Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours complained about Autistic Son

570 replies

NatureandBee · Yesterday 13:20

Just found out that my next door neighbours have complained about my autistic DS. The complaint was related to him shouting in the garden(he’s non verbal and he vocally stims) and how he sometimes has no clothes on in the garden and their grandchildren can see him.

They put in a complaint to my HA and I wish they had spoken to me first. I do understand how loud he can be and I try hard to keep him dressed. The fences are high but they can see into my garden from their bedroom windows.

He’s not out there from morning til night, only in the school holidays and after school for a bit. I also work and he stays with his Dad for part of the week.

I feel so on edge now and feel like I can’t have him in the garden in case they complain again, I’m also a single parent and it makes me feel vulnerable that they have an issue with us.

They are an older couple with an immaculate garden/house. I do understand how they like to enjoy peace and quiet in their garden and obviously they deserve to not be disturbed.

I’m ashamed to say I cried when I was told of the complaint, I’m embarrassed now 🙈

OP posts:
SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:09

BreatheAndFocus · Yesterday 18:42

It is relevant to my point, ie having a disability doesn’t mean you don’t have to comply with the law. Noise can be a statutory nuisance, whether it’s swearing or screaming or whatever. Having autism and/or being a child doesn’t mean you can just make as much noise as you want. The case I linked to specifically mentioned children and that in the case of children the parents were responsible.

She didn’t have a confirmed diagnosis, a specialist hadn’t been able to confirm if the noises were involuntary or not, the main noise complaints where from the middle of the night (not the middle of the afternoon in the garden), and had been offered soundproofing.

It’s not the same.

GlomOfNit · Yesterday 19:13

OP, two things: first of all, even though you've told your utterly charming NDNs that your son is autistic, tell them again. Find a leaflet about severe autism (actually I'm not sure I've ever seen such a thing!) or explain how it impacts him every minute of his day. And yours. Print off an NHS page on autism and non-verbal children. Does he also have learning disabilities? Print something off on that too. Go round (while he's at school?) with a BIG smile on your face and politely give them this information into their hands. Explain briefly that you'd like them to know a little more about your son. Explain that the very nature of a disability means he cannot help any of this. Still smiling, tell them that he has a right to enjoy his garden as they do theirs.

Ok, then they can't say 'oh but we didn't know'. They can't say 'but my cousin's daughter's friend's son is autistic and he's really good at maths and talks the hind leg off a donkey'. Some people aren't educated about autism/LDs at the severe end of the spectrum. Some people still prefer to tell themselves that it's ultimately down to 'bad parenting'.

The other thing is: grow a thicker skin. He's ten so you already know you need to, but do try. You've got a LOT on your plate and you need to filter out the wankers.

If they persist in this, if they continue to fail to understand the nature of disability and autism and that they really should walk a mile in your shoes first, then tell the HA that they're being discriminatory.

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:13

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 19:09

It got to be some kind of shout or scream to be loud enough for even op to agree loud which is likely quieter than how her neighbours feel it is.

Though I think a lot of comments including mine are not directed directly at the op but more of the issues of noise from neighbours.

There is a difference between a loud noise and shouting.

As an example, our son doesn’t have a shout type stim. He makes a humming noise, but louder. With the occasional “gagagaga” and what we call birdies (putting his fingers together and flapping his arms).

It wouldn’t sound like shouting, screeching or screaming to anyone. Even someone who doesn’t appreciate the noise.

My point is that I think some people are assuming the noise must be offensive or screechy, because he’s autistic so as you say it “must be,” rather than assuming the neighbour might be a miserable cow.

Vinvertebrate · Yesterday 19:13

TwinklySquid · Yesterday 18:56

Where do you draw the line then on behaviour? What is okay because someone is disabled?

I would say anything involuntary is very much tough shit.

What can the OP sensibly do that she is not already doing?

If nothing, they're just going to have to buy earplugs or a detached house. Nothing to be done.

GlomOfNit · Yesterday 19:15

OhMyGodSusan · Yesterday 13:42

To be honest he needs to be wearing clothes when outside not being naked. That is a valid complaint.

Don't be silly Susan, he's ten.

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 19:15

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:13

There is a difference between a loud noise and shouting.

As an example, our son doesn’t have a shout type stim. He makes a humming noise, but louder. With the occasional “gagagaga” and what we call birdies (putting his fingers together and flapping his arms).

It wouldn’t sound like shouting, screeching or screaming to anyone. Even someone who doesn’t appreciate the noise.

My point is that I think some people are assuming the noise must be offensive or screechy, because he’s autistic so as you say it “must be,” rather than assuming the neighbour might be a miserable cow.

If it’s too loud it’s going to become annoying eventually regardless of what it is though.

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:17

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 19:15

If it’s too loud it’s going to become annoying eventually regardless of what it is though.

That’s a real shame.

Kids play in gardens. Even autistic ones.

If someone has a general issue with kids playing in gardens, might I suggest a field. Or the moon.

