Re: messy play. I generally hate doing it with my kids even though I'm really creative myself. My problem is I'm a perfectionist and a control freak and constantly fight and lose the urge to take over, whether it's painting, baking, play doh. I took DS1 (4.9yr old) to a paint-your-own-pottery place yesterday. You pick a piece, paint it, then they fire it and you get a lovely glazed product back in a week. I fought the urge (for 95% of the time) to take over and let DS1 do it himself and do you know what, he did an amazing job. Whether this was because the mess was all somebody else's to clear up or not, I'm not sure.
Like you said, anothermonkey, I am CONSTANTLY torn between the mother I want to be (think Maria in the Sound of Music) and the mother I am (Cruella De Vil).
As for single/co parenting: I definitely find things easier when I'm alone. Yes, it's harder physically, but I do find that I'm more in control (most of the time!) By that I mean that there is nobody else who you feel you must compromise your own style for. As I've said before, I definitely find myself being more "shouty" with the kids if DH is around and in a bad mood. I jump on their every move to prevent a deterioration in behaviour and therefore the mood of the house rather than letting the little things go. DH tends not to let the little things go, and then gets more and more wound up. If I then get defensive of what they do, he sees it as a personal attack on him. So I either have to be on his side (and be shouty at the kids) or be on their side and have him go sulky because he thinks I'm unsupportive and critical. I can't win! It drives me insane. This is why I was dreading the school holidays so much and having him at home all day.
Dreaming I AM furious inside when DH smacks the boys, but don't say too much because the way he sees it is that HE is their parent too, and I shouldn't be able to tell him how to parent. However, whilst he's still in the "the odd smack does them no harm" camp, he has definitely been holding back on the smacks more since I've been calmer and less shouty. (He doesn't smack them often, nor hard. It's more for "shock" value to get them to stop doing something or other). Whilst I don't like him doing it, I can understand how sometimes their behaviour drives him to do it. Oh God, now I sound like I'm making excuses. I suppose I have to forgive him for it because he doesn't know any better himself. Yet. I haven't suggested he reads the books I've read - as I'm sure he'd just scoff at the idea. But I'm hoping that over time he will see that the calmer parenting works.
For example, today, on our way to go swimming, we called in at a retail park. I had something I needed to buy and DH had something he needed to return. Rather than the 4 of us all go into the shop (which can be chaos) DH waited in the car with the boys while I went in the shop, then vice versa. When I returned to the car, DH complained how they'd been a real pain in the arse - unfastening their seat belts, climbing all over the seats, etc (we've just had a brand new car, so obviously DH doesn't appreciate this sort of behaviour. Whilst I don't either, I'm realistic and know that nothing stays looking new when you have kids). When DH went into the shop, I put the boys back in their carseats, strapped them in and they were as good as gold. When DH returned, I told him how great they'd been and he said something like "Well, I don't know what it is, why they behave for you and not for me. They must be scared of you or something". Hmmmm. Well, I certainly hope not! I don't EVER want my children to be scared of me. Respect me, yes. Scared of me, never.
Yesterday, all four of us were in the supermarket and I was getting a little stressed with the boys for pestering over new toothbrushes, so I just left them with DH while I went off to pay for the things in our basket. Next thing I know, they've both run off from him
. They would NEVER run off from me in the shop. For starters, I wouldn't give them the ability to - they'd either be in a trolley, strapped in a pushchair or holding my hand firmly. And secondly, I have enough voice control over DS1 (not so much with DS2) that he wouldn't run further than a few yards. Of course, they both came back after a moment or two, but that didn't help stress levels in the house between DH and I. I sort of blamed him for allowing it to happen, and he blamed me for going off and leaving him with them. Ok, maybe I shouldn't have gone off. But there have been plenty of times (hundreds!) when I've been alone with both boys in a supermarket and they've not run off. The problem is, he gives them a little bit of a free reign, but has little or no voice control and doesn't want to shout or get angry for fear of making a public show of himself. I couldn't give a shit what other shoppers think! If my boys were running off from me down an aisle, if I had to yell to get them to stop, I would! Whereas I bet he didn't.
Like I said, our parenting is so different, and I don't know whether it's a good thing or a bad thing. You know, good cop, bad cop. Our boys definitely see Daddy as a pushover (a "funtime Frankie). And I wonder if that's why they don't listen to him, because they don't respect him.
You must all be bored of reading this now, so I'm off to get some cheesecake. Have a good evening everyone x