Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they could have/should have brought something

376 replies

BurnoutGP · 10/10/2026 20:46

I am in hospital after major (planned surgery). DD1 age 25 will be looking after me (she lives at home for a small rent that cover everything). She has had to take some time off work (unpaid).
I am fiercely independent and have brought in my own squash/snacks etc. The 2 other people in my room have had visitors all day bringing lovely fresh fruit/sweets/drinks etc. DD1 visited this evening bringing my stepmother (very close ben in my life since I was 14. Father died few years ago)
They came empty handed. There is a lovely M+S in the concourse of the hospital they would have walked past it when they came in. But hey ho. Except DD1 started on my bag of snacks eating 2 without even asking. So I very sarcastically told them off and said not only did you not bring me even a M+S fruit snack you're now eating the snacks I bought in. Im pretty immobile.
They then said oh do you want us to go get you something. I said well it really defeats the purposes if you have to be told. And it would have been almost closed.
AIBU to be hurt and disappointed and a spoilt brat
IANBU they should have brought something.
DD1 is usually pretty good but can be a bit self absorbed and they are very used to me being super capable and doing everything. I am now a bit worried what her "looking after" is going to look like....

OP posts:
iamnotalemon · 11/10/2026 07:40

justaddittothelist · 11/10/2026 07:04

Op, I totally understand where you are coming from. The previous posters who say they wouldn't bring anything unless asked just blows my mind.

I was visiting a relative last month over the course of a week. Every visit I brought a small selection of nice things to cheer him up like his favourite sweets, a cookie etc. I thought that this was normal practice like when you go to a party you take a gift, or when you are invited for dinner you bring wine (or similar)

Just overall thoughtfulness/care for others. It really seems to be lacking in the majority of the posters on this thread!

I hope you are feeling better soon

That’s so lovely of you and I do agree that so many people are selfish and rude nowadays.

PollyBell · 11/10/2026 07:40

JayJayj · 11/10/2026 07:32

When my mum was in hospital we just asked if there was anything she wanted us to bring. She won’t just want some random foods or snacks. I might have picked up a magazine while getting what she wants but she had her iPad that she use to read on.

Same as when I am in, I just ask people what I want them to bring it just seems less game playing

LittleGungHo · 11/10/2026 07:41

BurnoutGP · 10/10/2026 20:51

I asked for some cold squash and my pillow. You dont ask for treats or gifts. It just felt quite stark compared to the other visitors. And maybe that reflects me not having a partner and depending on my child (albeit) and adult to look after me.
But I wouldn't say please bring my some nice treats as a gift to cheer me up ?

Or they had text and asked for things to be brought in?

Your response was childish/bratish. They came to see you and care about your health.

Somewherenorthofhere · 11/10/2026 07:44

JustWalnut · 10/10/2026 20:48

If you wanted them to bring something in you should have asked.

My mum has had several ops over the last few years. She always gives me a list for when I visit. I wouldn't take food in just because.

Edited

Agree. When someone isnin hospital they arent their usual self due to pain or grogginess etc . The first few times mum was in i would take her usual favourites without being asked.... and theyd go off or be left uneaten, melted weeks later in heatwave

Now we are both more experienced, she just tells me if she wants something.

LakelandHiker · 11/10/2026 07:45

My DH recently had major (unplanned) surgery. I barely left his side during visiting hours and didn't take him food the first couple of days because, well, I didn't really know if you could. I knew he was being fed though. Eventually I took him cups of tea but he was so unwell he couldn't eat much.

It's a weird thing to be mad about, at least they showed up for you.

Boomer55 · 11/10/2026 07:45

Many wards now don’t allow flowers in there, so I wouldn’t take flowers.

When my DH was in hospital, a lot, I just used to phone and ask, before visiting, if he needed anything else - but food, treats etc often went to waste.

The visits really mean more than what is bought in.

Tharealkate · 11/10/2026 07:56

USaYwHatNow · 11/10/2026 00:18

I think there's some posters here who come from very sad and unfeeling families OP, or maybe we're the exception to the rule because whenever myself and my sibling have been in hospital either planned or unplanned, our parents, other family members and friends have always brought a treat in, or something non edible to cheer us up, unprompted, in addition to the 'do you need anything practical' list.

