say, I am glad I do not live there anymore. I know some fab clever people who are kids were who were brill at maths, sport or drama or knew something about everything, but alas are still living in Peckham, working in the local shops or unemployed. Many of the schools we would have gone to had DM not work her arse off, have closed down, or changed to Academies, some rough old schools where the kids wanted to succeed but the teachers treated the place as a stop gap, and WOULD tell kids they'd amount to nothing. Not sure that could happen now, they might be sacked ( I'm 34), I feel humbled that I have the DM I do, if I my Dad was my mum and vice versa, not sure where I'd be.

This is why when some tutors or teachers say bright kids will shine wherever and with supportive parents is nonsense, those kids slip through and are few and far between.

When some say to not spend my money on luxuries, but on education for primary is a waste of money, does anger me, thats where I see the value.

I feel they are waiting for the time for me to make a complaint about the school, or an issue, so they can say... see, private was a waste of money etc.

catkind:

You don't know my background if you think I think people who don't choose private education don't value their childrens education. I am saying I have very good friends who I am now questioning our friendship as I get it all the time I am wasting my money, stopping having a full life by giving up my pleasures just for private school. Yet these same mothers have said they want private school, primary is a waste and they can't afford it and they do many of the above and more. My DF said, she would/should do as her DS loves sport but the current school is lacking, but not enough to stop going to the gym, eating out and getting her hair done, plus the odd Ted Baker dresses. What am I to say to that? Nothing, but defend my ground, because I came from nothing and now my future has changed, and that of my childrens.

Have you grown up with the light going off because the electricity key has finished and your DM has not got the money till charge the electricity, always being told we were poor white trash because we lived on an estate and parents were uneducated, we had dreams, DM had dreams, but no one to help her, till she was an adult and mum and did not want us to live a life of poverty. I am grateful, because clever children will not do well anywhere, the right environment and encouragement makes the difference.

hmc:
Thank you, I think you are right. Of those that I know that make the snide comments etc, many have said to me before they could afford fees, but felt, their own ways were too hard to change i.e. too used to the gym. GP liked hair done and professional retouching, highlights and blow dries, need the weekly eating out with the other mums/ friends for a break ( expensive places, not a Costa or MD or the like), likes dry cleaning all her clothes even ones bought cheaply, personal trainer once a month, need the weekly cleaner, taxis to the station instead of the bus or walking. I do not judge them, but find it hard to hear that because I have given up the following to comfortably do so:

Expensive gym membership 300 per month
Hairdresser who used to do home visits once a month 100-150
Monthly dry cleaning (80) as less often no and hand wash delicates
L'Octtaine and Berts bees products monthly (45)
Make up - changed from YSL to Bobby Brown
Wait till I visit family back in SL before mending DH and my shoes, costs 12 where I live to have stilettos done and 4 per pair in SL
Eat out with the kids once a month, sometimes every 6 weeks, get presents for kids friends birthdays in advance (buy nice stuff at knock down prices)
Eat out with DH once every 2 months for a nice meal, tend to go during the day, so no need for additional babysitters, and use groupon and deals for nice places in London at fraction of cost
Family holidays where kids go free or using accumulated points or book year in advance.

When I got up what I used to spend on the above, now that was a waste of money as I don't miss it. Yes I do appreciate some people may not have nothing to cut back on, but my issue was friends think I am wasting my money and foolish to give up the above just for private education, one would send private in a heartbeat if she could still do the above and the other wants to educate privately from Y3/Y4 but does all of the above and states she cannot afford it?

Zoe:
clever, motivated kids with supportive families will probably shine wherever they go to school.. nope. Have you lived on a South London Council Estate where the local school has demotivated teachers who think all kids will end up as teenage parents or jailbirds by 21? We knew some really clever kids with supportive but uneducated parents, who did not do well as they did not have the "support in terms of knowledge" and contacts to help them get along, choose subjects wisely etc. So they just did not reach their potential and now work in min wage jobs now.

Lessons learned, cannot change people's attitude towards your choice, you just have to continue to do as you do.. Maybe I need to distance myself.

Thanks for the comments

OP posts:
Tallandgracefulmum · 28/06/2014 10:15

IIKK Yes is impressive.
My mum wanted Dulwich College but could not afford it, we went to St Dunstan's had some bursaries and older brother had an assisted place at a better school.
Lucky to be of the age where I just crept in with grants for my first 2 years at uni, before they stopped and the tuition fees came in.

Mum had to pay 50% of our fees took on early morning cleaning, my brother used to go with her to help her, worked in factory during the day and evening cleaned in the city again. Weekends did cash in hand work sold on East Street Market.

Then got a place to go to nursing school, but could not continue due to the fees, so changed route, and got qualified and got a professional job but still kept the cleaning morning and evening, but ditched the weekend jobs. We scrimped; we ate, but did not go on holidays just days out to Brighton or Blackpool which was fab. Mum bought a house which was run down in east Dulwich before it was trendy and now, enjoying retirement, but it was bloody hard, took hard work from all of us, too, paper rounds etc, helping mum with the cleaning etc.

Mum earnt more in the last 5 years of her working time than in the whole 40 years combined of her low paid working since the age of 14.

Just attitude that cleaners, bus drivers etc can't educate privately- people wonder how they afford it, by major sacrifice.

OP posts:
OwlCapone · 28/06/2014 10:21

Fine your choice for your kids, but if you had friends who questioned your choice and called you stingy would you not get offended, maybe if you were a stay at home and they said you could work for it?

Well, you have questioned the choice of everyone who chooses differently and effectively accused them of being stingy because they haven't given up X, Y or Z. I'm wouldn't be offended, I would just think that person has absolutely no respect for other people's choices and is probably a snob.

I am a SAHM. Money is not an issue - all three could have been put through private school for their entire school career without giving up anything. Where does that put me in your blinkered view of choices?

You seem to be unable to grasp that people would choose to sent their child to state school rather than private. Perhaps, rather than complaining about people who don't agree with your choice, you should remove your own blinkers and realise that your choices are not the right ones for everyone, they are only your choices. Private schools are not always better for the child.

AvonCallingBarksdale · 28/06/2014 10:23

I think you probably equate private education with "better" education, which, sometimes, it is and, sometimes, it isn't. Best not to judge either way, really. But I get what you're saying - and I think you're determined that your own DC will have more opportunities than you did. Nothing wrong with that, but just be happy with your own choices, and let others be happy with theirs, otherwise you risk getting terribly wound up and becoming a bit obsessive Smile

HercShipwright · 28/06/2014 10:47

OP - you mentioned your profession and your brother's but didn't specify what professions they are?

Tallandgracefulmum · 28/06/2014 10:55

Thank you Avon.

I can just recount my experience, private did change my life. I am still working class, done good. My DC though, that generation has changed for the better.

For those whose are from families where they live in nice houses in wealthy cathcments, where they can sell in the future etc etc, thats great, probally own DC don't need all the help they can get.

Kids from my old background, the only way out was attending a better school, in them days it was the privates, for people like me thats an aspiration, face it most grammar schools in inner city London were closed yonks ao, so to move on up out of benefits and council housing it was hope for bursary or assiated place and thats if your parents knew about it.

For middle classes, it was just a given the kids would go to uni, not need to educate privately as parents were well educated and could supplement at home, uneducated parents can't do that.

Object.. you are indeed right. I am not trying to please or to judge, I just hate that I get bashed at my school choice for primary thats all.

For exmple, friends aside, was at a party with DD where was introduced to one mum. Introducer said DD is going to such and such school. I got the ooh, why, where do you live, what about such and such school, interesting, does DD have special needs?

As Happy said in an earlier post, get used to stuff like that.

Have a great weekend all. :)

OP posts:
Tallandgracefulmum · 28/06/2014 11:04

Herc - we all work in law, professional services (accountancy and MC) arts and luxury sailing/boats.

My mums first job was at Anchor Butter factory.

My first real job was at a local solicitors firm. Big genrational change.

OP posts:
Ilovenicesoap · 28/06/2014 11:13

I agree that my DC didn't need to go to private school to get a good education- thats the point I was trying to make.
Maybe your DF feels the same way and has the confidence and skills to ensure her DC will do well.

I hope this doesn't sound unkind but you seem very insecure and don't seem to have gained much confidence from your time at PS.

Jinsei · 28/06/2014 11:16

OP, I can understand your choices and I think they are perfectly valid, but I do think you are making assumptions about private schooling because of your own personal experiences. Who's to say that you and your siblings wouldn't have done equally well if you had gone through the state system?

I think the one thing that clearly did make a difference for you and your siblings was the tremendous value that your parents put on education, the high aspirations that they had for you and the belief that you could make it. In your family, these values and aspirations were manifested by your parents making huge sacrifices to put you through private schools. In other families, those values and aspirations might express themselves in very different but equally effective ways.

I went through the state system myself, with very supportive parents. I was fortunate that both my primary and secondary education were very good. I went from my state comp to Cambridge, where I met people from both the state and private sectors. I have subsequently spent lots if time in both sectors in a professional capacity.

I base my views on my experiences, just as you base your views on your experiences. I have seen nothing to persuade me that it would be worth paying for private, even though we could comfortably afford it. Tbh, the only people I know who use private schools in my town are the ones who couldn't get their dc into my dd's state primary.

It's not about values. I would happily sacrifice all of my creature comforts if I genuinely thought that dd would get a better education in the private sector. In fact, it wouldn't even require a huge sacrifice, as we only have one dd. But actually, I prefer our state school anyway.

I think it's a perfectly valid choice to send your dc to a private school if you think that's the best choice for them, but I don't think you should make assumptions about why other people don't. They are rude to say that you are wasting their money, even if they privately believe that they are. But you would be equally rude to make the assumption that they've chosen not to use private primaries because they value their gym membership over and above their dc's education. It's just a different perspective.

Ilovenicesoap · 28/06/2014 11:18

Have confidence in the choice you have made OP.
As you say its your money and your choice.

The school years will be long and arduous if you let a few comments get to you Smile

ShineSmile · 28/06/2014 11:20

Personally if I had to choose between primary and secondary, I would send to primary. It will give them a good start to proper language skills, and it'll be easier for them to fit into a comprehensive secondary instead of a private secondary.

Mintyy · 28/06/2014 11:23

I think OP is utterly clueless about state education and I can't believe there are people willing to engage with her on this thread.

Your way or the Highway op? Ok fine, but don't come on here and bleat about it.

People are always going to argue against every aspect of private education - just let them do it and go back to your bubble.

HercShipwright · 28/06/2014 11:30

Ok. Well, I'm more than 10 years older than you. And I work in the city for an international firm. I grew up on a south London council estate, and I can assure you that you really aren't the only one at a high level in the professions who did so. I would also point out that I went to a comp, and then Oxbridge, so it certainly wasn't necessary - even earlier than your day - for someone from our sort of background to go to a mediocre private school to get on. Since you also raised the issue of your mum's working life - my mum had to leave school at 14 to go into service, after her parents died. Her mother was a traveller who settled (more like, ran away) and came to England (from Ireland). Generational leaps are quite common for people my age, certainly.

I think you are massively over-crediting going to a so so private school and understating your own and your siblings' personal achievements. It was the qualities you and they brought to the party that made you succeed, more than anything else. If you want to send your kids to private school then do so, it's your money. But it is neither necessary nor the only way to get a good education. And it's simply wrong to state that if you care about your kids' educations you send them private. My DDs go to/are about to start at a grammar school which is a far better school than the local private schools (although I work in the city I don't live anywhere near London any more). If I had sent them to the private schools instead that would to be honest be indicative of a priority set that didn't place quality of education first. This obviously isn't the same everywhere but it's a useful reminder that you shouldn't make sweeping generalisations. And nor should you judge people who make different decisions to you - we all have to do what is best for our own kids and we should try and do that without second guessing or denigrating the choices of other people - who will also be doing their best, in their own circumstances.

RainbowsStars · 28/06/2014 11:32

It all depends what you want out of life for your children, we don't all want the same. All of mine have been through/are going through state school and have been/are high achievers, with the money saved on school fees they are able to have a horse and do various out of school activities and have three holidays a year, none of which would be possible if we'd been paying school fees.

rabbitstew · 28/06/2014 11:32

Tallandgracefulmum - if you don't like others judging you, it's incredible you posted in such a judgmental way yourself. Don't do unto others, even on an anonymous forum, what you would not want done to yourself - it comes across as spiteful and two faced. You have clearly either chosen very materialistic friends for yourself (which says something about you), or are judging them unfairly and, by posting on here, appearing to judge random strangers, also, who might choose to mix state and private education.

Also, the way you talk about the sacrifices your mother made for you as though you wish to emulate her in every way, when she actually wanted something different for you, makes it sound almost as though you don't WANT to know that a state education actually might not ruin your children's future, because you would somehow feel guilty if you could get for free for your children what your mother had to make huge sacrifices for. The best education and parenting is not about the maximum parental sacrifice possible, it's about doing what you believe to be the right thing in your circumstances (not the circumstances your mother faced...). Sometimes parents have to make huge sacrifices for their children and sometimes they don't.

Jinsei · 28/06/2014 11:33

minty, I agree that she's clueless about state education, but what do you expect? Her mum nearly broke her back trying to send OP and her siblings to private schools because she believed that was the only way that her kids could make it. That's a pretty strong message, probably reinforced by the fact that the OP and her siblings have done better than the kids she knew growing up. The logic is flawed, yes, but it's easy to see why.