You ‘can’t imagine’ just thinking of a few things you’d really love to own, when asked? And you think we’re the weird ones here?
A Christmas list isn’t a shopping list that one issues to their family and expects them to buy everything on it. It’s simply a list of IDEAS for things you would really love and appreciate, if someone is keen to buy you something. That’s all. To be honest, we keep gift buying fairly minimal in my family - my sister and I exchange a little gift worth less than a tenner, my brother usually makes me something as he’s very talented at a specific craft and I love his work. I buy for my mum and she buys something smallish for me and DP. DP and I get a few bits for each other, usually a couple of things from a list and a couple of little surprises - but I certainly wouldn’t expect everything/anything on my list, or feel even remotely entitled to receive them.
I always ask for a list from DP and my mum. I’ll usually get them a surprise or two as well, but lists are nice so I know they’ll be delighted with at least something I buy them and therefore money won’t be wasted. Hardly a crime, is it? Jeez.