Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Do you judge mums who bottle feed?

419 replies

babybrian · 08/04/2010 11:40

I tried to breastfeed, for one reason and another I failed. I am about to start going to baby groups and have worked myself into a bit of a neurotic state.

Tell me, honestly , do you judge mums who bottle feed? My dd is only 8 weeks and I worry people will think I don't love her.

OP posts:
currycrazy · 08/04/2010 16:05

i agree.....i feel probably even more crap than i already do..
but hey anything can only be better than the formula causes cancer thread

Librashavinganotherbiscuit · 08/04/2010 16:08

I used to feel jealous of mothers who FF, I BF and bloody hated every minute.

jellybeans · 08/04/2010 16:08

Not really unless they say they couldn't be arsed to try or 'it feels pervy' or something and I may fleetingly think they are abit brainwashed and not putting their baby first. But if they try at all then NO. Same if they had reason not to.

megonthemoon · 08/04/2010 16:18

I would wonder why the mum wasn't breastfeeding. I don't consider that judgey so much as nosey. I know loads of women try to instigate bf but stop for many reasons, so I would definitely not assume you hadn't tried, and to me with bf it is the trying that is the important thing IYSWIM - for some it succeeds for some it doesn't and it's a bit of a lottery as to who it works for and who it doesn't given the patchy bf support in this country. I mixed fed from 2 weeks largely due to poor support, but miraculously I did manage to bf to a year in the end, so I do know it doesn't always work out as planned.

I would definitely judge though if a mother said something like "breastfeeding is unnatural/disgusting" or "it's a bit icky" or "my boobs are for my husband" without ever having tried. IMHO those reasons show someone's ignorance and lack of willing to do what is best for their child. But I am a really judgmental person, and know that it is not necessarily my best character trait so I'm probably one of the worst types of people you would come across...

Lymond · 08/04/2010 16:21

babybrian - no one with intelligent enough opinions to care about will judge you for the way you feed. And the same is true for mothers who breastfeed.

Judging someone for feeding a baby milk from a bottle is particularly ridiculous because there is no knowing what the milk is... it could be expressed breast milk anyway.

whomovedmychocolate · 08/04/2010 16:27

Actually I did judge a bottle feeding mother once - when she remarked that she 'felt sorry for my DH' I was BFing DD and she said 'oh I like to keep mine special for my DH'

MrsSawdust · 08/04/2010 16:35

No, I don't judge bottle feeders.

If I'm being totally honest though, I do have one negative reaction to seeing a baby being bottle fed - disappointment. Not for the baby or the mum (who I assume adores their baby btw), but purely selfishly, for myself. I have rarely seen other mums out and about bfing their babies (just one in the last 12 months in fact) and it makes me feel like a freak, and like I'm the one being judged, especially when I need to feed in public

Ineedsomesleep · 08/04/2010 16:36

babybrian haven't read all the thread so sorry if I am repeating what has already been said.

Please don't think that you failed as you put it. You tried your best I'm sure and there is such little support out there for bfing mums when things go wrong.

No one will judge you for doing the best for your baby.

And if you do have another Lo you may find it much easier next time, at any rate you will be more clued up on where the support is to be found.

Enjoy your baby, these weeks are very precious.

ticktockclock · 08/04/2010 16:40

I would never judge, so long as mum and baby are doing the right thing for them and bub is healthy and happy. I tried BFing and could not do it for a number of reasons. The hormones produced were exacerbating my migraines and making my life hell. My breasts were monstorous (4x size of bubs head) and this caused massive problems with latching on. In addition to this my milk did not come in for a week after the birth so I had to bottle feed for the first week so that my LO could eat. There are so many reasons why mums can't do it. Don't feel bad and if any one says anything to you they aren't worth your time.

confusedfirsttimemum · 08/04/2010 16:46

mrssawdust - Really. Where are you? Come to south London, there are boobs out everywhere here!

dawntigga · 08/04/2010 16:47

Of course not - why would I? I have no idea of what led to that persons wanting/needing to use formula so why would I make that judgement? I love bf'ing and would encourage anyone to give it a go but I always say I'd prefer a happy mum and baby on formula than a miserable mum which leads to a miserable baby carrying on with bf'ing when it isn't the best solution for them.

EBFTheCubTiggaxx

ChocOrange05 · 08/04/2010 16:48

I would judge - by wondering why they weren't BF - as an immediate reaction, (I am judgemental though although I don't like it about myself) but I would never assume the mother loved the baby less, that's just a horrid thought, and if it were a case of not being able to BF then I would completely understand. If its because they didn't want to I would be quite - I met someone once who said she didn't even try to BF as she didn't like the thought of it, and that really upset me (on behalf of her and her DC).

Don't worry though, I am sure you will meet lots of other mothers who are in the same position, and from my experience there were very few mums who were still BF after 3 months anyway and after then I found as a BF mum I was more the odd one out.

Good luck!
PS - any baby group where you feel judged isn't worth going to IMO

ArthurPewty · 08/04/2010 16:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ArthurPewty · 08/04/2010 17:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

JollyPirate · 08/04/2010 17:08

"No I don't" in answer to the OP.

I struggled with BF and bugger all support so bottlefed DS.

I am also a HV and it doesn't matter a jot to me how parents feed their babies as long as they are happy with the decision they have made.

currycrazy · 08/04/2010 17:08

leoniedelt....how do you know it was due to what you were fed?

so you can guarantee if you were BF you would be fine

ArthurPewty · 08/04/2010 17:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Dizzymummy · 08/04/2010 17:14

People who judge others usually have some inadequacy or other so I generally pity them if anything. Congrats of your baby.

ArthurPewty · 08/04/2010 17:16

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

BettyButterknife · 08/04/2010 17:22

The only time I do is when mothers have got on fine with bf but just can't be bothered with it anymore. I went through so many problems trying to bf my DS, was really devastated at the end so to hear someone say they took to it like a duck to water but stopped, for whatever reason, galls me.

Don't you think that part of the 'Breast is best' campaign creates judginess though? I know what they're trying to do, but to imply anything other than breast is not best (which I know is a fact, but I'm talking about marketing) sets women up for a fall or at least engenders a slight competitiveness between mothers.

BettyButterknife · 08/04/2010 17:24

PS BabyBrian - the only time I felt judged at a baby group was when I bottle-fed (with formula) my DS at a bf support group (I'd gone along with a friend). Group was called Cherubs - felt like starting my own ff baby group called Demons or something

MrsSawdust · 08/04/2010 17:26

confusedfirsttimemum I'm in a working class oop north town. Would love to come down to South London. Just can't afford it

Lutyens · 08/04/2010 17:32

OP struck a chord with me. When pg with dd, I was sure I would breast-feed, there wasn't the slightest doubt in my mind and I had read up on the physical discomforts (sore nipples, mastisis etc etc) and was prepared to deal with everything.

What I wasn't prepared for was that my milk never came. It was so devastating for me. There were a few drops of milk but nowhere near the flow there should be. I used to listen to people in my antenatal group say stuff like "I heard a baby cry and my breasts let down milk" and they'd talk about the toe-curling feeling when the milk let down. I have never experienced any of this and I used to feel like such a failure listening to all this.

At 4 weeks, I gave up struggling and gave dd the bottle. It was that or starve her. When I stopped "breast-feeding" I had no pain, no heavy breasts, nothing. That was when dh believed that I didn't have milk - he used to have a pet cat as a child and had to help her deal with blocked ducts when her kittens were given away.

I spent the first year of dd's life terrified that everyone was judging me. I used to look around furtively when I took the bottle out. If anyone had ever commented on the bottle, I would have died, literally died, as I was so guilty.

But in all that time, ONLY ONE woman commented, and that was a reflection on her not on me. She was an old woman with horribly strict views - I cut her out of my life when she made that distressingly hurtful comment and I am happier for it. Her son was getting married around that time and I was feeling for her dil and hoping she had no trouble either conceiving, in childbirth, or in bf'ing, using cloth nappies, blw etc. etc. because her MIL wouldn't be understanding or supportive, the stupid cow.

Lutyens · 08/04/2010 17:33

Oh My! That turned into a bit of a rant!!!!!

Apologies

confusedfirsttimemum · 08/04/2010 17:37

mrssawdust - Nor can we! Sadly oop north would be a hell of a commute...