Please or to access all these features

Divorce/separation

Here you'll find divorce help and support from other Mners. For legal advice, you may find Advice Now guides useful.

39 years stolen by kindness, I don't know where to put my rage or process

255 replies

MoonSilverwing · 09/10/2026 23:44

In June I lost 39 years of a partnership, through what turns out to be the crulest kindness I have ever experianced. Not by a bad man, a kind man, a man who loved me in his way as a friend. A man who, after 10 years together, was offered two choices, neither of which would have taken me out of his life.

We had been togther 10 years (since I was 18 and he 23) We had known each other as friends since I was 13 and he 18. At 28 I said I wanted to have children with him. I said I understood if he didn't want children (he'd said as much before) and if that was his choice then I would go to a sperm bank. However if I did the latter, then he and I couldn't be a couple anymore but I would always be his friend and in each other's lives if he still wanted.

He thought about it for a week and then said, ok, lets have kids together. I thought that meant he loved me like I did him. I thought he hung the moon and stars and, I don't know, I never imagined he didn't want that life with me, he said yes right?

Right. Wrong. The kindest man in my life was it turns out a people pleaser. He knew how protective I was of being able to make my own choices in life. He knew, he knew me.

3 children and 2 months off our 39th anniversary together I sat him down to talk. Really talk because he was quiet man. Were there red flags during those years? Absolutely. I thought it was me. why did he never reach for me first, why was it always me? why did he think me carry our child made me unattractive, he never said but I could see it. I thought a man would see the miracle, our child, growing inside me and a man would find that beautiful. So when he didn't, I thought, ok, it's me. I'm not pretty enough, skinny enought (pregnant!) I'm too strong a personality, I'm not loveable enough. Anything as long it was my fault, because the alternative was unthinkable. if I was enough, why wasn't I enough.

I worked, supported the family, paid the bills, not because I wanted to be in control, because he never took notice about that stuff. No one was going to fight for me, or even better, stand by my shoulder and fight with me.

A kind man. A great father, patient, all you could ever wish a father was, that is what he was and still is. I should also say, a very high functioning autistic man. I never knew that for years, I discovered it slowly, so slowly.

The talk. Simple, I asked direct questions about us. What I learnt was this. He thought loving me as a friend was the same as being in love. He never really desired me, I don't think sex ever meant much to him whoever it might have been in his life. When I gave him that choice all those years ago this is what he did. He sat with it. Then he made a the decision that my choice to be a single parent wasn't good and so he agreed to have children with me. He never told me, never indicated anthing at all. he let me believe he wanted it, he wanted us and a future. He didn't, not like that. He is a man that stole at a minimum 29 years of my life and truth to be told 39 years. He is a man who gave up his entire life as well, because he didn't think being a single parent was good. That's it. The whole truth.

I moved into the annex, he helped me. I still support the family, pay the bills. The house is for our kids, that was always the plan. they are high functioning autistic but two are still at home and I need my family to always have a safe place they can just be themselves in. I will continue to do this because that is who I am.

For him, nothing has really changed. The house is there, we live there only I sleep in the annex. I still do my thing and he still educates the youngest. Only difference is my sleeping/living location which is in the garden.

I have so much rage inside me and I have no where to put it. I cannot put it on him. it would be like whipping a puppy. He made a choice because he's a kind man and a people pleaser. I cannot find an outlet but I need one. Something, anything but I'm so full of hurt, rage and I feel like I'm beeing knocked to my knees everyday. I shove myself up and power through, go to work, help others because it's my job and I love it. Then I keep falling to my knees and I'm as so tired of fighting but I don't know how to be anything else after decades of fighting for everyone. I get, go down, get up and all the while the rage consumes me with nowhere to go. All I can do is write it down to release the pressure valve, that is why I'm here.

Not because I think anyone can fix me but because I need some human contact that see's me, after so many decades of not truely being seen I need just one human being to see me and say it's ok. That I'm enough. Not enough for him, I know I'm not, I just want to count somewhere on this earth and know I'm seen.

thank you for listening.

OP posts:
Fernsarethebestplants · 10/10/2026 18:02

He may be asexual and not that interested.

I do agree that not being desired eats away at you, it wouldn't be for me for sure.

All this talk of other lives, all of us could have lived these. I chose passion, he died, it was horrific and ended up a single parent which wasn't what I wanted at all.

