Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked that no one helped the girl on the train

508 replies

Ohhh1 · Yesterday 14:37

14 year old SA in trained

I am being unreasonable in think people need to stop being so absorbed on their phones whilst out in public. It seems no one helpped this child whilst she was being raped because they were too busy on their phones.

Autistic girl, 14, 'sexually assaulted on train by Afghan migrants'

Baryalai Rahimi, 25, and Mirebadurahman Sadat, 29, are said to have spotted the runaway teenager at a station in rural Kent before following her onto the London-bound train on February 5.

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16264873/afghan-migrants-schoolgirl-14-raping-train-toilets.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Ponoka7 · Yesterday 18:05

SilenceInside · Yesterday 18:01

@LoudWriter as I already said upthread the list of things that need questioning, for me, based on the limited information in this article don’t include the other passengers at all.

What I've linked has more detail, including the girl being kissed and hugged tight when a ticket inspector came passed. That poor girl was assaulted in sight of so many people.

Laurmolonlabe · Yesterday 18:06

Ponoka7 · Yesterday 18:03

Girls 11-14 being picked off our streets at the rate it's happening, is a new issue. But we've always had sex offenders, so mostly MN looks the other way.
@Laurmolonlabe it happened as reported.
https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2263125/afghan-migrants-rape-autistic-girl-train/amp

I could tell the story of what I witnessed today, but there's no point, it won't be believed. Nor will what a fairly local street has had to put up with for weeks, including parents organising patrols of the area to keep their girls safe. It's ended by one of the men in the HMO stabbing himself and setting himself on fire. All in front of children.

So if you witnessed it why didn't you help?

1dayatatime · Yesterday 18:06

TheLastSilverSaint · Yesterday 15:20

Do you think it's the government's fault when white British men rape kids, too?

Because that happens a great deal more often than kids being raped by refugees. There will be hundreds more sex crimes committed by white British men than by Afghan refugees.

The Daily Mail wouldn't even bother reporting this case if the defendants were British, and if they did, they'd totally be blaming the victim. They only give a shit about women and girls when it gives them a chance to stir up racist reactions.

You do realise that there are a lot more white British born men in the UK than there are Afghan male refugees in the UK.
So the proper comparison is crimes per capita of white British born males vs Afghan male refugees.

Afghan males in the UK are 7.5 times more likely to commit a sex crime than the British average:

Shocked that no one helped the girl on the train
Tweeply · Yesterday 18:09

TheOriginalEmu · Yesterday 15:45

So are you saying we should never have tourists in the country? or anyone coming here for work. delivery drivers are out in case they’re a rapist. No more planes because the crew might be foreign rapists. or cruises or anything. basically let’s just shove a 50 foot wall around the country and no one can come in and rape anyone.

Maybe a good idea?

Clavinova · Yesterday 18:11

PumpkinsForLife · Yesterday 16:56

There's a huge difference between 3 times more likely and 7 times more likely, why is the statistic so imprecise? That discrepancy makes the statistic almost pointless, really.

Also, they're "3-7 times" (again, a huge difference in extremes there) more likely to be convicted than white men. That doesn't mean they commit 3-7 times more crimes. A refugee is far more likely to be reported in the first place than a white man, and then far more likely to be convicted as well. That could easily account for the difference.

Edited

A refugee is far more likely to be reported in the first place than a white man, and then far more likely to be convicted as well.

Is that because they are more likely to have committed stranger rapes/street rapes so easier to convict? Hardly reassuring.

Tweeply · Yesterday 18:11

Ponoka7 · Yesterday 18:05

What I've linked has more detail, including the girl being kissed and hugged tight when a ticket inspector came passed. That poor girl was assaulted in sight of so many people.

People need to be more active, but I know folk are worried. But, anyone can say to a person/child, "Do you know this person"? And then let them answer you. I would certainly do this

SilenceInside · Yesterday 18:12

@Ponoka7 the ticket inspector has a case to answer then for not doing their duty and noticing this was a child and a sexual assault rather than an adult and consensual behaviour.

CakeAndEats · Yesterday 18:13

SilenceInside · Yesterday 18:04

@CakeAndEats having any men enter the country makes the chance of sexual assault and violence increase. So maybe no men at all should be allowed to enter the UK for any reason? That would be the safest thing, and anyone allowing any men into the country would be making things worse. A rational policy do you think?

We can start by not letting men in from some of the worst nations on earth for women.

OneAlertOliveFinch · Yesterday 18:13

Mind boggling that a forum for mothers who in general have strong feminist beliefs, would glaze over statistics and bend over backwards to defend men from the 3rd world counties. "But but... white men do it too..!". Shocking. I feel for your daughter's. These men are not compatible with our culture.

Lifetsuck · Yesterday 18:14

OneAlertOliveFinch · Yesterday 18:13

Mind boggling that a forum for mothers who in general have strong feminist beliefs, would glaze over statistics and bend over backwards to defend men from the 3rd world counties. "But but... white men do it too..!". Shocking. I feel for your daughter's. These men are not compatible with our culture.

Men are women’s greatest predator regardless of country or race

Lifetsuck · Yesterday 18:15

OneAlertOliveFinch · Yesterday 18:13

Mind boggling that a forum for mothers who in general have strong feminist beliefs, would glaze over statistics and bend over backwards to defend men from the 3rd world counties. "But but... white men do it too..!". Shocking. I feel for your daughter's. These men are not compatible with our culture.

