Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child responsibilities.. Should dinner be made or even started when the first parent gets home from work?

361 replies

Playinwithfire · Yesterday 08:21

Last night I get home, it was around 7.30 and my youngest said mummy I'm hungry. I was confused DH had been home since 2pm and sorted HIS stuff and then he headed off to his hobby. I checked to see if they had enough dinner, then the child says we didn't get any dinner! I'm furious...

There has been a few changes and I have been very understanding that DH is trying to adjust. However, for f"*k sake... I feel like I need to still manage everything and ensure things get done. I'm asked a 100 questions daily. An I snapped last night...

I just don't get how you can go off to a hobby knowing that your children still haven't eaten however, you've made sure all the stuff he had to do was priority and very much completed.

OP posts:
GreyCarpet · Yesterday 12:02

MrsBananaman · Yesterday 11:14

Maybe in the absence of an adult this is fine, but their father was there and just didn’t do it. I don’t think a 15 year old should have to make dinner for his siblings because their father just didn’t do it. That’s awful.

OP YANBU in this instance.

This.

This isn't an abstract discussion about 15 year olds developing skills or taking on responsibilities in the home. Because most of us would agree thats a good and positive thing.

This is about a parent relying on a child stepping up to fill the gaps in their own parenting.

Do you need reminding to make some dinner for your children every single day?

And this.

Who is reminding the mum to feed the children?

Maybe the OP's post is completely disingenuous. Maybe the kids asked at 4pm what was for dinner, dad said they could just heat up a frozen pizza when they wanted and the 15 year old refused. Which would make some posters' responses a bit more understandable.

But, either way, the dad shouldn't have gone out at 7pm knowing the 8 year old hadn't eaten. He could have left 15 year old to get over themselves and fed the 8 year old. But he didn't. That's where the parenting fail lies. He went out knowing a young child was unfed.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 12:05

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 11:56

Most of the responses are pointless in the absence of the nuance which makes the difference in this situation.

many posters have just made up that the father was doing fuck all all afternoon and shouted at the teenager to make dinner as he left.

no one knows if that’s true.

because it’s entirely reasonable for a normally engaged dad who is busy for whatever reason - including a hobby as parents are people too - to say before the little ones dinner time ‘Fred, can you put dinner on, I’m a bit busy today’

and that’s worlds away from the dad not giving a shiny shit about anyone other than himself or even thinking about their dinner.

either could be true in the absence of context from the op.

Unless they eat half an hour before the 8 year olds bedtime every day, then the dad clearly didn't give a shiny shit.

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 12:06

mrsm43s · Yesterday 10:41

Because 15 year olds should do simple chores when requested to by their parent. It's not an unreasonable ask.

I think it is given that he was at home from 2pm until 7pm and didn't seem to be doing anything else.
If dad was doing the hoovering/ washing / DIY etc then yes it's perfectly reasonable to ask the teen to help out by that doesn't seem to be the case here

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:08

Goinggreymammy · Yesterday 11:32

Goodness. Im wondering what you think the DH'S hobby is, that it would take 5 hours to get ready?!!! Perhaps a drag queen?
Edited to correct typo

Edited

It's irrelevant. The Dad asked his 15 year old to do a perfectly reasonable chore. The 15 year old wilfully disobeyed. That's bad behaviour.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 12:09

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:08

It's irrelevant. The Dad asked his 15 year old to do a perfectly reasonable chore. The 15 year old wilfully disobeyed. That's bad behaviour.

Jesus 😂

CloveRinse · Yesterday 12:09

Makebelieveanotherlife · Yesterday 09:24

Op you’ve written this post quite poorly with relevant information left out. So seems like you have a communication issue.
You spoke to him before he left so why didn’t you ask what are they having for dinner. Regardless of who is cooking in our home it’s a fairly normal question to ask each other.

I think you need to calm down. Your posts come across like you are having a weird day.

She shouldn't need to ask another adult - their father - whether the kids are being fed or not - especially as he was home for a good few hours before her.

Your take is very strange and also misses the point entirely.

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 12:10

mrsm43s · Yesterday 10:56

We don't know that he's not. And asking a 15yo to cook a simple meal for themself and their sibling is a perfectly reasonable ask from time to time, especially if Mum is at work and Dad is getting ready to go out.