Previously this may have been a magazine or I even had a photo of the family pet brought in at one point!

In turn, I have had a few friends end up in hospital and have done the same and would do for anyone.

When both my children were born, friends and family arrived with treats and gifts and practical assistance whilst still in hospital.

To be honest, I learnt that kindness and generosity from a young age from my parents.

Threads like this, and their responses from other posters only serve to remind me how unfortunate some people are to have zero support and how fortunate I am to have such generous, kind and supportive family members and friends, of which we seem to be in the minority, sadly!

So no I don't think you're unreasonable but equally if this behaviour isn't modelled by you in respect to your child, or you never witnessed it from your step parent then I'm not surprised they haven't bothered.

Threads like this, and their responses from other posters only serve to remind me how unfortunate some people are to have zero support and how fortunate I am to have such generous, kind and supportive family members and friends, of which we seem to be in the minority, sadly!

I’ve said I understand why Op felt a bit disappointed but I think this post is OTT in the context of this thread.

I mean are you suggesting OP or anyone who have family and friends visit have “no support” or are not kind just because they don’t bring gifts to a hospital ? That sounds very materialistic and narrow minded to me.
In OP’s case her daughter taking unpaid leave and visiting IS a massive support and very kind.

Surely the visit is the main thing and bringing a gift is surely just a bonus? And also people can show their kindness in various ways. They can be generous with their time and effort. Personally I definitely value presence over presents.

Wetcoatsandmudagain · 11/10/2026 08:54

SquirrelGG · 11/10/2026 01:35

If anyone brought all that in to me while I would of course be grateful that they thought of me I would secretly be grumpy about having things all over a small space and then having to cart it all home again. Hospitals generally have books, magazines and blankets surely and I'm quite capable of doing without hand cream and wet wipes. I know my loved ones cared about me and valued me, I don't need them to clutter up my hospital space to prove it.

Each and everyone to their own. I bring back books and magazines that are read etc. majority of my visits are in HDU or intensive care and then wards so they have been unable to do much for themselves. Feedback has always been positive

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 09:16

Anyahyacinth · 10/10/2026 23:04

No it isn't as is documented by my life experience and My Hospital Plate daily posts naming hospitals in the UK on Facebook

I see, every hospital I’ve interacted with in the last two years has had very good food. I’m sorry your experience has been different.

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 09:19

iamnotalemon · 11/10/2026 07:39

I totally get you OP. I had major surgery recently and felt the same - no visitors or any support but my circumstances are different - and it’s crap.

No visitors is a very different scenario to visitors who have taken unpaid leave to visit and then care for you who just didn’t bring in a pack of chocolate with them.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 11/10/2026 09:24

I never visited my DM without a parcel of some sort. Usually sandwiches as she wasn’t keen on hospital food.
I hope your recovery is smooth. Keep things in perspective. You’ll be feeling sensitive after the surgery. Best of luck.

KTMeetsTheRsUptown · 11/10/2026 09:48

You say the shop was almost closed, so it was still open...probably because you've always been independent they just brought what you asked for but
at least they came to visit you... I would have just told them what to get me, if I wanted snacks. Hope you feel better soon 💐

Imseriouslyyouguys · 11/10/2026 10:02

Sunbringer · 10/10/2026 23:00

I think you’re being a bit sensitive. It was a planned surgery so I’d have assumed you’d planned for it and that the hospital feeds you enough food to prevent you being hungry. What are you all doing that you require reams of snacks on top of 3 meals and two puddings a day?

Flowers would’ve been nice.

”the hospital feeds you enough food to prevent you being hungry”

Haha, you wouldn’t be saying this if you’d been an inpatient recently.

Shesafancyflapjack · 11/10/2026 10:02

OP, what a nasty and cold response you’ve had here. I absolutely understand why you felt hurt. You are alone, scared and vulnerable in hospital and the people who should show you unconditional and spontaneous kindness did not. You have every right to your feelings and some of the replies you’ve had are borderline sociopathic.

Imseriouslyyouguys · 11/10/2026 10:03

Sunbringer · 10/10/2026 23:03

UK hospital food is pretty good nowadays

It really, really isn’t. I can testify from as recently as a few days ago.

CuteHANDBAG · 11/10/2026 10:19

I think it would have been nice for them to bring something but if I were you I would have just asked.

iamnotalemon · 11/10/2026 10:27

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 09:19

No visitors is a very different scenario to visitors who have taken unpaid leave to visit and then care for you who just didn’t bring in a pack of chocolate with them.

True. At this point I would have been happy to see anyone, regardless of if they had come empty handed or not.

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 10:32

Imseriouslyyouguys · 11/10/2026 10:03

It really, really isn’t. I can testify from as recently as a few days ago.

Seems it varies by trust.

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 10:33

Shesafancyflapjack · 11/10/2026 10:02

OP, what a nasty and cold response you’ve had here. I absolutely understand why you felt hurt. You are alone, scared and vulnerable in hospital and the people who should show you unconditional and spontaneous kindness did not. You have every right to your feelings and some of the replies you’ve had are borderline sociopathic.

Why would she be scared? She’s an adult on a safe ward with nurses caring for her, visitors and it was a scheduled surgery. Would you really be shivering in terror at that?

And they did show her unconditional love by coming to spend time with her… what’s conditional is OPs love apparently, and yours, which requires presents.

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 10:35

Imseriouslyyouguys · 11/10/2026 10:02

”the hospital feeds you enough food to prevent you being hungry”

Haha, you wouldn’t be saying this if you’d been an inpatient recently.

My mother in law was inpatient for 10 weeks this year. She had a big tray of food three times a day with a main, dessert, side and fruit. Then at 4pm biscuits and tea or hot chocolate. It was far more than she’d eat in a day on the outside. And she had a snack menu she could ask for any time of day with fruit, yoghurt, cake bars etc.

It seems my local hospital is ahead of the curve but she was absolutely well fed and turned away some of our offers of extra food.

Anonymouseposter · 11/10/2026 10:42

Imseriouslyyouguys · 11/10/2026 10:02

”the hospital feeds you enough food to prevent you being hungry”

Haha, you wouldn’t be saying this if you’d been an inpatient recently.

I have had a few operations. I wouldn’t call them major but I had an abdominal hysterectomy and part of a lung removed. To be honest for the first couple of days afterwards I didn’t want much to eat and was quite sleepy, then I was home after 4 days ( agreed to go home and come back to have the stitches out). Many hospital admissions don’t give you time to be over worried about the food. I’m also wondering what care OP will need. It was nice to have meals made but I could have made a sandwich if necessary. I know some operations are worse and some people have a diagnosis that requires more emotional support but all that “it’s too late if I have to tell you “ business is annoying.

Tharealkate · 11/10/2026 10:42

Sunbringer · 11/10/2026 09:19

No visitors is a very different scenario to visitors who have taken unpaid leave to visit and then care for you who just didn’t bring in a pack of chocolate with them.

Yeah I feel a few people are confusing two issues.

Having no visitors and having visitors come with no presents are completely different scenarios.

Sparkletastic · 11/10/2026 10:43

Your daughter sounds like a good girl. Thoughtless of step mum though.

Excellentsausages · 11/10/2026 10:57

SquirrelGG · 11/10/2026 01:35

If anyone brought all that in to me while I would of course be grateful that they thought of me I would secretly be grumpy about having things all over a small space and then having to cart it all home again. Hospitals generally have books, magazines and blankets surely and I'm quite capable of doing without hand cream and wet wipes. I know my loved ones cared about me and valued me, I don't need them to clutter up my hospital space to prove it.

I've had a few hospital stays in the past few years and none of the hospitals have provided books or magazines! I'd say magazines are an ideal hospital visiting present.

The blankets are also not great in hospital, I can definitely see why people bring extra blankets and pillows.

SixtySomething · 11/10/2026 10:58

PollyBell · 11/10/2026 01:29

And who it so blame for that? If you expect people to be physic and want to go all passive agreessive the other people are not to blame

Passive aggressive? I don’t think so. She just wants her feelings and invalid situation noticed. I’ve been in hospital and it’s natural to compare yourself to the patients in the other beds. It’s what people do. I find it very odd to want to name call someone for having feelings tbh.