I’d love to learn what you have to suggest regarding women’s safety

Let’s assume immigration is banned

What do you propose we do with the men in this country?

OneAlertOliveFinch · Yesterday 18:16

Lifetsuck · Yesterday 18:14

Men are women’s greatest predator regardless of country or race

Some are more predatory than others.

NotStayingTheSame · Yesterday 18:16

Lemonlimeandwhat · Yesterday 16:15

That is pretty sad. What if it was your child? Wouldn't you want someone to help?

Well obviously 🙄 I’m not going to put myself in danger though to get involved.

climbintheback · Yesterday 18:19

Fuck international law protect our women and girls - how come Hungary and Poland and such like manage it.

Clavinova · Yesterday 18:19

TheOriginalEmu · Yesterday 15:45

So are you saying we should never have tourists in the country? or anyone coming here for work. delivery drivers are out in case they’re a rapist. No more planes because the crew might be foreign rapists. or cruises or anything. basically let’s just shove a 50 foot wall around the country and no one can come in and rape anyone.

So are you saying we should never have tourists in the country?

Are we giving tourists free accommodation and spending money now?

or anyone coming here for work

Perhaps we could ask the people coming here for work to apply for a visa and produce ID before we let them through border control. Might be a good idea.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 18:19

brownbootsandhats · Yesterday 17:49

Hoards of men from uncivilised counties

shoukdnt we be taking the blame for that ? For the way we have meddled in their politics , invaded , try to enforce our rule, at the sam time teaching then our language and singing the praises of our country

Except that the exact same phenomenon is observed among, eg, Somali men in Denmark - which never colonised them and whose language is unlikely to be taught in their schools.
Afghan men are high up on Danish crime lists too.

It looks as though it's the fault of the men and the society they come from, and not the country that so kindly accorded them asylum.

https://x.com/visegrad24/status/2058243286444224849/photo/1

CakeAndEats · Yesterday 18:22

OneAlertOliveFinch · Yesterday 18:13

Mind boggling that a forum for mothers who in general have strong feminist beliefs, would glaze over statistics and bend over backwards to defend men from the 3rd world counties. "But but... white men do it too..!". Shocking. I feel for your daughter's. These men are not compatible with our culture.

Let's assume you're European and the mum of a DD who lives on the continent. I think if they were taking a trip to London you'd wish them well and be excited for them. If they were going to Kabul for example you'd be terrified for them and their physical safety.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 18:23

Lifetsuck · Yesterday 18:14

Men are women’s greatest predator regardless of country or race

It's not "regardless" though. There are abusive men everywhere, but rates of domestic violence, rape and femicide vary widely around the world depending on how socially acceptable male violence is in various countries.

It's no coincidence for example that Mexico, with its tradition of machismo has one of the highest rates of femicide in the world. Is it racist to say that too?

lightand · Yesterday 18:23

LauraNorda · Yesterday 15:14

Even if someone had had a go, who do you think the police would be pursuing?

This country is finished.

Sorry, but I dont think that that is the right attitude.

climbintheback · Yesterday 18:24

We have a million kids unemployed - drive a delivery van train to be a carer or no benefits - simple!

CakeAndEats · Yesterday 18:25

Emilesgran · Yesterday 18:19

Except that the exact same phenomenon is observed among, eg, Somali men in Denmark - which never colonised them and whose language is unlikely to be taught in their schools.
Afghan men are high up on Danish crime lists too.

It looks as though it's the fault of the men and the society they come from, and not the country that so kindly accorded them asylum.

https://x.com/visegrad24/status/2058243286444224849/photo/1

Edited

I had a very bad experience with a Somali man in my last trip to Copenhagen

Apotofrealcoffee · Yesterday 18:26

Emilesgran · Yesterday 18:19

Except that the exact same phenomenon is observed among, eg, Somali men in Denmark - which never colonised them and whose language is unlikely to be taught in their schools.
Afghan men are high up on Danish crime lists too.

It looks as though it's the fault of the men and the society they come from, and not the country that so kindly accorded them asylum.

https://x.com/visegrad24/status/2058243286444224849/photo/1

Edited

I wish people arguing ‘it’s just men in general’ would actually address this point.

I also wish we had a tally of how many of these ‘isolated incidents’ have happened in the last few years.

Frequency · Yesterday 18:28

I'm not shocked. I'm saddened, but not shocked. I was assaulted on a bus at the same age. I did feel able to say no to the point that I asked other passengers to help me, and they pretended they couldn't hear me. My friend tried to tell the bus driver, who berated her for disturbing him while he was driving and told her to "just move seats".

The men (and one woman) who assaulted me were white, fwiw. They were locals.

ThePerfectStormBird · Yesterday 18:28

A runaway teenager ended up being raped by two men. Nope doesn’t surprise me whatsoever.

Pessismistic · Yesterday 18:29

Ohhh1 · Yesterday 15:45

The lack of attention bothers me. People just zoom in on their phones / books etc and like to zone out to anything that is remotely uncomfortable.

This is a 14 year old girl who was being led to the toilets but two much older men, ofcourse people should have noticed and said something

Hi op I think you are forgetting people sit on phones listen to music etc is to be distracted purposely and to mind their own business. The men are too blame and I imagine any passenger will feel awful knowing this happened but no one can read minds. It’s a horrific experience for her but you blaming passengers is wrong.