If they have issue with autistic kids specifically playing in gardens, I’d suggest fucking off.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:18

godmum56 · Yesterday 15:57

In a garden with tall fences? By which i mean fences tall enough for children not to see over? I am not ND but anyone who comments on what I wear in my own fenced garden can do one.

I just think it's bad practice in general to let a growing kid think that it's ok to be nude outside. It could set up problems in the future. That's actually as much from his point of view as anyone else's. I don't really side with these neighbours.

BreatheAndFocus · Yesterday 19:19

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:09

She didn’t have a confirmed diagnosis, a specialist hadn’t been able to confirm if the noises were involuntary or not, the main noise complaints where from the middle of the night (not the middle of the afternoon in the garden), and had been offered soundproofing.

It’s not the same.

I didn’t say it was the same. I was responding to someone who said having a disability trumped other people’s rights. It doesn’t.

godmum56 · Yesterday 19:22

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:18

I just think it's bad practice in general to let a growing kid think that it's ok to be nude outside. It could set up problems in the future. That's actually as much from his point of view as anyone else's. I don't really side with these neighbours.

not that easy when the child is autistic.

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 19:22

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:17

That’s a real shame.

Kids play in gardens. Even autistic ones.

If someone has a general issue with kids playing in gardens, might I suggest a field. Or the moon.

If they have issue with autistic kids specifically playing in gardens, I’d suggest fucking off.

So you don’t ever find noises annoying?

Lets be serious most people are understanding but everyone has their limits.

A cockerel every morning at 6am is annoying but unless it’s an arsehole cockerel it’s not constantly going off all day.
A dog barking for 5 minutes regularly is annoying.
A twat bag revving his car or bike is annoying. A basket ball bouncing for ages regularly is annoying.
Squeaky trampoline springs can be annoying. A neighbour who bbqs daily could be seen as annoying.

Most decent people try to limit annoying their neighbour while still enjoying their space. Only wankers go oh well fuck them they can move nothing I can do.

Maybe the noise makers and other annoying people should live in the middle of nowhere if they want to be free to make as much noise as they want. It goes both ways.

If you want understanding you also have to be understanding.

Tessgirl · Yesterday 19:24

DoubleBusy2026 · Yesterday 13:58

I think we all understand that but a compromise needs to be made as the neighbours still have a right to peaceful enjoyment of their own property. I would absolutely sympathise with a child who has a disability but that doesn’t out trump or completely remove everyone else’s rights to peaceful enjoyment of their homes.

You seem to think the noises and nakedness are something the op can control. Or do you think he just be locked up inside all the time?

AnonyMumAuDHD · Yesterday 19:24

Timeforachange26 · Yesterday 17:57

How do you know he will mature out of it?

And I wouldn't let any child of mine play naked in summer Be burned to shreds

Edited

I dunno - parenting ( 2 SEN), foster parenting, child minding approx40 kids, teaching, Guide/scout leading, district commissioner with the safeguarding of 3000 kids under my charge, I could go on. Lots of characters, lots of wild ones, lots of SEN ones, lots from broken families doing all sorts … none of them were stripping off naked or sexual deviants by the age off 15.

The lad was playing in a pool in his garden where both he and his mother were unaware that he was being observed or that this was causing distress to anyone else. Had she known, I am sure she would have found a solution. And I am sure she will now find other methods to restrict the behaviour, perhaps using some of the back-zipped playsuits PP have suggested. OP will find a way now she is aware there is an issue.

The fact that you question whether he will grow out of it or can be guided to behave differently with support is rather ableist, isn’t it? Are you OP’s neighbour, perchance? Because you should be ashamed of yourself.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:25

godmum56 · Yesterday 19:22

not that easy when the child is autistic.

I hear that and I actually feel for the OP. I just think that it is important to be clear about when nudity is appropriate and when it isn't. I'm talking more from a safeguarding perspective than from an etiquette perspective. The neighbours sound like a pain (and I have no sympathy with them whatsoever about the noise) but I think they kind of have a point about the nudity. JMO.

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:29

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 19:22

So you don’t ever find noises annoying?

Lets be serious most people are understanding but everyone has their limits.

A cockerel every morning at 6am is annoying but unless it’s an arsehole cockerel it’s not constantly going off all day.
A dog barking for 5 minutes regularly is annoying.
A twat bag revving his car or bike is annoying. A basket ball bouncing for ages regularly is annoying.
Squeaky trampoline springs can be annoying. A neighbour who bbqs daily could be seen as annoying.

Most decent people try to limit annoying their neighbour while still enjoying their space. Only wankers go oh well fuck them they can move nothing I can do.

Maybe the noise makers and other annoying people should live in the middle of nowhere if they want to be free to make as much noise as they want. It goes both ways.

If you want understanding you also have to be understanding.

If someone came to you and said “Bob’s kids playing in their paddling pool and their noise doesn’t bother me, but when your child specifically plays out, and makes the relevant noises they do, that really gets under my skin” …

You’re telling me you wouldn’t tell them to get fucked and stop singling your kid out when Bob’s are apparently fine?