Late-fifties is a time for reassessing and deciding what we want in the years ahead. Look into HRT and therapy or start journalling if you feel like there's a biological basis for your rage and you need to let it out. Trips alone, trips abroad, how you'd like to live.

I also think parenting three children, two with autism will have burned you out, so no wonder you feel emotionally drained and like running away, especially if one is still school age. My children are fantastic, but being a mum does drain you.

There is a new chapter for you. Not sure your husband has 'stolen' anything, more that you have misplaced your youth and life and need to take some active steps to get at least some of that satisfaction back now the children are older.

TheBunnyLover · 10/10/2026 18:14

He sounds exactly like (a male version of) my ex.

Supporting2026 · 10/10/2026 18:18

I imagine this has been draining in ways I can't understand but I'd also step back and ask if, given how things have turned out, you think this is a worse or better outcome than other choices you might have made. I am a single parent of 2 toddlers in later life completely by choice and I am very glad I did it but its not easy either at every level. I also know there will be things when the kids are older where they will have to work through my choice. The single greatest reason I chose this option was that I couldn't find anyone else I trusted fully to have parental rights over my children that I wanted to spend that amount of time with. It sounds like regardless of everything else he has been a great father though and if you loved him then I assume you also wanted to spend that time with him.

ThatCyanCat · 10/10/2026 18:19

One act of kindness and yes, self sacrifice on his part without openess, took away the one thing in my life I have always valued above any other need in my life.

I'm sorry but I don't follow this at all. It clearly wasn't the need you valued above any other in your life because you prioritised your need for children above it... and you didn't ditch him and go seek a man who could give it to you and instead lived 39 years without it. Had he refused you children, you said you would use a donor, not go and seek a man who wanted the same things as you including children and properly desiring you in the way you wanted.

You say this is the one need you valued above all but based on your actions it appears to be the thing you found least important. It never seemed to be a priority. The priorities seemed to be children, then him.

That's why I asked why, suddenly, now, after all this time and all this life, this issue suddenly got forced to the point that the relationship is apparently over.

OrganicDecafEarlGrey · 10/10/2026 18:22

OP I understand you're feeling like you've lost most of your life but I think a lot of us feel like this in our fifties anyway. Your DH did love you and it's pretty unconditional. From what I can see, most relationships are based on sex and the love is conditional. Once the sex has gone so is the love and realistically, most of us lose our sex drive anyway. Mine disappeared ages ago because I had an early menopause and even if yours still exists, I doubt it will for much longer.

Then what will you have? You'll just end up on your own for the rest of your life instead of being with someone who loves you. Anyway, loads of men are just pretending...if you've been on here as long as I have, you'd know that. I'm being too harsh probably, but I don't know what you expect? I'm sure perfect relationships do exist but they're vanishingly rare. You're going to regret it if you give up the stability you have, because I can assure you, you won't find anyone better. I'm a couple of years younger than you and if I'm very attractive if I do say so myself. I only attract men in their seventies.

Noodles1234 · 10/10/2026 18:40

I think to a point we all paint a picture of our (thought of) hopes and dreams, assuming our partners are on board. The rage you feel with no real outlet is very understandable. I feel yours is an utter shock for you, all very passive and no one to shout at. I do believe your DH may not be capable of feeling lust or desire as you do, so how he feels is his form of love, it’s just different to yours and ASD people can word things differently to neurotypical people and in the heart of it is very similar.

Not to belittle it as it is a huge adjustment, but he has been a good father, good husband, not abusive, cheating or deceitful. Some partners go through a different hell. I would take the wins, you have 3 beautiful children who are alive and well, you have a job and a good life. In time it may feel a little easier just feeling wistful for a different life, however the life you have seems fortunate in its own beautiful way.

Enjoy Italy and enjoy life.

Hydrangeblueeyes · 10/10/2026 18:47

I wonder if high functioning autistic men understand 'Love' in a different way. If I were waiting for outward displays of affection, declarations of love or even deep conversations with my DH, I would be waiting for a long time. It can be lonely and frustrating as he is very passive.I once asked him why he stayed with me and he replied ' because you are nice to me' .He would however, do anything for me. I have decided (so far) to stay in the relationship and we have been married 30 years. We don't have any children together, you said that your partner has been a good father and that is something worth having. Doing the arithmetic it seems you are about the same age as me. I am definitely going through some exestential 'crisis' at the moment, ( too late to be a midlife crisis!). I am trying to evaluate my life not just my marriage, as time slips through my fingers. You seem to be saying that you think 39 years have just gone down the drain, but 39 years is a long time to write off. I think after a life of working in a career helping others and bringing up three children it is time to take stock, maybe have therapy as suggested by an up thread poster.

Mrszigelda · 10/10/2026 18:50

You are in a position where the person at the centre of your live was dishonest with you, for a very, very long time. Whatever the justification, that was wrong and your rage is justified. He took your right to decide away by being dishonest with you. That is, if his decision making recall is accurate- and that he always felt that way. I think we sometimes reinterpret what we felt, with the benefit of hindsight. The future? It is yours and it can be honest. Make plans. Big and small. Be your whole self. Visualise what you want and see if it’s possible. I feel for you and wish you a future filled with lovely things.

Hydrangeblueeyes · 10/10/2026 18:55

WarmthAndDepth · 10/10/2026 00:54

I hear you, OP. You are not alone - thousands of other women are at your shoulder, walking similar paths.

My autistic DP made a similar call when we had DC -he believed I'd make a good mum so should have DC. He always said it would be too much for him but I thought it was more of a figure of speech, not actually a reasonably plausible prediction which has, in many ways, proven accurate. He thinks he was doing a kind thing -I honestly think it was more of a case of not losing me.

He has not had the capacity to engage emotionally in the way I'd hoped -in other ways he has been more than adequate. I've tried to make peace with our differences and have reconciled that we're never going to 'meet', as painful as that is.

What you describe is exactly how I see my situation. We don't all end up with our 'soulmates', and we have to either make our peace with this or walk away. Staying and feeling resentful is the worst thing to do.

Aluna · 10/10/2026 18:55

One act of kindness and yes, self sacrifice on his part without openess, took away the one thing in my life I have always valued above any other need in my life.

I think you need to stop fuelling his self-serving narrative. He’s never going to say to you: I married you because I didn’t want you to let you go despite not being sure if it’s what I wanted. I’m not that into sex or kids and I went along with it because I was too weak and afraid to go for what I really wanted and actually I didn’t know.

His version attributes maximum saintliness to himself and covers up the reality of very ordinary motivation: fear, weakness, selfishness, attachment.

I’m not sure why you’re buying into this - unless possibly to see him as better than he really is.

unicornsandstardust · 10/10/2026 18:56

You can't lock the thread OP, but you can delete it from your lists of Threads I'm On/Watching/Started and you can disable notifications in general if you want, so you won't be told if someone quotes or tags you anywhere and that will apply to all threads. You can also change your username if you want to post anonymously on other threads without your username being linked to this one (people can search previous posts and it's not uncommon to name change frequently).

ForeverTheOptomist · 10/10/2026 19:00

MoonSilverwing · 10/10/2026 18:00

Thank you for your post. It was calm, kind & informative. I sincerely appreciate your words.

@ForeverTheOptomist Yes, I am taking a train there for a day trip, I shall take your advice! Thank you for your encouragement.

To everyone else that posted, and I mean everyone. There are so many of you, it is overwhelming to say the least. I didn't expect that, which just goes to show I know nothing about message boards!

All of the comment, positive, critical and surportive of another human being. I've listened, taken it all on board and appreciate it all.

I will say this. Re-reading my post (yes dramatic in some spaces, after all, emotions can be that, human nature I guess) at no point did I want anyone to think badly of my ex-partner. Yes, he has loved me. I know that passion and the whole first blush of romance is just that; a young firey persons hearts and stars and all of those things that romance novels try to sell us as forever. I understand the quite love and I understand that relaishionships evolve and change, hopefully for the better.

I chose the annex after I could, when my eldest left home. A space for me, somewhere I could sleep (which is something I am relearning after decades next to someone. No one tells us about that extra space and how it will feel) I haven't stopped loving the man he is, limitations and all. We have always been a team, my weaknesses his strenghts and vice versa. Would I leave into a place of my own? Sure. I like boundaries, learnt that they are what keep my mental health in a good place. I won't because I cannot afford to support two households and that IS my choice. Family first, he is still family and I am grateful for his care.

To those who suggest a fling or three, I'm smiling, really I am and thank you for the freedom to suggest it. I have no interest in giving my heart, body or loyalty to anyone beyond those I already have. I have never needed another person in my life to validate my existance. I have and do love and I understand overall, that's a gift because I got to experiance it.