Getting ready to go out.... for 5 hours?
I'm sure if he'd for something useful the OP would have mentioned it but OP said he sorted his own stuff out. Didn't appear to do anything for the family

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Yesterday 12:11

YourWildAmberSloth · Yesterday 09:52

Think there are two separate issues here. DH is an arse, he was at home and should have sorted dinner before he buggered off. A 15 year old should be more than capable of pulling something basic together, beans on toast, sandwiches, something, for a hungry younger sibling in an emergency. I'm sure the 8 year didn't sit in silence but would have said 'I'm hungry' or 'what's for dinner?'. This is not about excusing DH incompetence, laziness or stupidity, but about taking responsibility when you have been left in charge - it's not just about being there.

Completely agree with this.

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:15

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 12:06

I think it is given that he was at home from 2pm until 7pm and didn't seem to be doing anything else.
If dad was doing the hoovering/ washing / DIY etc then yes it's perfectly reasonable to ask the teen to help out by that doesn't seem to be the case here

It's a reasonable ask of a 15 yo, regardless of what the Dad was doing.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 12:17

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:15

It's a reasonable ask of a 15 yo, regardless of what the Dad was doing.

You're blaming a 15 year old for a useless, selfish man.

Stompythedinosaur · Yesterday 12:17

Your dh is a prick. Feeding your dc is a very basic part of parenting. Feeding yourself and not your 8yo is unthinkable. Is he trying to punish you for being at work late? I can't see any way this wasn't a deliberate choice, he clearly knew the dc were hungry and he hadn't fed them. Unless he has a significant cognitive issue, he knows his dc need to eat.

Any expectation the 15yo sibling steps into a parenting role so their father is facilitated in failing even the most basic aspects of parenting is totally unreasonable.

Honestly, I'd be absolutely furious. Why the hell did he go off to a leisure activity if he hadn't managed to make a meal for his dc?

SandyCastles · Yesterday 12:18

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 11:56

Most of the responses are pointless in the absence of the nuance which makes the difference in this situation.

many posters have just made up that the father was doing fuck all all afternoon and shouted at the teenager to make dinner as he left.

no one knows if that’s true.

because it’s entirely reasonable for a normally engaged dad who is busy for whatever reason - including a hobby as parents are people too - to say before the little ones dinner time ‘Fred, can you put dinner on, I’m a bit busy today’

and that’s worlds away from the dad not giving a shiny shit about anyone other than himself or even thinking about their dinner.

either could be true in the absence of context from the op.

I do agree with you, but the nuance is already there IMO:

There has been a few changes and I have been very understanding that DH is trying to adjust. However, for f"k sake... I feel like I need to still manage everything and ensure things get done.*

I think that tells us everything about the situation at home from OPs perspective (without PP making things up), to me it sounds like he was busy sorting himself out and just didn't think about the kids at all, or purposely left it knowing OP would take care of it when she got back, or he could pass it on to the 15 year old to sort out when he left, any of those scenarios point to the fact he didn't see it as his 'job' to deal with.

I think him leaving it to her is the most probable which is why OP is so annoyed with him, whatever these changes are he needs to get with the program that whoever is in the house with the kids is the one responsible for those kids.

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 12:22

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 11:56

Most of the responses are pointless in the absence of the nuance which makes the difference in this situation.

many posters have just made up that the father was doing fuck all all afternoon and shouted at the teenager to make dinner as he left.

no one knows if that’s true.

because it’s entirely reasonable for a normally engaged dad who is busy for whatever reason - including a hobby as parents are people too - to say before the little ones dinner time ‘Fred, can you put dinner on, I’m a bit busy today’

and that’s worlds away from the dad not giving a shiny shit about anyone other than himself or even thinking about their dinner.

either could be true in the absence of context from the op.

You don't think that if he'd been busy doing stuff for the family it wouldn't have been mentioned? Really?

ednaclouda · Yesterday 12:22

Playinwithfire · Yesterday 08:21

Last night I get home, it was around 7.30 and my youngest said mummy I'm hungry. I was confused DH had been home since 2pm and sorted HIS stuff and then he headed off to his hobby. I checked to see if they had enough dinner, then the child says we didn't get any dinner! I'm furious...

There has been a few changes and I have been very understanding that DH is trying to adjust. However, for f"*k sake... I feel like I need to still manage everything and ensure things get done. I'm asked a 100 questions daily. An I snapped last night...

I just don't get how you can go off to a hobby knowing that your children still haven't eaten however, you've made sure all the stuff he had to do was priority and very much completed.

His bloody 'hobby' better be more important than feeding his hungry child
what an arse to leave the child hungry
i hope you've stopped this nonsense from him

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 12:24

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:15

It's a reasonable ask of a 15 yo, regardless of what the Dad was doing.