Or would you just apologise for not having kids like Bob’s, and for their very existence, and lock them in a cupboard out of the way?

x2boys · Yesterday 19:30

ExtraHotDoubleShot · Yesterday 18:51

Yes I 100% acknowledge autistic kids need to live somewhere and unless their parents are millionaires, that ‘somewhere’ will be an ordinary house with close neighbours. But I’m also disabled and regularly awake with that at night so I’m always tired, constant noise next door would drive me over the edge and make me deeply shitty.

In OP’s shoes I would attempt to buy a small rural bungalow which you can usually get fairly cheaply (in this part of the country anyway), the type down a track off a main road.

Yes because its just that simple to uproot your entire family and take yourself away from all the services that might be helping your child to buy a cheap rural bungalow 🙄

worldshottestmom · Yesterday 19:31

Holidayhooha · Yesterday 19:00

OP wished they’d spoken up her first; perhaps they were fearful of meeting this level of aggression and hostility in response. (Although to be fair the OP sounds much more reasonable and civilized).

That's honestly never the case unless it's regarding addressing people that are obviously aggressive (loud music, alcohol, drugs, parties til early hours, you get the idea).

They didn't address her because:

a.) They know they're being ridiculous,
b.) They know there's not much they can expect her to actually do to change anything,
c.) They're spineless cowards and thought that going through the LHA would have them kick her and her vulnerable son out, for him having autism. Unsurprisingly, that did not and will not happen.

It's really annoying tbh that so many people in the world say they're accepting and supportive of those with additional needs, until they see those conditions in real life and then they're like, ew wtf get it away from me I'm reporting them for having additional needs. Tragic really.

NatureandBee · Yesterday 19:32

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:06

Can I just point out, I’ve read through OPs posts and absolutely nowhere does she mention screaming, or screeching, high pitched or otherwise.

She has said he stims, and it can be loud, but hasn’t said it’s screaming or screeching. She refers to the complaint being about shouting in her OP, but then clarifies that he’s not shouting, he’s happily stimming.

Posters who are referring to that have somehow made that up themselves, and I would question why that is.

It’s loud but not high pitched, it’s actually a very low pitched AAAAGGH noise - my mum once commented on the phone and asked me was there a motorbike outside…it was my son 🙈

OP posts:
SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:33

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:25

I hear that and I actually feel for the OP. I just think that it is important to be clear about when nudity is appropriate and when it isn't. I'm talking more from a safeguarding perspective than from an etiquette perspective. The neighbours sound like a pain (and I have no sympathy with them whatsoever about the noise) but I think they kind of have a point about the nudity. JMO.

The issue is likely to be the specific circumstances.

My son understands that he should keep his clothes on in public. In his home comfort, he sees absolutely no need to because that’s his environment.

The garden isn’t public as far as he’s concerned, it’s within the confines of his space, where he can take his tshirt off because it’s his house. Stepping into the garden doesn’t change that, because that’s still home.

Which also explains why OP has said he doesn’t do it at school, or as regularly, because that’s not his space.

dcadmamagain · Yesterday 19:33

A big hug - you are doing your best . He’s entitled to use his own garden. I woukd try and teach him to keep pants on but then if they’re looking from their top windows that’s not your problem!

try not to worry

ExtraHotDoubleShot · Yesterday 19:34

x2boys · Yesterday 19:30

Yes because its just that simple to uproot your entire family and take yourself away from all the services that might be helping your child to buy a cheap rural bungalow 🙄

I know I was just saying what I would make happen if possible. It sounds super stressful for OP too, she has not only the noise to contend with but the neighbour disapproval.

worldshottestmom · Yesterday 19:34

x2boys · Yesterday 19:30

Yes because its just that simple to uproot your entire family and take yourself away from all the services that might be helping your child to buy a cheap rural bungalow 🙄

Brb going to buy a ""cheap""" rural bungalow away from kids schools, my job, my family and friends, with my unlimited amount of money. Why didn't I think of this sooner!

ExtraHotDoubleShot · Yesterday 19:35

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:33

The issue is likely to be the specific circumstances.

My son understands that he should keep his clothes on in public. In his home comfort, he sees absolutely no need to because that’s his environment.

The garden isn’t public as far as he’s concerned, it’s within the confines of his space, where he can take his tshirt off because it’s his house. Stepping into the garden doesn’t change that, because that’s still home.

Which also explains why OP has said he doesn’t do it at school, or as regularly, because that’s not his space.

Yes but he’ll be a grown man and then he can’t just wander around naked where kids might see him. Come on, be sensible.

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:35

NatureandBee · Yesterday 19:32

It’s loud but not high pitched, it’s actually a very low pitched AAAAGGH noise - my mum once commented on the phone and asked me was there a motorbike outside…it was my son 🙈

Ours is more an “uuuuuugghh” sound, they should start a band.

pavillion1 · Yesterday 19:35

10 ??? Regardless of anything else he needs to be wearing clothes if outside