This post or more importantly, isn't about how it didn't turn out like I thought we were (although that comes into it obviously). It's about choices. Mine and his. He chose to say yes to my request, they were not evil reasons, he's not capable of that. He chose to not tell me his reasons. Had he, I wouldn't be here writing this. One act of kindness and yes, self sacrifice on his part without openess, took away the one thing in my life I have always valued above any other need in my life. I have my children, all beautiful human beings that I love beyond words. Not just because of who they are but because of both parents.

Overall, you have all given me your thoughts and I value each and everone. So thank you. I won't post again on this thread, I'm not sure how to lock it, or if I should. But I do thank you all for giving me balance that I so desperately needed.

You are more than welcome OP. And I am absolutely delighted to have read your positive and less distrssed message.

Enjoy the trip. I hope you have a wonderful time. I recently took one on my own, several thousands of miles away. It did many many good things, including hitting the reset button!

edit - Sorry, I've just remembered that you're leaving the thread now. You probably won't see this!

Pinkissmart · 10/10/2026 19:03

He’s not a kind man, he’s a weak man.

You pushed for what you wanted ( right or wrong) and he was too weak, too dishonest. This is not kindness.

It’s ok to leave him. Being with someone who doesn’t feel the same is completely soul destroying 💖

Wildgoat · 10/10/2026 19:13

Im struggling to understand. You’ve been together nearly 40 years. He loves you, you love him,he chose you, whatever the reasons, you made your position clear, gave him an ultimatum and he agreed to your terms, you didn’t say and you must love me romantically and unconditionally.

you also intend to continue in your marriage it seems, as a family, all that’s happened is you’ve moved to your own room. You’ve not actually seperated or divorcing ?

Fernsarethebestplants · 10/10/2026 19:15

Glad you have found this a bit helpful. Whatever has happened in our lives, the fifties is a time for thinking what we want the rest to look like, this is a good opportunity for a reset and you are already starting with that.

Donniemac · 10/10/2026 19:46

That is a very powerful and touching story.

Bowies · 10/10/2026 19:48

There are communication issues in the relationship but I don’t think you are in the right here piling all the blame at his door for your own unhappiness.

You could have simply split up and looked for another partner at the time, rather than giving him the strange and confusing sperm donor ultimatum.

There are other interpretations, such as he does love you and chose to stay with you to support you in your choice to have DC and to provide them with a DF. I don’t see that as “people pleasing”.

You must have realised before, his views on romance and sex, if only through his actions. If you didn’t it was perhaps you were so blinked about having DC, prior to now having got the 3 you wanted?

girljulian · 10/10/2026 19:54

I’m really sorry you’re sad. I don’t really understand what he did wrong.

Donniemac · 10/10/2026 19:59

A very perceptive response. That's what I was thinking but didn't have the words. What is love? The Christan definition is that you love someone if you are prepared to die for them. I suspect, in that context, this lady's husband loves her

JLou08 · 10/10/2026 20:01

Had he ever felt the way you expect him to feel about you for anyone else? If not, it sounds more to me like he has alexithymia. If it's not enough for you, it's not enough for you and you're well within your rights to end things. But, I don't think it means you're not enough for him.

PizzaBnJerryMealDeal · 10/10/2026 20:19

What is stopping you both from having a clean break ?

Divorce

Live totally apart

Start new lives

SurvivalInstinctsOfABakedPotato · 10/10/2026 20:23

You worked, you supported the family, you paid the bills, you initiated everything and he didn't find you attractive when you were pregnant

I'm not really seeing what was so wonderful about him?!

On the other hand the whole 'he was my world and holding the moon' crap is just unrealistic crap in cards and not real life

I actually think you're both unreasonable

Alwaysontheright · 10/10/2026 20:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Alwaysontheright · 10/10/2026 20:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

bigvig · 10/10/2026 20:36

Just because he says things OP it doesn’t mean they are true. I very much doubt his version of events. It sounds like a story designed to wound you and also make him not at all responsible for causing any pain - plus he gets to believe he’s the good guy. Plus he still gets the bills paid. I heavily suspect the truth is he didn’t want to lose you but is emeoiotnally stunted and doesn’t like admitting any fault so constructs weird narratives to make himself look ‘good’. For some reason you believe him. Leave the idiot OP and reclaim some freedom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread