Thanks all. I feel the same - don't want to share our name ideas in RL, also want to keep something a surprise as we've already told everyone it's a boy. So will share them only here!
When I was thinking of Leonardo for DS everyone had so many comments. Some people loved it and some people didn't. Ironically, both our families really didn't like it but we just ignored them and I'm happy with did. As you say smitten, once the baby is born, everyone gets used to it and ends up loving the name.
I want to have a few more on our shortlist though. So the jury is still out!
I'm busy today but itching to go shopping now... may pop out for 30min and buy something for the new baby just to get it out of my system!