So if dad sat on the sofa from 2pm until 7pm and then went to his hobby for the evening that's OK to ask the teen to do the dinner?
If dad is busy no problem

ednaclouda · Yesterday 12:25

I bet the 15 yr old didn't go hungry
you need to set some strong rules in this household
15nyr old and dh get set tasks

you cant do every single thing

HoppingPavlova · Yesterday 12:26

At first I was skeptical, as frankly this is a sob story our kids would have given at 18yo ‘I wasn’t given any dinner’, yet the cupboard and fridge would have been full of food for them to rectify that 🤨. I used to tell them to contact social services and tell them their woes 🤣.

At 15yo, I’m not too sympathetic. On instances, they just need to fix themselves beans on toast or similar, no harm done and is good for them to do so.

However, on seeing the youngest is 8yo, I am sympathetic. I believe it’s reasonable for the 15yo to sort themselves out, but not to do a meal to feed a range of siblings young in age. Therefore, your DH is a dick and I would have read him the riot act.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · Yesterday 12:27

What a selfish dick. Smacks of I’m alright jack, fuck the rest of you

theemmadilemma · Yesterday 12:29

I swear people here like to misread.

Who's reading the OP and the follow ups and thinking her 15 year old child is saying 'Mummy I'm hungry'? Clearly those are the words of a younger child who is also in the house - her menitoning her youngest and 'they' also confirms multiple children. Some of you would get stuck in a box without instructions on how to get out.

OP he's a cunt. He's parentifying your oldest to make up for lack of parenting. It's not the 15 year olds job to make tea when Daddy has been home for 5 hours and had plenty of time to do, you know, what parents fucking should.

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:30

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 12:09

Jesus 😂

Quite, the bar people have for their children is so ridiculously low. How on earth will they grow up into functional adults if we consider asking a 15 yo to bung a pizza in the oven to feed themselves and their sibling is unreasonable, and that disobedience is OK.

Dad made a reasonable request. Child disobeyed, Mum parented very poorly. She should have expected that the 15 year old would, without complaint, completed the very reasonable task as asked. Instead, she's teaching the 15 year old it's OK to disobey.

15 year olds should routinely be contributing to reasonable, age appropriate tasks, of which 'please cook a quick dinner for yourself and your sibling' is one.

GreyCarpet · Yesterday 12:30

ednaclouda · Yesterday 12:25

I bet the 15 yr old didn't go hungry
you need to set some strong rules in this household
15nyr old and dh get set tasks

you cant do every single thing

She might as well be if she's setting the tasks. It's making it her responsibility still.

I never once had to remind my children's dad to feed them if I was out. I might have asked what they'd eaten but never if they'd eaten.

If I didn't leave explicit instructions, they still got fed. And I think he'd have been rightfully offended if I'd tried to remind him.

.

HairsprayBabe · Yesterday 12:31

@Cosyblankets there is no rule that says you have to be "busy" with something productive to ask your children to do chores. You all live and contribute to the same home in one way or another, especially when they are older. (However in this situation it does sound like the DH is the one severely lacking in contribution)

Teens should not be treated like Cinderella either though. If dad had plenty of time to make dinner before the children were home he should have done it. To me it sounds like he is one hell of a faffer and a procrastinator - who on earth takes 5hrs to "get ready" for a hobby.

GreyCarpet · Yesterday 12:32

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:15

It's a reasonable ask of a 15 yo, regardless of what the Dad was doing.

Given we don't now the exact circumstances, this could be perfectly reasonable.

However, knowing it hadn't been done, it wasn't reasonable of him to go out at 7pm knowing the 8 year old hadn't been fed.

mrsm43s · Yesterday 12:33

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 12:24

So if dad sat on the sofa from 2pm until 7pm and then went to his hobby for the evening that's OK to ask the teen to do the dinner?
If dad is busy no problem

Yes. Obviously not every day. But if Mum or Dad ask that the 15 year old make a simple dinner for themself and their sibling from time to time, for any reason whatsoever, that is perfectly OK.

SandyCastles · Yesterday 12:33

ednaclouda · Yesterday 12:25

I bet the 15 yr old didn't go hungry
you need to set some strong rules in this household
15nyr old and dh get set tasks

you cant do every single thing

15nyr old and dh get set tasks

I feel sad for people being given this advice, 15 year old, absolutely, they do need to learn about what is expected of them, and probably have set tasks to complete as teenagers are selfish fuckers at the best of times.

But no wife should ever have to set her husband the 'task' of feeding their children in her absence.. it just goes to show how useless and selfish some people are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread