Hostages

[TakeMe2Insanity]

This is running on Al Jazeera and others - apparently Israel refused to take back two hostages.

https://english.alarabiya.net/amp/News/middle-east/2023/10/21/Hamas-says-intended-to-release-two-hostages-but-Israel-refused-to-receive-them

Agree

Hamas has no consideration for human right. Remember what ISIS did. These terrorists do not follow Western democratic norms and are the enemies of all good people everywhere.

The confusion arose because the Israeli Govt tweeted they had found her body. They have since deleted that tweet and it now becomes clear what did happen.

As usual some of you jump in and try and twist poster's thought or meanings.
Hamas did this and it is totally barbaric. What the Israeli Govt does now in revenge is also barbaric.

Rest in peace Shani. I do hope her body can found and she can be given a dignified funeral. The video of her dancing at the festival showed such a joyous free spirit , absolutely sickened by what Hamas did to her.
We can’t hate those we disagree with, those who are not on ‘our side’ we have to find a way to peace but there are too many people who cannot/do not want to grasp this.

Sky news is reporting a video has been released of three of the hostages asking Netanyahu for a prisoner swap

Netanyahu is under immense pressure here.
No idea what will happen next but really praying that the hostages are released somehow

Can’t believe once again they’ve posted misinformation specially with something so important for her family

I thought Hamas giving that poor girl's family false hope was yet another cruelty in the whole thing. It was clear from the footage that she was already dead but what parent wouldn't hope?

They have recovered parts of her skull, likely from a decapitation, so saying she was in a Gaza hospital was a cruel lie.

Who actually posted her body was found?

It sounds like part of her skull was found.

Yes they certainly lose credibility, especially in such a sensitive situation

No according to her mother she was shot in the head

@Efacsen ah okay, there's a lot of stuff being posted on X. That would certainly be consistent with the head injury she had on the back of the pickup truck.

Her mother said her credit card was used in Gaza on the Sunday and she also got the phone call saying she was alive. They are just utterly disgusting but should we be surprised when you see how they killed people ? Theft and lies seems quite minor in comparison.

Latest from BBC
They said they can't release the video but have posted a still
Those poor ladies. They are innocent and did nothing to deserve this.

Latest report is Shani was DECAPITATED after her naked, gang raped, broken body was filmed being spat at and cheered, and the Palestinian people cheered it too as evidenced by videos showing their reaction to the attacks in Israel.

And the sick monster sympathisers on here bleat that the poor Palestinian government were driven to do that to an innocent young woman, because Israel had prevented them from committing similar atrocities to their civilians by ‘blockading’ them and Israel should turn the other cheek and try to make peace.

Beggars belief.

She was a bit younger than my DD. The fear and pain she must have gone through makes me want to scream.

I do not judge Israel for their retaliation.

I judge the Palestinian government for using their children as human shields and committing these atrocities as an act of war.

If you search 'sky news hostages' on twitter - the film clip is in responses to sky's tweet

STOP SPREADING MIS_INFORMATION

Shani was shot in the head - her mother said so

I don't wish to argue with you on a thread which we are discussing something quite sensitive and I can understand the anger
But collective punishment of innocent civilians cannot be justified because of the acts of Hamas
I stand by this

The Israeli president does actually say she was decapitated though:

https://twitter.com/ronzheimer/status/1718977025426292752

Can’t believe once again they’ve posted misinformation specially with something so important for her family

Yes they certainly lose credibility, especially in such a sensitive situation

Are you for real? This is what you’re choosing to focus on here?
Don’t bother to answer that actually, I already know why.

Well that's not what her mother was told by IDF this Sunday

They need to get their story straight!

Yes I’m for real. can’t you understand how overwhelming it can be for a family to not know about what has really happened to their family member , to be told they’ve got the body for this to be published and then to be told no sorry once again we gave you wrong information.

israel needs to make sure every information they provide has been verified multiple times , their credibility is at risk once again. The outcome won’t change the future of this lady and her family but if Israel wants people to trust them they need to stop cocking it up when they provide information because next time they acusse Palestine about something nobody will believe them.

You do know I was simply replying to a poster who posted the first sentence you have highlighted in bold
Do you take offence in my criticising of the Israeli government simply because I am Muslim?

@25milesfromhome or you simply can't fathom why I might have a concern for Israeli hostages?

@25milesfromhome i come on here to update whenever i come across any information on hostages or if there is a possibility of their release. Why? Because they are innocent civilians who deserve to be home with their families
You jumped on one post of mine and took it out of context simply because of your bias against me